Need Advice on .357 mag revolver

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dog Wonder

Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2008
Messages
41
Location
East Coast
I am considering buying a .357 mag revolver to be used by my wife & myself for home protection. We both have experience shooting semi-auto's but like the reliability of the revolver. My hands are meduim size & my wifes are small(but she is fairly strong). My concerns or questions are
(1) how is the felt recoil
(2) what model .357 mag handgun would you
recommend?
(3) what barrel lenght would you suggest using
on your recommended .357 mag handgun?
(4) any other suggestions you have on the .357
mag handgun


P.S. A shooter at our local range suggested my wife & I look at the Ruger SP- 101-.357mag revolver--any thoughts you have on this handgun/

Thank-You for your time & attention to my thread
Happy New Year! 2009!
 
For home defense only, I would say you could do far worse than to get a 4" GP100. They are well made revolvers at a reasonable price. I personally don't have a problem carrying a revolver of that size, but some do. For carrying many prefer the SP101 and a 3" is a very good length in that. I would buy either before a new Smith & Wesson.

You really can't go wrong with a pre-lock Smith & Wesson either. A 4" 66 or 686 can be found at a reasonable price usually. My personal pick for an all around great revolver is a 4" Model 28. It's a big frame so it can make carrying difficult for some, but it tames the recoil big time and its a joy to shoot.

Barrel length is really up to you and how you feel with the revolver in hand. I have revolvers in 3,4,5, and 6 inches. My favorite is the 5 inch, but I think the 4" is better for concealed carry.

.357 mag is a great caliber choice because you can go from mild to hot depending on your whim!
 
Dog Wonder, For the home 4" barrel, with 38+P ammo in it. As far as to what name brand, S&W is the way to go. orchidhunter
 
First off I would reconsider using magnum ammo. The blast and sound from a 357 indoors would be quite deafening. If you must have a 357 revolver please use 38 Spec +P ammo, it is much easier all the way around. As far as guns any good S&W K or L frame with a 4 inch barrel should do the trick. A Ruger of comparable size will also work.
 
I agree shooting .357 Magnum ammo in a dark confined space like a bedroom or hallway at night wouldn't be a pleasant experiance. It would be like a "flashbang" going off. I also keep my home SD revolver loaded with .38 Special +P ammo.

As for which revolver, I would also agree a 4" S&W Model 686 or 4" Ruger GP-100 would be best. Both will serve you well and last a lifetime. I wouldn't worry too much about how the gun feels in your hand since there are so many different grips available out there. You can custom fit your revolver to your hand these days and make if feel just right.
 
P.S. A shooter at our local range suggested my wife & I look at the Ruger SP- 101-.357mag revolver--any thoughts you have on this handgun/
Click to expand...

I have an SP101. It's a good little gun but a tad small for HD only. I agree with others that for purely Home Defense I'd go with a 4" barrel gun with fixed sights. My preference would be towards S&W but that's just my preference. In current model something like a S&W Model 619.

As far as recoil it's stout shooting magnums out of the SP101. Out of my 6" 586 recoil is less but still quite noticeable - .357 mag is a potent round. Now the .38+P is much lighter recoiling even in the small gun.

You mention experience with auto loaders. Have you both shot revolvers? The long heavy trigger pull is quite different than a semi auto in SA mode. I personally don't shoot revolvers as accurately but in fairness I probably don't practice enough with them.

Any chance of renting?
 
You can't go wrong with a Ruger Gp100/Security Six, or older S&W K/L frame. My first handgun was a old service revolver S&W Model 19 with 4" barrel. Plenty for home defense loaded with +p .38 that should be very easy for your wife to handle.

If you have the budget and can find one the Colt Python.
 
1. Felt recoil is subjective and there are many factors such as ammunition used, weight of firearm, type of grips, etc. The nice part about a 357 is you can start with 38 wadcutters and work your way up the power level std 38s, +P, full magnums.

2. A GP100 or L frame S&W. They both heavier than a K frame and will absorb recoil better than a K or J frame sized gun. you seem to be concerned about recoil.

3. 4" is probably the best all around.

4. A 4" 357 is about the best all around handgun you can have.
 
I agree with all other recommendations on

revolvers to buy. I personally favor S&W, but I have also had some nice Rugers in the past.

I also agree that full house .357 loads are going to be both deafening and may run the risk of overpenetrating (through walls, doors, etc). Only you know your house layout and whether there is any chance of a bullet going somewhere you cannot have it go (like into a neighbor's house).

If the revolver is strictly for in the house and not for concelament, I would recommend at least a 3" barrel and at most a 6" barrel. Any shorter than 3" and you will have a lot more muzzle blast. Longer than 6" and the gun might start to feel like it's in the way and not easy to control.

If you can find some calm 357 loads, that would be your best bet, otherwise, consider using 38 Special +P loads. If you do get a 357 and shoot +P loads, they will not feel like they are kicking as much as 357 loads.

Different frips also make a huge difference. I always used Pachmayr grips (without the finger grooves) on all my 357's and 44 magnums. They take the snap out of those powerful loads so you can shoot them all day (once you are used to the gun and loads). Hogue also makes excellent grips.
 
I agree with all other recommendations on

revolvers to buy. I personally favor S&W, but I have also had some nice Rugers in the past.

I also agree that full house .357 loads are going to be both deafening and may run the risk of overpenetrating (through walls, doors, etc). Only you know your house layout and whether there is any chance of a bullet going somewhere you cannot have it go (like into a neighbor's house).

If the revolver is strictly for in the house and not for concelament, I would recommend at least a 3" barrel and at most a 6" barrel. Any shorter than 3" and you will have a lot more muzzle blast. Longer than 6" and the gun might start to feel like it's in the way and not easy to control.

If you can find some calm 357 loads, that would be your best bet, otherwise, consider using 38 Special +P loads. If you do get a 357 and shoot +P loads, they will not feel like they are kicking as much as 357 loads.

Different grips also make a huge difference. I always used Pachmayr grips (without the finger grooves) on all my 357's and 44 magnums. They take the snap out of those powerful loads so you can shoot them all day (once you are used to the gun and loads). Hogue also makes excellent grips.
 
I agree with all other recommendations on

revolvers to buy. I personally favor S&W, but I have also had some nice Rugers in the past.

I also agree that full house .357 loads are going to be both deafening and may run the risk of overpenetrating (through walls, doors, etc). Only you know your house layout and whether there is any chance of a bullet going somewhere you cannot have it go (like into a neighbor's house).

If the revolver is strictly for in the house and not for concelament, I would recommend at least a 3" barrel and at most a 6" barrel. Any shorter than 3" and you will have a lot more muzzle blast. Longer than 6" and the gun might start to feel like it's in the way and not easy to control.

If you can find some calm 357 loads, that would be your best bet, otherwise, consider using 38 Special +P loads. If you do get a 357 and shoot +P loads, they will not feel like they are kicking as much as 357 loads.

Different grips also make a huge difference. I always used Pachmayr grips (without the finger grooves) on all my 357's and 44 magnums. They take the snap out of those powerful loads so you can shoot them all day (once you are used to the gun and loads). Hogue also makes excellent grips.
 
I agree with all other recommendations on

revolvers to buy. I personally favor S&W, but I have also had some nice Rugers in the past.

I also agree that full house .357 loads are going to be both deafening and may run the risk of overpenetrating (through walls, doors, etc). Only you know your house layout and whether there is any chance of a bullet going somewhere you cannot have it go (like into a neighbor's house).

If the revolver is strictly for in the house and not for concelament, I would recommend at least a 3" barrel and at most a 6" barrel. Any shorter than 3" and you will have a lot more muzzle blast. Longer than 6" and the gun might start to feel like it's in the way and not easy to control.

If you can find some calm 357 loads, that would be your best bet, otherwise, consider using 38 Special +P loads. If you do get a 357 and shoot +P loads, they will not feel like they are kicking as much as 357 loads.

Different grips also make a huge difference. I always used Pachmayr grips (without the finger grooves) on all my 357's and 44 magnums. They take the snap out of those powerful loads so you can shoot them all day (once you are used to the gun and loads). Hogue also makes excellent grips.
 
I agree with all other recommendations on revolvers to buy. I personally favor S&W, but I have also had some nice Rugers in the past.

I also agree that full house .357 loads are going to be both deafening and may run the risk of overpenetrating (through walls, doors, etc). Only you know your house layout and whether there is any chance of a bullet going somewhere you cannot have it go (like into a neighbor's house).

If the revolver is strictly for in the house and not for concelament, I would recommend at least a 3" barrel and at most a 6" barrel. Any shorter than 3" and you will have a lot more muzzle blast. Longer than 6" and the gun might start to feel like it's in the way and not easy to control.

If you can find some calm 357 loads, that would be your best bet, otherwise, consider using 38 Special +P loads. If you do get a 357 and shoot +P loads, they will not feel like they are kicking as much as 357 loads.

Different grips also make a huge difference. I always used Pachmayr grips (without the finger grooves) on all my 357's and 44 magnums. They take the snap out of those powerful loads so you can shoot them all day (once you are used to the gun and loads). Hogue also makes excellent grips.
 
No post, no post, no post, no post, then a bunch of them all at once!
I give up!
:banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead:
 
Don't feel bad Inspector, this has happned to me also. I saw the post where you asked about this. It's not just you. orchidhunter
 
This was my first choice, I recommend it as yours.

69L.jpg


Ruger New Model Blackhawk Convertible .357mag / 9mm
4 5/8" barrel
 
For home defense, if you haven't got your heart set on a .357 magnum, you might also consider .45ACP. You can buy any number of good autos in the caliber, but also some very fine revolvers. In terms of stopping power, it gives very little, if anything away to the .357, and as a low pressure round, has considerably less muzzle blast and flash. It's also far less likely to overpentrate, and there are any number of superb loads out there for it.
 
I'd recommend the Ruger GP100... I own one.. but don't put out the taurus... I have a model 65 taurus that out shoots the Ruger, and any Smith I've ever shot... The taurus is well made and will last a lifetime as well...



357-5.gif
 
My 357 is a Taurus stainless and no complaints. The $$$s saved on the purchase price went for ammo. Taurus makes a fine gun and stands behind them as well as any other maker. I keep it in a high ride form fitted soft leather holster and it comes out easily/quickly. It is my "official" hiking partner and hunting partner. A good thing about a 357 is that you can interchange 38 special ammo. Later and hope you find a great one, wc
 
Almost any .357 with a 4 or 6 inch barrel with do, but I'd prefer a 4" of HD use. In your home I'll bet the longest space between hall way and rooms is 25- 30 feet. If you were outdoors I'd strictly recommend a 6". You can change the grips on any gun to fit your needs, and get a few speed loaders also. Don't confuse heavy duty hunting loads with home defense loads. The hunting loads are hard core, but the HD loads like the S&W 110 gr are easy to use. After the first few rounds the recoil becomes much less scary.

I would however stick to Ruger gp100 (my favorite) or S&W or colt. Stay far away from Taurus. I'd never buy another Taurus again.
 
For a medium and small hand, I'd say you might both shoot an SP101 or J-frame smith well enough.

My thoughts on the SP101- I like their size and think that 5 of 357 or 6 of 327 is plenty enough for HD use. I don't have one because my hands are too large for the gripframe.

I do have a 357 Mag revolver for home defense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

D
  • Locked
Looking to buy quality 357 magnum revolver
2 3
Replies
52
Views
4K
BCRider
BCRider
Z
  • Locked
.357 Magnum Revolvers
2 3
Replies
53
Views
5K
cbsbyte
C
Piotr Fita
  • Locked
Pistol scope for .357 mag
Replies
15
Views
3K
Varminterror
Varminterror
Y
  • Locked
choosing a .357 magnum
2
Replies
28
Views
3K
JohnK
J
S
  • Locked
Ruger Security Six 357 Mag
Replies
0
Views
472
smokinjim
S
Back
Top