Not Thrilled With Uberti Right Now

Status
Not open for further replies.

Foto Joe

Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2010
Messages
1,378
Location
Cody, WY
My long awaited Uberti Schofield Russian finally got picked up in the last week or so. Before making the deal I failed to ensure that I could even get 44 Russian brass and almost hit the wall on ever getting to shoot it for that very reason. Fortunately I did find some and got it shipped in a few days ago.

With Black Dawge bullets from Powder Inc and 23gr of Swiss we were off and running right?? Wrong!!!

Given the fact that this is a factory new gun, I took it on good faith that somebody in Italy had the sense to at least drop some brass in this thing and rotate the cylinder, obviously not and niether did I.

Anyway, I got a box of 50 Black Powder cartridges loaded up and headed out to the desert with a CB pistol as well for some smoke and experimentation with the beloved Schofield. Unfortunately the love affair lasted right about until I loaded the cylinder with brandy spankin' new brass and closed it. It turns out, the cylinder won't rotate with the gun loaded, period.

Here's what I've figured out so far. On the recoil shield of the Russian in the area where the firing pin protrudes through to strike the primer, there is what I call a "Doubler". This is an area of the recoil shield that is elevated slightly, ostensibly I believe to hold the brass tight into the cylinder at the point in rotation where the firing pin strikes it. The "Doubler" is just a few thousandths thick and is shapped in a rectangular pie shape, dimishing as it gets closer to where the arbor would be on a Colt. The "Doubler" itself extends upward and all the way to the top of the tangs which hold the closing lock of the top break.

This "Doubler" obviously serves an engineered purpose, but the unintended consequence is that the head of the cartridges are too thick to pass between the "Doubler" and the cylinder. At first I blamed the "Top Brass" brand of brass that I had gotten but, after posting on the Reloading Forum a gentleman replied that he had mic'd his Starline Brass and come up with the same measurements for the case head thickness, which by the way are between .051 & .054 on both Starline and Top Brass. Therefore I have at this time ruled out the problem being the brass.

I don't have a set of feeler gauges with me in the RV but I suspect that the distance from "Doubler" to cylinder is probably .050

Now, on to how I'm gonna fix this without sending this gun back to Italy and kissing it goodbye for 4 or 5 months. By the way, if you've got any other ideas, please don't hold back, I want to shoot this thing BAD!!!

I took it back to the local GS where I purchased it to have the cylinder lock screw loosened (some Italian Gorilla puts the screws in these things) as well as the barrel pivot screw. I meant to take some 44 Russian brass with me to demonstrate the problem but screwed up and grabbed 38 S&W by mistake, oops.

The GS owner who also smiths' looked at it and declared that there looked like plenty of room for the case heads and if there wasn't it was probably because the gun is new and the bluing is too thick to allow clearance. He suggested that I get a piece of Crocus cloth and polish off the bluing and it should work. I went down to the hardware store and picked up some fine Crocus cloth and went to work.

The first thing I did was to remove the bluing from the end of the blast collar in front of the cylinder. This still left me with clearance between the cylinder and forcing cone but didn't make any appreciable difference in rotating a loaded cylinder.

I then went to work polishing the bluing on the "Doubler", which I might add is like trying to saw a piece of angle iron in half with a butter knife. At this point in time I have given my hands a rest and the bluing on the "Doubler" is nice and smooth polished, but still intact. Needless to say, the gun is still only a decoration.

Give me some ideas here guys, I'm at a loss. Keep in mind, I had to have the GS owner explain to me what Crocus cloth even was, so I'm not a gunsmith or a metal worker, keep it simple please.

Thanks,
 
Test your hypothesis about the doubler by loading some empty brass into the cylinder.
Start with 1 and see what happens.
You should be able to spot any binding issues with only one in there, and if it doesn't bind, then you have more information and clues.
Right now, clearancing anything until you get more information and know what to modify is a bad idea. Diagnostics are what you need to be doing.
If you don't have any empty brass, disassemble one of your live rounds and use one of the cases from that.
 
wheelgunslinger said:
Test your hypothesis about the doubler by loading some empty brass into the cylinder.
Start with 1 and see what happens.
You should be able to spot any binding issues with only one in there, and if it doesn't bind, then you have more information and clues.
Right now, clearancing anything until you get more information and know what to modify is a bad idea. Diagnostics are what you need to be doing.
If you don't have any empty brass, disassemble one of your live rounds and use one of the cases from that.

In my wordy OP, I neglected to say that I have indeed done that. By loading one empty brass she'll spin in either direction right up until the case head hits that #@$& doubler.

I'm gonna wander around the RV park this morning and see if I can come up with some feeler guages.
 
Call the uberti representative and request it be fixed. I'm pretty sure they have facilities in the US and approved gunsmiths
 
more then likely the cyl. needs to be moved forward. not work at the back. check barrel gap. .003" to .006". i would prefer the tighter clearance or gap I should say. look this over first before filing metal from rear.
 
I would try to see if I could find some different brass. I dont know if .44 russian can be made from .44 special or .44 Rem mag brass. You could cut down some different brass and see if that helps. Could be that the brass you have has a real thick rim.

Just a thought.
 
TheRodDoc said:
more then likely the cyl. needs to be moved forward. not work at the back. check barrel gap. .003" to .006". i would prefer the tighter clearance or gap I should say. look this over first before filing metal from rear.

I started out with that in mind. I did polish the "Blast Shield/Ring" in front and got the bluing off that, but that was about it. Too much and I'm gonna have the problem of the cylinder binding on the forcing cone.

Loosenock said:
I would try to see if I could find some different brass. I dont know if .44 russian can be made from .44 special or .44 Rem mag brass. You could cut down some different brass and see if that helps. Could be that the brass you have has a real thick rim.

Thanks, been there, done that. 44SPC/Mag can be cut down for Russian but the head thickness is the same, .051 to .054 and wouldn't solve the problem.

I did get my hands on a set of feeler guages. I need to remove .004 from the doubler which is pretty much the thickness of said doubler. I'm calling Uberti after I post this to see if I have any chance of shooting this gun in the next year.

Thanks, keep any ideas coming.
 
Ok, I'll try this again... A GUNSMITH.. GUNSMITH... G-U-N-S-M-I-T-H...

That's the type of person who should be performing work on a firearm.
If you keep messing with it, you'll void the warranty and when you have to send it back, it's gonna cost a lot more than shipping fees and a few months wait.

Or you can ignore good advice and destroy it... your choice.
 
Zombiphobie said:
Ok, I'll try this again... A GUNSMITH.. GUNSMITH... G-U-N-S-M-I-T-H...

That's the type of person who should be performing work on a firearm.
If you keep messing with it, you'll void the warranty and when you have to send it back, it's gonna cost a lot more than shipping fees and a few months wait.

Or you can ignore good advice and destroy it... your choice.

I fully agree. That's why after hitting it with the feeler gauges and seeing that about .004" had to come off to make it function, I pulled the plug and called Uberti.

My conversation with Uberti Customer Service was excellent. She assured me that I would have my gun back in about two weeks.

So....we can consider this thread closed if you like. I'll report back on how Uberti does with putting my new gun into functioning status and how long it takes.

Thanks all for the input.
 
Good Luck Joe!


We'll be interested in hearing what they had to do to fix it, or, if they just send you another one instead.

Kind of weird, unexpected problem to hear of for any Revolver, let alone a new Uberti.
 
Try shaving minute material off the back of the brass cartridge case.
I know someone who does that with a battle rifle that was rebarreled and converted to 7.62X51 NATO and it works. :)
 
TheRodDoc said:
you might want to send a brass case along with it.

I did just that, and I made sure that the six brass that I sent them definitely would not rotate. As stated before, the brass measures .051 to .054, the .051's will turn past the doubler but not without rubbing, the .054's, won't turn at all.

arcticap said:
Try shaving minute material off the back of the brass cartridge case.
I know someone who does that with a battle rifle that was rebarreled and converted to 7.62X51 NATO and it works.

Arcticap,
I originally thought that was a decent idea as well. Until I started looking at a couple of the cartridges which I had gotten to rotate. The primer was marred slightly, telling me that if I removed material from the head, that primer was going to protrude above the head. The last thing I want to do is detonate a primer when the cylinder isn't lined up with the barrel.

When I first loaded this gun, my original thought was that I was an idiot for not ensuring that I had seated the primers completely. Although I've made that mistake before with other cartridges, apparently I had learned from those mistakes, I had seated these primers well.

Anyway, she'll be setting sail for Maryland today and we'll see how long it takes for the return. In the meantime, I've got an 1894 Marlin that started out as my deer gun 10 years ago that is just aching to have some Black Powder 44 Specials sent down the barrel. I'm sure that I'll be able to keep myself occupied shooting "Something" until the Schofield returns.
 
wheelgunslinger said:
actually, don't close the thread, if you please.
I'd like to see how long it takes to resolve and the resolution of the problem itself.

Trust me, I'm a "BIG" customer service person. I owned a business for over 20 years and dealt with the public every day for over two decades. I will definitely report back when this is resolved, one way or another.

I think that my title on my original post may have been slightly inaccurate, it's not that I'm unhappy with Uberti (I think they are top notch in BP guns), I am instead unhappy with my new gun. Every company goofs on quality control from time to time. The important part of the sale is how they treat you and your problem after they have your money. For right now, I'm impressed with Stoeger and Uberti. Their customer service person was knowlegable regarding a Schofield Russian, impressive given there just aren't that many of them out there. And they immediately offered to have me send it back to them with no messing around.

I'll let everybody know how this turns out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top