Probably a dumb question..

Status
Not open for further replies.
H

halfded

Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2009
Messages
826
Location
Virginia
Is there a difference between handloading and reloading? The title of this section of forum is "handloading and realoading"; what's the deal? DO handloaders do each individual round by hand for more precise results?
 
Never really thought about it.

I guess if you pinned me down?

Reloading = The process of handloading ammo using reloading tools & equipment.

But really, ya got me!

rc
 
In some places I have seen people refer to reloading as buying all the components except brass (which is reused) and loading rounds.

Handloading has been used to describe:
- tailoring a given round to different guns
- the constant search for improved accuracy by changing powders, primers, seating depth, etc.
- making bullets (casting or swaging) and doing the above.

Honestly, too subtle for me to really care about.
 
Reloading... progressive press...
Handloading: For benchrest et al...

If you want to split hair that is...but I am no expert and didnt sleep in Holiday Inn last night. ;)
 
Same term if you ask me, but a good question indeed. I have wondered the same thing from time to time but never let it bother me. I will admit, I like the term handloading better as I relate that to the production of super precise match grade ammo. Like dude said above, I too have not slept at a Holiday either.
 
That's why I use the word assemble. Reload sounds like changing magazines and Handload sounds like something else all together.

LGB
 
Midway USA GunTec Dictionary says:

"Handloading": The practice of loading or reloading small arms ammunition by hand-powered equipment and methods.

"Reloading": The complete process of manufacturing ammunition by hand from its individual components.

All this as opposed to using loading machines powered by motors?

rc
 
Hummm... I Reload my handloads after I fire them off. Then I handload the reloads to tailor them to my guns. Then I reload them again
 
Handloading is what you do after your cases are empty. :rolleyes:

Reloading is what you do when the bad guy is still breathing. ;)
 
:):)You were right in the first place, halfded. Judging from all the "dumb" answers, it was a "dumb" question.:D

I'm a "handloader" that "reloads" ammunition...:evil:
 
The terms do get used interchangably, mostly by those who don't know the difference but, technically, there IS a difference. It doesn't really refer to the tools or components used, it has to do with methods and care in the work. It's largely done by those using turret or progressive presses, few of them are striving for tiny groups so more demanding - and slow - techniques are meaningless to them.

"Reloading" is what most of us do. We strive for usable ammo in quanity, in the least amount of time and/or as inexpensively as possible. In application, it commonly means picking a charge out of a manual, testing enough to see if it's safe and then cramming some cases full to have fun blowing them down range in casual "target" shooting or practice.

"Handloading", as the name implies, means there's a lot of hand craftsmanship and, usually, some specialised tools to aid the process. It usually indicates that great care has been taken in selecting a limited number of cases and uniforming them in several ways for the absolute best cosistancy. They are then precisely loaded and carefully tested to find the best possible accuracy obtainable. So, in "handloading", the stress is on accuracy, not high volumes or time/money saved.

Whichever approach we choose, it should best suit our needs, neither is automatically "better" than the other. A reloader who spents a lot of meticulus time uniforming cases that will be tossed out in rapid fire by a limited accuracy weapon will be wasting a lot of effort with no gain. On the other hand, a long range target/varmint shooter who picks an "OK" load before quickly cramming together a single box of ammo for a day afield without doing all he can to insure accuracy is wasting the opportunity to make his few shots count.

The names really do, or did, mean different things, and each has a practical correct application. But, like so much of our language, through common misuse the words have been degraded so much it no longer matters very much which one we use.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the replies fellas. Answers kind of went along with my way of thinking; always good to seek knowledge though.

Although I do like this idea quite a bit:

Handloading is what you do after your cases are empty.

Reloading is what you do when the bad guy is still breathing.
Click to expand...
 
I shot my handloads and they went "Bang"

I shot my reloads and they went "Bang"

They are synonyms for all intents and purposes.
 
"Reloading" is what most of us do. We strive for usable ammo in quantity . . .

"Handloading", as the name implies, means there's a lot of hand craftsmanship . . .
Click to expand...

This is how I've always thought of the two terms as well. When I'm cranking out .45 Colt loads by the bucketful on my LnL AP for CAS shooting that's reloading. When I'm tinkering with my .270 Win loads on the Rockchucker trying to turn my 1 MOA groups into .75 MOA groups, that's handloading. In conversation, though, I just say "reloading" and let it go at that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

K
  • Locked
Polygonal Barrel .45 Handloading ?'s
Replies
7
Views
478
KSUperDuty
K
D
  • Locked
Why do handloads fail?
2 3
Replies
70
Views
3K
Walkalong
Walkalong
WrongHanded
  • Locked
From Reloader to Handloader
2 3
Replies
61
Views
2K
splattergun
splattergun
M
  • Locked
Handload 9mm or .45 Auto?
2
Replies
33
Views
1K
Monster Zero
M
D
  • Locked
Handloading & Reloading
Replies
19
Views
837
SLM
S
Back
Top