questions about pimping a model 29

Status
Not open for further replies.

coosbaycreep

Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2007
Messages
435
Location
near Roseburg, Oregon




This is the 29 I just got from my dad today for $300 and a taurus .44 special. The gun was originally mine. My dad gave it to me for my birthday or something about 5 years ago, and then last year I gave it and some other guns back to him.

I absolutely love this gun. I haven't shot anything that was even remotely as nice as this thing. (To be honest, most of the guns I've shot were crap). Not only that, but I'm a die hard mall ninja, and have an obsession with the Dirty Harry movies.

Anyway, as much as I like this gun, I want one with a 4" barrel instead. I'm thinking real seriously about trying to trade this one for a factory 4". Just in case I can't find someone willing to trade, would it be possible to have the barrel cut down to 4" on mine? If so, what would that cost me, how much would it affect accuracy, etc.? BTW, I'm not concerned with any decrease in resale value, as I plan on keeping this gun or whatever 29 I trade it for until I'm pushing up daisies.

What's my gun worth anyway? All the shops and gun shows I've checked the past few months had them from $500 all the way up to over $800, with $600-$650 being about the average. Mine is a 29-2, and supposedly has had the action worked over or a trigger job or something. It shoots good, I don't think there's any excessive play in the cylinder or anything like that, and the blueing looks good except for a few small spots on the very edge of the barrel. It has pachmyr grips on it, but also came with some wood grips (not sure if they're factory, because there's no emblem on them). It also came in a non-original box.

Are the 4" ones worth more or less than the 6 1/2"?

How much more reliable are the newer models compared to my 29-2?

If I end up trading mine for a different model, is there a certain model that's better (as in durable)? How interchangeable are parts on the later models? Most of the newer ones I see are all 629s, and I really want the regular 29 for the blue frame.

Whether I keep mine or get a 4", I have a vision for how I want it to look. I really like the looks of some of the newer S&W performance center revolvers with the two tone finish and stainless steel cylinders on blue frames. I'd like to eventually get some stainless parts and put on my gun (cylinder, sights, the little button thingie that opens the cylinder, etc.). Do the cylinders and other parts off the 629 exchange with the 29? Can the cylinder and other stuff like that be changed out by an amateur, or does it need to be done by a gunsmith? If it requires a gunsmith, what would that cost?

How about unfluted cylinders, is there an unfluted stainless cylinder available for the 29? I see the Lew Horton 3" guns on gunbroker and stuff with the unfluted cylinder, but I don't know if it's possible to buy those cylinders.

I plan on eventually getting some spiffy hardwood grips for it too. Is there any other manufacturers other than Hogue who make some nice grips for my gun? Some of the Hogue grips are really nice looking, and wouldn't bother me to have on my gun at all, but at the same time, they seem to be pretty common, and I'd rather have something more unusual if it didn't cost a whole lot more.

How about sights? This gun is already more accurate than I'll ever be, and I'll probably never even carry it in a holster, but since I'm going for a "combat" theme, is there any good night sights or anything for these guns?

Since accuracy and trigger pull already surpasses my extremely low standards and abilities, is there anything else that I can/should do to my gun to make it better?

Also, if you have already tricked out your revolver, I wouldn't mind seeing pics.

Thanks.
 
Nickel/stainless/shiny is all the same thing to me.

That's a seriously sweet gun though, and is basically what I want mine to look like, but I think I'd still like to keep the blue barrel.
 
I've been looking at S&W's website, and they have a parts list that list unfluted cylinders for both the 29 and 629. They also have barrels in every length to ever leave the factory.

Cylinders range from $125. 4" barrels are about $150. They also have the 5" full lug, which is also an option I would highly consider.

So now I need to know how expensive it is to have the cylinder and barrel changed out by a competent gunsmith?
 
I've done similar mods to Smith guns and I can tell you your best bet is to sell the Smith and buy a four incher outright. By the time you buy the barrel and pay for shipping and pay the gunsmith and pay for return shipping you're going to have more in it than you think.

I'm guessing you'll have a couple thousand dollars in a revolver worth maybe $600.

Besides, I'll almost guarantee dollars to donuts that Smith doesn't have any pinned barrels left.

You really want to "pimp" it out and have something worth something? Have Smith reblue it with a high polish blue and slap some highly figured Herret stocks on it. That would be a thing of beauty.
 
Last edited:
You can either try finding the parts in the finish you want or find blued parts and have them nickeled. The cylinder may need fitting and also the barrel if a good B/C gap is wanted. If there is no difference in the threads of the crush fit barrels and older pinned barrels you could most likely install the crush fit barrel and drill it for the pin. You have quite a few options for semi-custom wood stocks but full custom stocks can run into big dollars. A good choice though expensive is to find a good set of factory Coke Bottle stocks. Many N-frame shooters love these target stocks and they were only put on a few models, mainly the M29 and M57, for a short period of time. Search the internet for wood revolver stocks/grips. Some makers of night sights may be able to install the sights you want. Just contact them and ask. You will end up with quite a bit invested in the revolver but if you go to resell you won't get the money that a factory pinto would bring. Just so you will know your 6 1/2 inch M29 is somewhat collectable and highly sought after. That barrel length was dropped sometime in the late 1970s and quite a few people want them. So keep that in mind before doing the mods.
 
Keep that one and buy a 4" barrel Taurus M44.

Better yet, keep that one and buy another 4" Model 29. Maybe a 4" barrel 629 and have it powdercoated black or one of the performance finishes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top