Range Report: Springfield Armory Mil-Spec .45 ACP...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stephen A. Camp

Moderator In Memoriam
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
2,430
Hello. Having owned SA handguns off and on for a number of years now, I decided to try the parkerized Mil-Spec. For those interested, SA designates it as "PB9108L". I'd owned a couple of Mil-Specs some years ago, but managed to trade or sell them.

I had seen and shot a friend's WWII GI Mil-Spec, which is now called something else by SA and was most impressed with the barrel-to-slide and frame-to-slide fit, but I had been satisfied with the sights that came on the "regular" Mil-Spec and opted to go that route.

These pistols can be found under or right at the $500 mark from what I've seen...at least in my neck of the woods.

The Pistol: This gun came with the standard GI grip safety and spur hammer and checkered black plastic grips. The frame and slide are parkerized and the finish is even and not unattractive. The fixed sights are of the 3-dot variety and the front sight is a non-serrated ramp as opposed to the post sight on my earlier Mil-Specs. The trigger is short and grooved and the arch, grooved mainspring housing does have the integral lock.

I was surprised to see that the barrel in my gun was stainless steel and new to me was the small groove cut in the top of the barrel hood to act as a visual loaded chamber indicator.

f59f6555.jpg

The Mil-Spec is somewhat spartan, but this one turned out to be reliable and accurate. It is not without faults, however.

Unlike it's WWII Springfield cousin, the Mil-Spec has a lowered ejection port and the magazine well is beveled nicely. It came with one 7-round magazine.

Shooting: On two ocassions now, I've fired just over 600 rounds throught this pistol. These included FMJ, flat-points, factory JHP's, and handloads with both CSWC bullets and JHP bullets.

After the first session, I replaced the standard GI grip safety with a drop-in from Pachmayr that works fine with the spur hammer. The reason was that I was getting eatten alive by both the hammer spur and the sharp edges of the grip safety. I've had this problem with about every 1911 I've ever shot that was in this configuration. The wide grip safety stopped my being more chewed up, but managed to rub off the rather deep scabs from the previous session.

Due to rain and wind, shooting was confined to 10, 15, and 25 yards. No chronograph work was done as I didn't care to set it up in the rain, but I will check out this particular gun in the near future. I expect it will fall in line with my other 5" guns.

10 Yards: Nothing fancy a tall, just some controlled pairs fired starting from a low-ready position and a few failure to stop drills thrown in.

f59f650c.jpg

I found the sights easy to pick up for controlled pairs. Each set was fired in something under a second. The trigger pull on this gun is heavy, but that will be remedied in the near future.

15 Yards: Shooting from this distance was done standing and using a two-hand hold in slow-fire.

f59f6513.jpg

I was VERY pleased to find that the fixed sights were "on" for me. Many times this is not the case. I suspect that the group being very slightly to the left with a few shots low and left are due to the somewhat heavy trigger pull. I'd estimate it as 7 or 8 pounds. This will be changed in the near future.

25 Yards: Groups fired at 25 yards were done in slow-fire while seated and my wrists braced.

f59f6547.jpg

This group was fired using Federal 230-gr. HydraShok JHP in the "old" version, ie, truncated cone bullet rather than the current one having the more rounded ogive.

Observations: The gun was utterly reliable. It fired a total of just over 600 rounds w/o cleaning and the number of malfunctions was exactly zero. There were no failures to feed, fire, or eject. The slide locked open only when it was supposed to.

For those interested, a more detailed report is at:

http://www.hipowersandhandguns.com/Critical Look at Springfield Mil Spec.htm

This one is a keeper.

Best.
 
Quite a nice a review once again Stephen, thank you.

I liked reading this review, it's very helpful to me, a guy with no 1911's to date and yet considering an relatively inexpensive one. You may have pushed me over the top on deciding to get a 1911 or not. I have been very reluctant to buy one due to reliability problems and having to spend "X" amount of untold dollars on making it work. After reading this, I do indeed have more confidence in them.

Thanks again!
Marshall
 
As always, it's a pleasure reading your reviews, Mr. Camp. Invariably, they are uncannily well-timed with respect to my acquisition list, if not my wallet. ;)

Thank you, sir!
 
Stephen, nice report. Your experience of the Mil-Spec seems identical to mine. Although I've got some high-end 1911s, my new stainless Mil-Spec is becoming my favorite shooter (had to buy one in SS to keep the parkerized one company); think I'll keep it stock (except for the cheesy plastic grips). I love the clean, classic lines (arched MSH and NO front cocking serrations!).
 
Hello and thanks very much for the compliments. I'm in the midst of beveling/rounding the edges of the grip safety to see if I can retain it so that I'll have at least one 1911 with a spur hammer and GI grip safety.

Best.
 
I bought mine (also a PB9108L) last year and it has been as reliable as yours has been and then some, based on my total shot count. Mr. Camp, I really appreciated reading your thorough review.
 
Last edited:
As you always do Mr. Camp, very nice report.

Friend got one of these a few weeks ago. His too was completely reliable with the all the different ammos on hand. I even got lucky with 2 out of 5 on a bowling pin at 100 yards. One of the better 45's I have had my hands on.
 
Good shooting there Mr Camp. They are probably the best deal out there for a no frills 1911 .45 cal hand gun. I own three of them, and they all shoot without any problems. The more I shoot mine, the more accurate they get. I have noticed the prices going up recently though. They are still worth every penny. :) Good luck with your "Springer" Be careful, they can become addictive. :D


SILENT ONE
 
79277632.gif

Nice Report, Steve. I am glad that SA and Kimber have finally copied the chamber check notch that I have done for 20 some years. Kimber even has it "Patent Pending". I am also delighted that a factory gun like this works as it should right out of the box! Thanks for the excellent report as always.

35072013.gif

This gun was built before Kimber existed.
 
Do I see a slipper belonging to Dave in that first picture? I had a rather funny mental image when I saw that. A cranky old man(for so I imagine all 1911 smiths) in a bath robe and bunny slippers whacking a 1911 with a hammer. :D
 
Thanks for the almost perfect description of the Captain. I wear slippers a lot because of foot problems connected with my Diabetes. I have a great heavy blue bathrobe that I start the day with, and I love smacking 1911 frames and slides together with lead hammers. It is called "Cold Fitting" and will go about 1000,000 rounds as near as we can tell since we haven't loosen up yet in 20 years. I am sorry that you left out arrogant and opinionated so I will put that in for you. You are really right on!

37011895.gif

Who's that with the Duke? Could that be..................The Captain?
 
Thanks for the report, Stephen. Not long ago I traded a Beretta 92FS for a stainless Springfield Milspec and couldn't be happier. It has been flawless out of the box. :)
 
Stephen, I worked over a stock grip safety awhile back on a Mil-Spec and there's no hammer bite or imprint on the web. It can be done, just takes a bit of time. I also blended it a bit better to the frame.
 
Hello and thanks to all for the comments and input. I beveled and rounded the edges along the side of the GI grip safety that came on the gun. I'll shoot it shortly and see if that and the bobbed hammer do the trick.

Best and thank you all again.
 
Hello and thank you. FWIW, I just got in from the range where I put another 200 rounds through the gun: S&B 230-gr. FMJ, Winchester USA 230-gr. FMJ, Winchester 230-gr. "Subsonic" JHP, and Federal Classic 230-gr. JHP. Zero problems of any kind. That makes 800+ shots, 600 w/o cleaning, and no malfunctions and no first-round-flyer syndrome.

Best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top