Real world gunfight not as expected

Status
Not open for further replies.
My biggest takeaway is just to 'stay in the fight' until the end...and a bit of luck on any given day doesn't hurt either.
 
Someone once said, "No plan survives contact with the enemy."

The guy who does a better job of getting through that usually wins the fight, whether it be between two guys with handguns or two army corps.
 
Pretty rugged alright.
It also reminds me of just how weak most handguns really are compared to a rifle or shotgun.
 
It also reminds me of just how weak most handguns really are compared to a rifle or shotgun.

They are, but he was alos very lucky. A .45 to the face and live to talk about it? If it hadn't hit his jaw, being the curved bone structure that it is, would likely have been a very different story. Two inches lower or higher would probably have been a fatal wound. As well, his body armor probably saved his life, because at point blank, I'm betting the two rounds that hit it would have been COM.
 
I'm surprised how normal looking they got his face back to.

The will to live is a strong thing.
 
When the C-141 was new back in the early 60s the Flight Manual Chapter 3 Emergency Procedures were maybe a dozen pages long. By the time I go to the plane in the late 80s there were probably close to 100 pages. Of the many inflight and ground emergencies I encountered, very few went down the way Chapter 3 said they should. Why? Because nothing happens the way one would expect it to. Plan for the worst, hope for the best. Fly what you want, log what you need. Eat when you’re hungry, sleep when you’re tired. But I digress…
 
two things i take took to heart from his interview:

it doesn't happen like it does in the movies. (he was referring to how someone responds when they get shot)

he didn't leave his fate to "luck". (in reference to not just lying there and hoping you survive).l

glad he survived, and i hope he never has to face something like this again!
 
ouch.. It says one thing clearly.. Winning is willing.. willing to live, willing to stay in the fight, willing to win...

He obviously had the will... So many have died from minor and survivable wounds just because they lacked with will..

It also hold true, you never hear the one that gets you. He stated in the beginning of the interview that he thought he had been punched in the face, not shot..Adrenalin and dopamine, it is a life saver...

What amazed me is that he had the forethought to pull the suspect into him and finish him... there are many that would not have thought to do that... in his case it WAS the right thing for him to do.... Had he not, there is no telling how much fight was left in the suspect, no way to tell for sure, or how much was left in him.. and with 7 rounds in him, and untold blood loss... he did what he had to do...
 
It happens both ways. A guy who doesn't want to be dead can soak up non-CNS wounds like a sponge and keep coming. Somebody not as strong will can die from a flesh wound and the shock it creates. Mind-set wins most gun fights all other things being equal.
 
One of the lessons that I took out of this story is more ammo is better. The officer, probably using a Glock 22, was able to stay in the fight until the end.
 
One of the lessons that I took out of this story is more ammo is better. The officer, probably using a Glock 22, was able to stay in the fight until the end.

That had also occured to me in watching this interview. And I'll bet the suspect had a G21, since they said 12 rounds of .45 fired.

The officer may well have lost that fight if he'd been armed with a service revolver. Perhaps even if it had been a 1911, though I'm bettin the 9 rounds of .45 JHP he'd most likely have been using would have been sufficient.

That said, I think we can safely say that this is an unusual situation, with that many rounds finding their mark on both sides and the fight continuing.
 
Real world gunfight not as expected

And that is cause the other guy fights back and does not play by a rule book.

Just go to a dojo or boxing ring and spar someone full contact. Unless you are very experienced and the other guy a real novice you will find the fight does not go so easy. All cause the other guy resist, adapts, and comes after you.

Deaf
 
The officer may well have lost that fight if he'd been armed with a service revolver.
I don't know about that. The .357 out of a 4inch barrel can do some damage.
 
MachIVshooter said:
That said, I think we can safely say that this is an unusual situation, with that many rounds finding their mark on both sides and the fight continuing.

Not unusual, less common than not, but certainly not unusual.
Exchanging pistol rounds in any "fair" fight is fairly common, especially at very close range where either can score rapid hits with minimal skill.
"Fair" in the sense of both individuals armed and facing each other when hostilities start.

If you look at the reports of most self defense scenarios where a bad guy dies it is quite often after they ran out of the home/store, to collapse outside or down the street. It is a lot easier to point and move your finger to return fire than run a distance with holes in you. Yet the bad guys still managed to run quite a ways. So it is only because their priority was escape and getting away that those were the final actions they chose to perform.




We have had threads on this forum of individuals trading multiple hits with bad guys.
Such things are not new either, even going back to duels in early America you can find a number of them, including several famous ones, where both people involved die. Quite contrary to the movie showdowns where the fastest gun and first good shot always wins the fight.
It is those so psychologically shocked they have been shot that drop to the ground immediately, but even they typically have the ability to react, they simply choose to clutch their wounds in shock.
In this case the officer was not aware that he had been shot until they were exchanging shots. He thought the blow he felt to his face was a powerful punch to the face.
So he didn't have to go through the emotional trauma of the realization he had been shot in the head until he was in the middle of a gunfight.

newbuckeye said:
Imagine what HP rounds would have done instead of FMJ.

Not much, the .45 is a big slow round and the thin tissue over the jaw and teeth has very little soft tissue to apply force to and open up a hollowpoint.
It went through a thin amount of skin before impacting bone and hard porcelain like teeth. The result is a typical hollowpoint would have likely had the front damage so much that it wouldn't be doing a lot of opening up and been little different from the FMJ.
It then exited.
Even in typical torso hits hollowpoints don't open up like they do in water and gel tests where the medium is a solid consistent and deep amount of liquid to push the petals apart and give uniform expansion. Ribs and other bone damage and deform the soft engineered bullet designed to work with the energy of a pistol resulting in less predictable results. While in pure gel or water, or other uniform soft testing material the bullet has uniform pressure applied within the undamaged and uniformly shaped hollowpoint and can open up into a perfect flower, which someone can take a picture of and post online to marvel at and compare.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top