A sad .45 RH story. A friend of mine and I each ordered a 5.5" SS .45 RH a year ago last March. Mine went back in two days due to casting flaws. Mine came back in super shape - a real keeper. His went back a few days later - they replaced it, as the frame was warped! two for two isn't too swift - but we both still love the beasts.
In the .44 Magnum vein... I just bought my first 'true' .44M S&W - a new 629-6 6" half lug, a big brother for my 629MG, from which I shoot mainly .44 Specials. Tuesday will mark it's fourth week of ownership - and it's third week 'back home', in MA. I never have had to send a new S&W back for QC, etc - until now.
Re the Redhawk/Super Redhawk. Yep, their is a huge difference in size and mass... according to their literature, the 7.5" RH in .44 Magnum weighs in at 54 oz, while the SRH is 53 oz - actually, it is lighter! Of course, the 5.5" RH is 49 oz, while my 6" 629 half-lug weighs 45.5oz. Recall that the S&W's are heat treated forged parts, the Rugers are cast - they must be bigger to have the same strength.
Still, in the 5.5" .45 RH, one had a real treat, sadly gone from the marketplace. For a 7.5" .45, one could accept less-than-stellar accuracy and go for the slicker triggered .454 SRH. Yeah, my usually very-biased opinion...
Stainz
Stainz