Refinish or no?

Status
Not open for further replies.
It could use some gentle cleaning and oiling, but do nothing that removes, covers up or alters the original. You would be shocked at how much that will destroy its market value. And if market value isn't a deciding factor, consider how erasing its "history" will affect its sentimental value to you.
 
Last edited:
I understand your hesitation about refinishing this one. I would only refinish it if you could send it to Turnbull for a complete first class job. Pricey, but that level of work enhances value as well as appearance. A sloppy refinishing effort would be a crime.
 
you can never put it back. if it isn't objectionable, or broken I would not. If you want to see what it was like when new, go hold a refinished one or a repro or whatever at a LGS, and you'll most likely decide you like original better.
 
You re-finish that gun and will be worth half what it is worth now. Probably less than that. That's with a professional job. Do a bubba job and it wouldn't be worth a quarter of what it's worth now.
 
I understand your hesitation about refinishing this one. I would only refinish it if you could send it to Turnbull for a complete first class job. Pricey, but that level of work enhances value as well as appearance. A sloppy refinishing effort would be a crime.

^

This.

I went this route with an A.H. Fox 20GA SxS that had been in my families for 3 generations. It had seen some very, very, rough use on the salt marshes of RI and CT. Collector value would have been around $500..maybe. Sent it to Turnbull for restoration and upgrading...one year and $3700 later, it's still a family heirloom (the important part), but it's also a work of art, that still get's out to chase quail on nice days.
 
Looks fine the way it is. I wouldn't even send it to Turnbulls for restoration.

Leave it be; it's earned all of those nicks and dents and scrapes and scratches in service to your family.
 
My question would be why? As long as it is functional why would you mess with a family heirloom? I have over a dozen 100+ year old rifles, all of which I have shot and hope to pass on to my grandkids, and all I have done to them is to clean and preserve the original finish. Just as the scars on my hands and arms were earned the bumps and dings on the stock were earned during the life of your rifle.
 
Even if I had the money and everyone's go ahead to refinish it.......I just couldn't do it. Nope.

That is just my opinion. It is your rifle and you may do what ever you wish and I would honor that wish.
 
To me, it has a history with that finish. Your forefathers put it in that condition so I'd definitely keep it as is. if it's refinished it's lost that link to their hands.
 
25 Steven's Favorite. My wife has one from her late father in a 25 Stevens rimfire.
Just bought a box of ammo on Gunbroker.
She'll never sell or shoot it.
I'd leave it original
 
Show some respect for it. It’s glorious the way it is - use with pride and care the same way your dad and grandpa had before you were entrusted with it!
 
Last edited:
Turnbull or nothing.

Id call Turnbull for a quote and think about it.
Ask them if you can get it threaded for a can just to tell us what they say.
 
I'll depart from the consensus opinion only if a couple very specific conditions are met. Did your grandfather purchase the rifle new? I'd also want to know if he treasured it as a prized possession or if it was just a means to an end.

If he bought it brand new and it was one of the things he was most proud of -the hard work he put in to afford it and actually owning it -only then would I consider restoring it. Putting it back in the condition it was in when your grandpa fell in love with it would be understandable at least.

Not a recommendation at all. I'd say leave it be.
But I could see those being things to consider and valid reasons for leaning that way.
My grandpa had a pile of s___ Farmall tractor that he used for years. The property and the tractor are still in the family and both get used. Are we supposed to leave the tractor being essentially useless?
Nope, we restored it because even though it wasn't how he left it, now it's the tractor he would have had if he could have afforded it.
But tractors and guns are different animals...
 
Last edited:
I agree with the others who suggested no restoration unless you decide to give it the Turnbull treatment. What makes it special is its history with the ancestors. They are the ones who used it, preserved it, and provided it to you. That makes it one of a kind, and charges you with providing it to someone who understands what all that means, appreciates what it is and what it has done, and will carry on the tradition.
 
Wipe it off and a light coat of oil....it's a sexy gun with history ....your history..... Don't change a thing....
 
I have my grandfathers 30-30. Just a Glenfield 30a, nothing special about it. It has a scratch where he went to sleep sitting on the tailgate of the truck and dropped it. It has a ding on the ejection port where my uncle dropped it from a deer stand (bent the scope pretty bad and broke the scope mounting bolts). It has a superficial crack on the forearm where a distant cousin slapped it against a tree when he stepped on a snake and dropped everything and ran like a startled chihuahua (per his brother). To top all of that off it has tiny white latex paint droplets on the top of the gun where grandaddy painted the house for the last time. He could barely paint let alone move stuff out of the way to paint behind stuff that hadn’t moved in 20 years. The gun was stolen and sold the day grandaddy died by the one cousin who wasn’t bedside, and it has a pawnshop sticker on it from that event. It was bought back from the pawnshop 1 week after we buried grandaddy and the handwritten receipt is in the safe with it. I could easily fix every bit of that, but it would erase all of that history. Yeah it would still be THAT gun, but it wouldn’t be the same. When I hold that rifle I feel like I’m with grandaddy again and he has been gone for 20 years now. No way I would do any refinish work to mine, and I would advise to take stock of exactly how the wear got put on the OPs rifle, how it got treated, what it meant to the men who used it, and how it came to be in the possession of its current curator. Johnson’s Paste Wax will protect it in its current state. I would start with a detail clean and intentionally protect it from there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top