Skid: what would be an example of a civil offense? Do you mean something they could sue you for? Because I know that, unless I am writting a check, using my credit card or buying beer, the only person that's going see my ID is a LEO.
EDIT: additionally, if you refused to leave, could you be charged with felony armed tresspass?
At least here in VA trespass comes in 2 varieties - civil & criminal. You could commit either - or
both - offenses at the same time.
AFAIK VA does not have an "felony armed trespass" offense, but there is probably something like it they could hang on you.
Again, IANAL
but --
preemption laws only regulate the conduct of the gooberment. Even if the property owner/manager hangs out a sign that is not compliant with a state law requiring specific words in specific type size and font, in specific color, the property owner/manager can set the rules for what they will or will not allow. Those property owners who fall into the "public-access" arena do have to put up with the various anti-discrimination laws, but ccw-ing is not yet a protected class.
It all comes down to what you are willing to risk. If you do not want to risk an invitation to immediately leave - with or without the assistance of your local LEO - then you will "respect" the NO GUNS signs by not carrying there. If you do not want to risk your safety/security then you will respect the NO GUNS sign by not entering the posted property, thus remaining ccw-ed.
I just see anything else as some form of rationalization for either illegal or uncivil behavior.
Sure, if Regal Cimemas has the lock on movie theaters in your town you will face hard times. But if the issue of ccw is important to you, you will either go elsewhere where you as a ccw-ing person are welcome or will rent the movie later on. Maybe once or twice you will buy a ticket then ask the manager for a refund before you go in the doors, saying you saw the NO GUNS sign only after you bought the ticket.
But let's face it - Regal and the local manager do not care if you stop patronizing them. They don't care if you picket in front of their property -- as long as you are on public property when you do it.
As I see it, not until ccw-ers
as a group are willing to stand up in public and complasin about being punished because of the criminal behavior of the bad guys will ccw-ers get anywhere on this issue.
In the meantime ...
stay safe.
skidmark