S&W 36 vs 60 size difference?

[Dollar An Hour]

How much (if any) size difference exists between the .38 Spl J-frames such as Model 36/442 and Model 60/640? Will the same holsters work for either one?

For example I noticed that my M&P340 doesn't fit in my 442 Kramer pocket holster because of the full underlug on the 340's barrel.

I am considering adding a steel snubbie to the two lightweights above that I own, wondering if holsters will work for the new gun.

I know several of you guys own both, I'd appreciate your opinions.

 

[rcmodel]

All J-Frames are the exact same size, except as you noted, some recent ones may have slightly different barrel contours.

A model 60 is just a stainless steel model 36, which is blued carbon steel.


rcmodel

 

[Sistema1927]

The "J-magnum" frames are a bit beefier, but they all fit in the same holsters.

 

[The Lone Haranguer]

If they are both .38 Specials with the same barrel length, they are the same size. If the M60 is a magnum, it will have a quarter-inch longer and ejector-rod-shrouded barrel, as well as some frame/cylinder differences, making it larger.

 

[Marshall]

The 60/640 is a 357 Mag that can shoot 38 Specials. A Model 36 is a 38 Special gun. 2 1/8th inch verse 1 7/8 inch as well.

 

[gb6491]

My Model 60-9 (.357) will not fit in some closed end holsters listed for 2" J frames, some others work. Best to try the holsters on one to check the fit.

 

[Snubster]

Best to try the holsters on one to check the fit.

+1

I have several .38 Special J-frame holsters that won't fit the newer J-Mag frame.