S&W model 36,reblue or ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm actually wondering why the OP feels the need for trigger work. Those revolvers were usually made with hand finished internal parts. The triggers were much better back then.

I found out the difference when I bought a 1948 M&P and felt the trigger compared to a current production revolver.

It is true that the M&Ps of the vintage you mention have very nice stock triggers. I have several that I consider off limits to any screwdriver. The J frame , however , is a different ball of wax. The action in that small frame is based on a coiled mainspring rather than the leaf spring found in the relatively spacious K grip frame. Also the rebound spring of the J frame sometimes seems excessive in strength. I tend to think that the designer(s) was thinking SAFETY in determining the da trigger pull weight. Generally speaking , I think it is easier to achieve good trigger characteristics in a larger frame than in a bitty J frame.

In my experience many J frames , even older ones , have definite room for improvement in the actions , and the before gunsmith and after gunsmith trigger difference can be striking. ( I said many , not all ; there seems to be considerable difference between various individual J frames of the same vintage , for reasons that are over my head.)

Fact is , I have a flath latch Chiefs Specieal that will be shipping out soon for improvement for the fore mentioned reasons.
 
Prepared for pitchforks and torches...

If it were mine and, I really planned to keep it and carry it for a long time....

I’d get it hard chromed.

It’s not a Registered Magnum. It’s just a nice old revolver.
 
So do I suffer it as is,or send it back to S&W for a redo ?.

It is your gun, do with it as you wish.

The market for used guns is finicky. Some folks want a gun in "original" condition, some folks like the gun to be updated to near new finishes.

If you plan to keep the gun for a while and want it looking nice, get it refinished. If you plan to flip it soon, leave it as is.
 
Prepared for pitchforks and torches...

If it were mine and, I really planned to keep it and carry it for a long time....

I’d get it hard chromed.

It’s not a Registered Magnum. It’s just a nice old revolver.
I would really agree with your thoughts,BUT S&W will not do a finish on any gun that was not manufactured with that finish.

So unless I find another who I trust the whole job to [ trigger,action ] I would be stuck with a reblue.
 
No. Smith won’t hard chrome. Lots of great vendors do hard chrome though.
 
That is a great looking old gun. If it were mine, I would add a T grip and shoot it, carry it, enjoy it.
Understood fully.

BUT the action is very stiff,the trigger is thin and sucks !.

If I were a S&W armorer ,that would not be an issue.

I could live with the finish for a carry gun,but all other things considered = screams a do over.

Thanks for your input.
 
I was in the same exact situation you are in,,,
I picked up a well worn 3" Model 36 with a rough trigger.

All I did was flush the insides out with spray cleaner,,,
I did this several times and man was that gun filthy inside,,,
I was amazed at all the crud that eventually washed out of her..

But, to my relief, the trigger instantly became smooth,,,
As far as having it re-blued, I decided not to,,,
It wouldn't raise value or performance.

I decided to just buff it real well with steel wool,,,
Then applied some cold blue to even things out a bit.

Meet Libby,,,

libby.jpg

As you can see, she turned out quite well,,,
Certainly not as well as a factory re-blue would have,,,
But nice enough that I'm not at all ashamed to own the gun.

Oh, I replaced the white plastic-pearl "Mother of Toilet Seat" grips,,,
I found these new online for $22.50 shipped,,,
They look and feel just fine.

A factory re-blue will do nothing to increase the performance of your gun,,,
But the truth is, if it makes you happy and you can afford it,,,
Then by all means satisfy your desire for a pretty gun.

Aarond

.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top