AStone
Member
I'm in the market for a short machete,
or at least a tool that acts like one,
something with a blade around 10 - 12"
and an ergo, full tang handle, all in a package
that's less than $100 including sheath.
(Yes, someday I'll buy something like an ESEE Jungla,
or a Swamp Rat, but they're not in the budget right now.)
The major uses of this blade will be as follows in camps in mid- and northern Maine
(heavily wooded, much of it second growth; thick underbrush):
* chopping small wood (1" - 3" diam.) for fires
* batonning larger wood for fires
* clearing camp sites, cutting wood for shelters, etc.
(See below the line for more background on this project.)
Right now, after participating in several threads, especially this one,
and after a substantive amount of research/reading,
I've landed on these three contenders as my major choices
- were I to buy one tomorrow (which I won't).
I'm seeking feedback on the best one to acquire.
* Kabar Cutlass Machete
* Ontario Survival Machete SP 8
* Ontario Gen II SP52
Important: I've chosen the three blades above in part because
they seem suitable for batoning, unlike Kukri,
unlike those with a sharpened upper blade.
Opinions?
I'm open to others that meet the criteria specified above.
________
________
More background.
I am seeking a survival blade trio.
My current two shorter blades are:
* Spyderco Manix 2 (~ 3.5" blade)
* SOG Seal Pup Elite (~ 5" blade)
These two do most EDC chores: kitchen, eating, cord work, etc.
I own a full-sized Kabar with 7" blade,
but find it too short for chopping,
too long for kitchen duty.
The longer blade will take care of chopping, batoning firewood, heavy shelter work, etc.
In a pinch, it could do SD also, but that's not its major function.
or at least a tool that acts like one,
something with a blade around 10 - 12"
and an ergo, full tang handle, all in a package
that's less than $100 including sheath.
(Yes, someday I'll buy something like an ESEE Jungla,
or a Swamp Rat, but they're not in the budget right now.)
The major uses of this blade will be as follows in camps in mid- and northern Maine
(heavily wooded, much of it second growth; thick underbrush):
* chopping small wood (1" - 3" diam.) for fires
* batonning larger wood for fires
* clearing camp sites, cutting wood for shelters, etc.
(See below the line for more background on this project.)
Right now, after participating in several threads, especially this one,
and after a substantive amount of research/reading,
I've landed on these three contenders as my major choices
- were I to buy one tomorrow (which I won't).
I'm seeking feedback on the best one to acquire.
* Kabar Cutlass Machete
Weight: 1.20 lbs.
Steel: 1085 Carbon
Blade length: 11"
Overall length: 16-1/2"
Grind: Hollow
Handle Material : Kraton G®
Shape : Cutlass
HRC: 52-54
Blade Thickness: 0.165
Steel: 1085 Carbon
Blade length: 11"
Overall length: 16-1/2"
Grind: Hollow
Handle Material : Kraton G®
Shape : Cutlass
HRC: 52-54
Blade Thickness: 0.165
* Ontario Survival Machete SP 8
Blade Edge: Plain
Blade Length (inches): 10
Blade Material: 1095 Carbon Steel
Blade Thickness (inches): 0.26
Handle Material: Kraton
Knife Closed Length (inches): 4.06
Knife Open Length (inches): 15
Knife Weight (ounces): 22.8
Country of Origin: USA
Blade Length (inches): 10
Blade Material: 1095 Carbon Steel
Blade Thickness (inches): 0.26
Handle Material: Kraton
Knife Closed Length (inches): 4.06
Knife Open Length (inches): 15
Knife Weight (ounces): 22.8
Country of Origin: USA
* Ontario Gen II SP52
Blade Edge: Plain
Blade Length (inches): 10
Blade Material: 5160 Steel
Blade Thickness (inches): 0.26
Handle Material: Kraton
Knife Closed Length (inches): 3.25
Knife Open Length (inches): 15
Knife Weight (ounces): 18
Country of Origin: USA
Blade Length (inches): 10
Blade Material: 5160 Steel
Blade Thickness (inches): 0.26
Handle Material: Kraton
Knife Closed Length (inches): 3.25
Knife Open Length (inches): 15
Knife Weight (ounces): 18
Country of Origin: USA
Important: I've chosen the three blades above in part because
they seem suitable for batoning, unlike Kukri,
unlike those with a sharpened upper blade.
Opinions?
I'm open to others that meet the criteria specified above.
________
________
More background.
I am seeking a survival blade trio.
My current two shorter blades are:
* Spyderco Manix 2 (~ 3.5" blade)
* SOG Seal Pup Elite (~ 5" blade)
These two do most EDC chores: kitchen, eating, cord work, etc.
I own a full-sized Kabar with 7" blade,
but find it too short for chopping,
too long for kitchen duty.
The longer blade will take care of chopping, batoning firewood, heavy shelter work, etc.
In a pinch, it could do SD also, but that's not its major function.
Last edited: