Sierra match king HP for deer

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pic and info borrowed from the web . 77 Grain MatchKing . Looks like it did the job quite well . Who am I to judge, looks as dead as any deer I have ever killed .

"A bit over 100 yards. Again 18-20" penetration. Shoulder, ribs, lungs, liver, ribs, caught under skin on far side."

View attachment 1018859
The 77 SMK-WC has been reliable on coyotes. I wouldn't be scared of trying it.
The OP was talking about 6.5 which has given me completely opposite results.

Bluejay 75 is doing something that I am pretty sure would make it completely reliable.
 
I know you asked about Sierra bu poets but if the Sierra hunting bullet isn't available why take a chance with the SMK bullet injuring an animal and making it suffer? We are supposed to be ethical when hunting. There are so many good hunting bullets from Nosler, Speer, Hornady, Swift, Berger and a host of others why take a chance?

I like Sierra match bullets for the range but my hunting bullets are usually from Nosler.
 
I know you asked about Sierra bu poets but if the Sierra hunting bullet isn't available why take a chance with the SMK bullet injuring an animal and making it suffer? We are supposed to be ethical when hunting. There are so many good hunting bullets from Nosler, Speer, Hornady, Swift, Berger and a host of others why take a chance?

I like Sierra match bullets for the range but my hunting bullets are usually from Nosler.
You are correct, the subject is SMK . This look dead enough for you ? Save the drama ., wimpy little 77 SMK, looks like it's dead .

index.php
 
Not offended since you named it - Game King - that's a good bullet. But some folks are trashing those of us saying not to use MATCH KINGS claiming any ol' BTHP works fine on deer and, yeah, that's a little offensive. Sorry you chose to take it personally since no one called you out by name.
Offensive ? I think it's offensive you have to add your drama . Why not just move along without comment if you can't handle the facts, dead is dead no matter if you approve of the bullet or not . Obviously you have no experience with the SMK for hunting so in my eyes your opinion does not matter.
 
Save the match bullets for paper punching. If the manufacturer does not recommend match bullet for game hunting, I am going to say, that is a good enough recommendation for me. I have had the core come out of a Norma 30 cal hunting bullet, so why would I want to use a bullet that was not designed for expansion and integrity in meat?

And, what do you really get? If you don't think game bullets will shoot straight, go try some. It is surprising how well some game bullets will do at distance. I have not tested them all, but no real stinkers out to 300 yards, and beyond that, some of my game bullets shot very well indeed.

jzQLKOZ.jpg

FT1YVAK.jpg

30 cal, pulled Fed Fusion

wgm1Lzh.jpg

AWF3Wh6.jpg

kmgedxu.jpg

277 Fed Fusion pulled bullets

X6r738U.jpg

These 130's float at 600 yards, at least that is what I am claiming for the shots in the nine ring. Can't be me, right?

CYmKAJ8.jpg

the rifle liked the 150 Fed Fusion pulled bullets

8inhs5s.jpg

8CvOtfU.jpg

shot well at 600 yards

glW9y3a.jpg

hunting bullet, you think you can't hit unless you have a match bullet?

8gWYYUe.jpg

while the 6.5 Swede M70 puked with core lokt's

LT0GGCi.jpg

same bullet did well in a M700


iENXQeU.jpg

With quality bullets, I am going to say that aiming error is greater than bullet. Tight group sizes don't mean as much as having correct range estimates and being able to dope the wind. Match or game bullets still move in the wind, and you have to shoot enough under fish tailing conditions, or gusty conditions, to appreciate how much bullets drift.

I remember complaining one year in the pits at Camp Perry about the 600 yard conditions the day before. My 223 bullets were drifting 36 inches before they hit the target. Of course, some drifted more, some drifted less, wind is never a constant. And some old USMC on a target near by stumped up and told me when he won the 1000 yard service rifle match, with his M14, he had full left windage, and was aiming three targets over! I estimated his bullets were drifting forty feet, or so.

I heard an apocryphal tale of a marksman shooter with a rack grade Garand shooting at Camp Perry in gale like conditions. The story was, the shooter won the 600 yard match due to the randomness of his hold, his aim, the ammunition, his rifle, and wind gusts.

Could have happened, after you blow enough water out of your rear sight aperture, these fish stories sound plausible.
 
Last edited:
Can't speak for the OP, but I've also been looking for a 6.5 bullet to load for hunting and the issue is availability. Target bullets are available.....hunting bullets are not. At least not one's I'm familiar with. Hornady, Sierra or Speer. But I've mostly been looking on Midway. Reloading store 100 miles away may have something, but have not checked with them.

So for me, issue would not be forcing a square peg in a round hole.......it's "any old port in a storm". Trying to work with what you can get your hands on. So far, it's been a pass. Continue to wait.
 
If the manufacturer does not recommend match bullet for game hunting, I am going to say, that is a good enough recommendation for me.

Manufacturers want to sell bullets. Many of them sell essentially the same bullets in different boxes. One labeled for hunting, the other labeled as match bullets. Some used to advertise them for both hunting and match shooting until they figured out they could sell more bullets by offering different versions.

I can't say for sure about Sierra bullets, but based on what I read on the internet the Match Kings may not be the best choice. But many other bullets advertised as "match" bullets have proven to be just as effective, if not more, than many bullets advertised as hunting bullets. If you can find them the Lapua Scenar match bullets are an excellent choice for both hunting and paper punching. I've heard very good things about Hornady's match bullets too.

To the OP. Right now many of us have to use what we can get. I don't think I'd choose the Match Kings as my 1st choice. But if that is what I had I wouldn't stay home. Good luck.
 
Can't speak for the OP, but I've also been looking for a 6.5 bullet to load for hunting and the issue is availability. Target bullets are available.....hunting bullets are not. At least not one's I'm familiar with. Hornady, Sierra or Speer. But I've mostly been looking on Midway. Reloading store 100 miles away may have something, but have not checked with them.

So for me, issue would not be forcing a square peg in a round hole.......it's "any old port in a storm". Trying to work with what you can get your hands on. So far, it's been a pass. Continue to wait.


Give these a try.

https://www.midwayusa.com/product/1165149662?pid=925753
 
No drama, just my opinion. This is a discussion forum after all.
Yes, that deer looks dead alright but it also seems that a lot of meat has been destroyed.
So now it's about the destroyed meat ? :confused: I guess a guy is supposed to shoot them in the guts so nothing goes to waste ?

If you have ever butchered a deer you know already that's not prime stuff up there , Canning jar material .
 
Last edited:
Yes, that deer looks dead alright but it also seems that a lot of meat has been destroyed.

There’s less meat destroyed by a hunter sticking an HPBT or poly tipped frangible bullet through nearly useless and abundant rib meat which explodes at the centerline and doesn’t blow a huge exit wound than a fool “punching the shoulder” straight through a shoulder roast with a “controlled expansion” hunting bullet...
 
There’s less meat destroyed by a hunter sticking an HPBT or poly tipped frangible bullet through nearly useless and abundant rib meat which explodes at the centerline and doesn’t blow a huge exit wound than a fool “punching the shoulder” straight through a shoulder roast with a “controlled expansion” hunting bullet...
Another one of those guys. I actually am too.
Hit it with a fast soft bullet and they may make 3 jumps. I will lose either neck roast or shoulder steaks if it's heavy brush though.
It of curiosity what caliber, weight and velocity smk do you use? I'm more of an AMAX/VMAX on deer. They always open. If it's larger than 30 cal I use cup and core bullets.
 
Can't speak for the OP, but I've also been looking for a 6.5 bullet to load for hunting and the issue is availability. Target bullets are available.....hunting bullets are not. At least not one's I'm familiar with. Hornady, Sierra or Speer. But I've mostly been looking on Midway. Reloading store 100 miles away may have something, but have not checked with them.

So for me, issue would not be forcing a square peg in a round hole.......it's "any old port in a storm". Trying to work with what you can get your hands on. So far, it's been a pass. Continue to wait.
Don't get in a hurry. I am starting to see some Hornady SST's and Interlocks available online. Not my first pick, but they will work. I think I saw the most on Scheel's.
 
It of curiosity what caliber, weight and velocity smk do you use?

I haven’t used the 140 SMK in question, but I‘ve killed hundreds of coyotes and hogs with 77SMK’s, and several deer and hogs with 168SMK’s in ‘06 and 308. I’ve killed even more deer since with 105 Berger Hybrids, which are a relatively similar BTHP design.

The 105’s are 6mm’s, which I’ve fired from fast twist 243wins and AI’s, and 6 creeds.
 
@Dale Alan ,
Why do you seem so hostile towards me? I only gave an opinion and it's part of the discussion. I guess you don't like it when someone disagrees with you but for me it's not personal, only a discussion. I happen to think a SMK is a bad choice for hunting. You disagree and that's fine.
 
Manufacturers want to sell bullets

As has been talked about before, Hornady AMAXs used to be build and suitable for target and hunting work…..until they came out with the SSTs and all of a sudden AMAXs we’re only good for punching paper.

I’ll also add this observation. Spend any time in the pits at a High Power match watching and hearing all those target bullets impacting the berm 10 feet in front of you and tell us how any mortal animal in the planet would fair if struck by one.
 
I believe the OP may have given up on this post, but I agree with others. Why tempt fate with a projectile that isn’t recommended for hunting when there are so many that are readily available?
 
Can't speak for the OP, but I've also been looking for a 6.5 bullet to load for hunting and the issue is availability. Target bullets are available.....hunting bullets are not. At least not one's I'm familiar with. Hornady, Sierra or Speer. But I've mostly been looking on Midway. Reloading store 100 miles away may have something, but have not checked with them.

So for me, issue would not be forcing a square peg in a round hole.......it's "any old port in a storm". Trying to work with what you can get your hands on. So far, it's been a pass. Continue to wait.

I see this was posted about 60 days ago. Since then, I first found Hornady SST in 123 grains, then later Speer Hot Cor in 140 grains. Both from Midway. Gone now, but not forever. Window of opportunity is opening and closing......you just have to be looking when it does.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top