My EDC is an STI VIP, had a Ranger and there's a Texican in there as well.
I tend to agree with the non-fans on two points:
1. The California thing - mostly because STI wasn't selling anything there anyway. Had they simply, quietly, discontinued the rare LEO sales without the posturing I doubt anybody would have noticed. The press release just stirred the hive. They had given up on getting on CAL DOJ's roster long before the announcement.
2. For the same amount of money as a 2011 one can get a Baer, Wilson or even a Nighthawk. However, I expect us STI drones really don't care. At least I wouldn't know what to do with the butt end of slide that was hand checkered 40 LPI. There may be some that think the 2011 is attractive but personally I buy the things in spite of what they look like rather than because of it. 2011s are known to cause heartburn among 1911 traditionalists as well.
My next semiauto will be another 2011 and I'll once again look wistfully at the Baers, Wilsons, NHs, Browns, SA Pros etc. And once again march past them to get a 2011.
It's impossible to explain and difficult to understand but I'd bet the OP has a real handle on how the STI might be preferred by some even over the other top names in the business that make far prettier products. Methinks Boba Fett is doomed and has, or will be, assimilated. Welcome.