Some thoughts on the M&P Bodyguard 380

Joined
Feb 3, 2005
Messages
3,583
Location
Upper East Tennessee
If you look up reviews on the Bodyguard 380 they're all over the place, plenty of people love them and plenty hate them.

After having mine a few weeks and putting a fair amount of rounds through it, I also have an opinion... so I thought I'd share it... this might get long winded.

It has functioned 100% for me, no jams of any kind, but I haven't tried every brand of cheap ammo on the market either, I've just used Winchester White Box and Hornady Critical Defense. I do reload but I have no plans to reload for 380, no plans really to shoot it enough to make it worth it.... it's a "carry a lot and shoot a little" gun for me...I have others better suited to fun on the range.

I guess I'll cover the part most hate first... the trigger.... it's a long heavy double action only that takes some effort to master, that is both a blessing and a curse... the blessing is that its not cocked at rest, not partially, not half, not anything... it cannot fire without pulling the trigger, period... and that trigger isn't likely to get pulled all the way back by accident... the hammer isn't held under spring pressure and it has a firing pin block as a drop safety... it isn't going to fire like a P320, either because a spring let go or it was dropped.... just can't happen in the BG 380.... that is the only kind of gun I want in my pocket... the curse is, its takes some effort to master.

The safety...I could take it or leave it on this pistol, but I kinda like it being there. On mine, it dang near takes a screwdriver to pry it to the "safe" position, it's really tight and not likely to get turned on by accident.... but it moves to the "fire" position quite easily with a swipe of my thumb (ala 1911), not difficult at all.... though I do keep it off myself, I've taught myself to swipe it during the draw anyway.

Fit in my hand... well, it doesn't... but since I have to carry a gun this small, I've learned how to make it work in my pretty large hands... it'll never be comfy to shoot, but it is sweet to carry and simple to truly conceal.

Accuracy... this, it has in spades! The thing is capable of way better accuracy than a pistol this small should be... given enough time to aim appropriately, I can tear up paper plates at 25 yards quite handily.... but that's not what its for... quick, close combat accuracy is plenty good enough for a couple rounds in the face to end things if the need arises.

More to come... supper is done.
 
Last edited:
More on fit in the hand...

Something that hasn't been an issue for me but keeps happening when my son shoots it is him hitting the mag release and dropping the mag.

Its not a gun defect, it's just the way he holds it, because it doesn't happen to anyone else who has shot it.

I expect this is a pistol that just isn't going to fit some peoples hand right, which is probably true for any really small pistol... I'm glad it works for me though.
 
Ammo differences

With the WWB ammo it runs without jamming, but it ejects brass all over the place... straight up, straight back on my head, forwards, and even a few out to the right like its supposed to.

Often, this is caused by limp wristing, but that isn't the case here because I don't have limp wrists.

I believe it is a combination of the Win brass and the power of the rounds... the ejector protrusion is pretty short on these guns (it is on mine)... the WWB isn't loaded very warm, so the slide velocity is lower and the rim of the brass is inconsistent.

The Hornady Critical Defense stuff comes out and consistently flies off to the right with authority...according to my chrono, it is a bit hotter than the WWB.

Not really an issue, just something that happens.
 
Almost forgot... wanted to comment on the weight of it, being slightly heavier than others in its size range.

That's mostly the steel chassis it has, which fits down into the frame with its nearly full length slide rails, those rails being a contributing factor to the pistols superb accuracy.

It is about 14 ounces fully loaded but carries nicely in a pocket.
 
i recently got a new s&w bg380. ridgerunner665’s review is on target. i am a revolver guy, and shoot/carry a s&w 642. my favorite pocket ccw is a keltec p32. i find the bg380’s trigger pull to be way too long and indistinct for my tastes. the bg380 is reliable, carries well as a pocket ccw and is accurate. after 300+ rounds i don’t regret getting it but am unsure to keep it.
 
I prefer a heavy trigger over a lighter trigger in a self defense handgun or at least a manual safety (1911, striker fired pistols or having to cock a hammer on my SAA clones) that adds an additional step before the handgun can be fired. My Walther PPS would get far more WalkAbout time if it had a manual safety.
 
I'd only ever shot one BG and it was one my dad had picked up for the same purposes stated above. Trigger pull that was atrocious, light strikes and lots of feeding issues. He bought a spring kit someone in a video somewhere recommended and got the trigger pull tolerable. Helped with the light strikes quite a bit too. Still, shooting it reminded me how much I love my P238's.
 
I had considered the BG380 as a DAO option with mostly ideal features:

Ideal features: DAO w/unloaded firing springs mechanism (very safe), steel chassis, should be reliable, safe in a pocket (w/holster)
Not Ideal: reliability concerns, don't need or want thumb safety, experiences with S&W CS as shared above.

If they made them consistently reliable and offered the no laser/no thumb safety model again, I'd probably bite. Never actually handled one.
 
Just picked one up. I put some night sights and talon grips on it. Couple times to the range and it’s been accurate and reliable. Recoil is less than my LCP and about the same as my Glock 42. I like it and plan on carrying it quite a bit.
 
My issue is a S&W Bodyguard is and always has been a "J" frame humpback concealed hammer revolver.
Yeah, Jar, Smith recycled a time honored name. :)

Posters here have this pistol figured out.
-The long trigger pull is a challenge. I'm an old double action revo shooter, so it's not a problem.
-Happy for the safety.....it gets used for things like putting the gun in a lockbox; a quick grab won't find the trigger by accident...though the trigger is deliberate enough, it's not apt to go off anyway. Usually, I just ignore it.
-The gun seems far better made than an LCP, but it is the same size.
-It seems designed for a lot of shooting.

As posted elsewhere; I've two of them...one works perfectly, the other not so much. That is an issue.
Moon
 
Yeah, Jar, Smith recycled a time honored name. :)

Posters here have this pistol figured out.
-The long trigger pull is a challenge. I'm an old double action revo shooter, so it's not a problem.
-Happy for the safety.....it gets used for things like putting the gun in a lockbox; a quick grab won't find the trigger by accident...though the trigger is deliberate enough, it's not apt to go off anyway. Usually, I just ignore it.
-The gun seems far better made than an LCP, but it is the same size.
-It seems designed for a lot of shooting.

As posted elsewhere; I've two of them...one works perfectly, the other not so much. That is an issue.
Moon
And it was a major factor in ending the US involvement in the Vietnam civil war.
 
And it was a major factor in ending the US involvement in the Vietnam civil war.
I recall that photo. The Victor Charley who got a Bodyguard stuck in his ear had done something really brutal, but you're right, it sat badly with our populace.
Moon
 
On the BodyGuard front, my local shop is going to ship it back; the owner is of the opinion that, on a second return, it will be replaced. The shop owner gave me a box of factory .380s, and it short cycled on those as well.
Stay posted.
Moon
 
I rented one once when we were shopping .380's for my girlfriend. I really wanted to like it but the slide bit my hand pretty consistently if I didn't purposely keep my grip low. I have really big hands by most folks standards though. Accuracy wasn't bad and it didn't have any hiccups. In the end I wound up with a 1st gen Ruger LCP and she got a Kahr P380.

My LCP is in really rough shape these days but still runs. If I had to replace it I'd probably go for an LCP II or Max.
 
I believe it is a combination of the Win brass and the power of the rounds... the ejector protrusion is pretty short on these guns (it is on mine)... the WWB isn't loaded very warm, so the slide velocity is lower and the rim of the brass is inconsistent.

The Hornady Critical Defense stuff comes out and consistently flies off to the right with authority...according to my chrono, it is a bit hotter than the WWB.
Hey Ridgerunner, you said you chronoed the WWB ammo; what kind of velocity were you getting. My handloads are doing 925'sec, and they are among the ammo that runs perfectly in the first BG. I'm thinking that a too-strong recoil spring is the issue with the malfing one.
Thanks,
Moon
 
Hey Ridgerunner, you said you chronoed the WWB ammo; what kind of velocity were you getting. My handloads are doing 925'sec, and they are among the ammo that runs perfectly in the first BG. I'm thinking that a too-strong recoil spring is the issue with the malfing one.
Thanks,
Moon
853 fps average for 10 rounds for the WWB...Hornady Critical Defense was 887 fps.
 
My 380 BG with a laser is pretty accurate at 30 feet from a rest, but hand held, good luck. I found a smooth complete trigger pull, not trying to guess or feel when it will break works best for me. It is a point and shoot pistol and certainly not a range gun.

I added some Talon grip material to the grip to protect my candy azz hands.
 
Back
Top