Sort of makes all the "SHTF" discussions moot.

Status
Not open for further replies.

thatguy

Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2004
Messages
1,166
I see many threads about what guns to use or take in an emergency, or disaster, etc. I usually didn't pay much attention to them but after what we've seen following Katrina a thought has come to mind.

Unless there is a total lack of government authority, no influsence from the government at all possible, martial law will be declared and anyone walking around with a rifle or shotgun will be disarmed or shot by U.S. Army or National Guard personnel.

So, I guess the best answer to the "which gun for the SHTF" question is: A concealable handgun because anything over your shoulder or plainly displayed will make you a target for the military patrols and I doubt that they will be interested in hearing about how you're a law-abiding citizen exercising your Second Amendment rights.

Just an observation.
 
My sidearm is a given. So is my rifle.

But whatever the answer of what is best, the short version is you better have something.

I wonder if all the people that used to reply "well, honestly--how likely something like that to happen (and especially the ones that tack on "here in the US") so why do you need that stuff/those guns?" are still running their mouths.

Good point about being able to be discreet from both the "bad guys" and the "GOOD guys".
 
The obvious answer is to get out of Dodge as fast as possible. That way, you probably won't need your guns: and they won't be subject to confiscation by, or be objects of suspicion to, the authorities in the disaster area.
 
Once the Guard has moved in and control the streets it is time to lay a little lower, gun wise. No point adding to their concern.

Now, if you have a functioning neighborhood patrol system set up, you go meet with the local commander and inform him of the fact.

Hopefully he or she will be pragmatic enough to work WITH you and thank you for allowing them to concentrate resources elsewhere.

Here's where something like a common, non-military looking "uniform" could help, blue windbreakers with armbands and the like. It will give the authorities a quick recognition that you and your neighbors are an organized group of responsible citizens, not a pack of looters.
 
I think a 9mm or a 45 would be best, as those are probably the 2 most popular calibers, and you might have to find ammo elsewhere.

That being said, the only pistol I own so far is a makarov, 9x18.
 
Yes but the problem is those few days that there is NO law. Once the NG or local PD have taken control there should be little need for you to be lugging a gun around.

Besides the way I see it in a situation like that your best bet is like PM said and that is to get out of Dodge. If that is not a likely scenario then find someplace to hold up and defend.

There is one other thing PM said that makes lots of sense. The whole goal should be to never need to fire a shot. Lay low, protect yourself and loved ones if necessary but you shouldn't be Ramboing around any way.

My spoiled only child uneducated opinion.

Chris
 
One other thing Katrina has show us is many situations where a very small number of rounds makes the BGs/Rioters turn tail and look for easier prey. This seems to hold true with the theory that most low life predators are looking for easy prey and that having a couple hundred rounds on hand ready to go should you need to defend the homestead is probably plenty.....spend the rest on canned food and water.

Chris
 
Now, if you have a functioning neighborhood patrol system set up, you go meet with the local commander and inform him of the fact.

Hopefully he or she will be pragmatic enough to work WITH you and thank you for allowing them to concentrate resources elsewhere.

If not he's not appreciative, what then?

But it's the right way to go - your patrol can turn to self defense purposes instead of peace keeping when the military arrives. Should still be armed, but not openly - makes the troops nervouse...
 
Recon,
That's why things went so bad. The politicalcritters didn't have the guts to do what was needed. They didn't want to offend anybody, or perhaps they couldn't make a decidion without a poll.
 
It is my understanding that Martial Law can only be declared by an act of the United States Congress. So far that hasn't happened yet. Just because the governor or mayor says on tv that it has been declared doesn't make it so.
 
I have to chime in on this one. The one thing that New Orleans has taught everyone is DON'T RELY ON THE GOVERNMENT. I will not get political on this but there was a total break down from the Mayor, Governor, FEMA and almost everyone. One thing is the sniping from the sidelines is easy when you have 20/20 hindsight. There isn't one person out there running their mouth of how it should have been done that could have made a hill of beans difference had they been in charge.
I would say you should have at least 2 weeks worth of supplies and prepared to defend yourself, family and home with extreme predijust if need be.
As been ruled on several times by the Supreme Court of the United States, the Federal Government, State Government and the Police are not legally required to protect you or your family.
Until the public in general realizes that little known fact you can expect the same lack of response by officials (Both Parties) and the same looting and lawlessness during any major incident like Katrina because things will never change. This type of social behavior will always be there because of the government programs that have created this underclass have made things in general worse.
I wonder what would have happened had the population of New Orleans in general have had a more protective attitude towards their community and been more prepared and armed? I bet the looting would have been minimal.
 
It will be interesting to see if any info is ever posted about a legit use of a firearm in self defence down there in NO.

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/01/n...38400&en=424579c16a2ef81d&ei=5059&partner=AOL

Police and Owners Begin to Challenge Looters
By FELICITY BARRINGER and JERE LONGMAN

NEW ORLEANS, Aug. 31 - In a city shut down for business, the Rite Aid at Oak and South Carrollton was wide open on Wednesday. Someone had stolen a forklift, driven it four blocks, peeled up the security gate and smashed through the front door.

The young and the old walked in empty-handed and walked out with armfuls of candy, sunglasses, notebooks, soda and whatever else they could need or find. No one tried to stop them.

Across New Orleans, the rule of law, like the city's levees, could not hold out after Hurricane Katrina. The desperate and the opportunistic took advantage of an overwhelmed police force and helped themselves to anything that could be carried, wheeled or floated away, including food, water, shoes, television sets, sporting goods and firearms.

Many people with property brought out their own shotguns and sidearms. Many without brought out shopping carts. The two groups have moved warily in and out of each other's paths for the last three days, and the rising danger has kept even some rescue efforts from proceeding.

Because the New Orleans police were preoccupied with search and rescue missions, sheriff's deputies and state police from around Louisiana began to patrol the city, some holding rifles as they rolled through the streets in an armored vehicle.

But on Wednesday night, the mayor ordered about 1,500 city police officers, nearly the entire force, back to their traditional roles.

The looters "are starting to get closer to heavily populated areas," Mayor C. Ray Nagin told The Associated Press, "hotels, hospitals, and we're going to stop it right now."

Gov. Kathleen Babineaux Blanco said she was "furious" about the looting.

"What angers me the most is disasters tend to bring out the best in everybody, and that's what we expected to see," Ms. Blanco said at a news conference. "Instead, it brought out the worst."

All sizes and types of stores, from Wal-Mart to the Rite Aid to the St. Vincent de Paul thrift shop, turned into bazaars of free merchandise.

Some frightened homeowners took security into their own hands.

John Carolan was sitting on his porch in the thick, humid darkness just before midnight Tuesday when three or four young men, one with a knife and another with a machete, stopped in front of his fence and pointed to the generator humming in the front yard, he said.

One said, "We want that generator," he recalled.

"I fired a couple of rounds over their heads with a .357 Magnum," Mr. Carolan recounted Wednesday. "They scattered."

He smiled and added, "You've heard of law west of the Pecos. This is law west of Canal Street."

Though no one excused the stealing, many officials were careful not to depict every looter as a petty thief.

"Had New York been closed off on 9/11, who can say what they would have done?" said Cynthia Hedge-Morrell, vice president of the New Orleans City Council. "When there's no food, no water, no sanitation, who can say what you'd do? People were trying to protect their children. I don't condone lawlessness, but this doesn't represent the generous people of New Orleans."

One woman outside a Sav-a-Center on Tchoupitoulas Street was loading food, soda, water, bread, peanut butter and canned food into the trunk of a gray Oldsmobile.

"Yes, in a sense it's wrong, but survival is the name of the game," said the woman, who would not identify herself. "I've got six grandchildren. We didn't know this was going to happen. The water is off. We're trying to get supplies we need."

Jimmy Field, one of the state's five public service commissioners, said supply and repair trucks were being slowed down by people looking for food and water. Some would not go on without police escorts.

"Right now we're hoping for more federal assistance to get the level of civil disturbance down," Mr. Field said.

One police officer was shot Tuesday trying to stop looting, but he was expected to survive.

An emergency medical vehicle that was taking a Baton Rouge police officer who had been shot last month from a hospital back to his hometown was shot at on the way out of New Orleans on Tuesday.

East Baton Rouge Parish officials agreed to send 20 buses with special weapons and tactics officers to help evacuate New Orleanians, but only if a state trooper was also placed on each bus. The plan was scuttled.

"I told them I don't mind committing drivers and vehicles, but I wasn't going to put our people in harm's way," said Walter Monsour, the chief administrative officer of the parish.

Besides the strain of having to rescue survivors, the police are bereft of much of their equipment, buildings and essential communications. The Police Department was scheduled to receive new radios on Wednesday night to coordinate its activities, said Lt. Col. Mark S. Oxley, a spokesman for the state police.

Charles C. Foti Jr., the Louisiana attorney general, said a temporary detention center and courthouse would be established somewhere outside New Orleans. "We will be ready to accept you in our system, and teach you about rules and order," Mr. Foti warned looters.

On Tuesday, the state police sent in 200 troopers trained in riot control, said Lt. Lawrence J. McLeary, a spokesman for the state police.

He said that the "nervous energy" in New Orleans reminded him of the 1968 Democratic National Convention in Chicago. "I've never seen anything like that in Louisiana," Lieutenant McLeary said.

With no officers in sight, people carried empty bags, shopping carts and backpacks through the door of the Rite Aid on Wednesday and left with them full. The forklift was still in the doorway. As they came and went, the looters nodded companionably to one another.

Paul Cosma, 47, who owns a nearby auto shop, stood outside it along with a reporter and photographer he was taking around the neighborhood. He had pistols on both hips.

Suddenly, he stepped forward toward a trio of young men and grabbed a pair of rusty bolt cutters out of the hands of one of them. The young man pulled back, glaring.

Mr. Cosma, never claiming any official status, eventually jerked the bolt cutters away, saying, "You don't need these."

The young man and his friends left, continuing the glare. A few minutes later, they returned and mouthed quiet oaths at Mr. Cosma, and his friend Art DePodesta, an Army veteran, who was carrying a shotgun and a pistol.

Mr. Cosma stared back, saying nothing. Between the two sides, a steady trickle of looters came and went, barely giving any of them a look.

Felicity Barringer reported from New Orleans for this article, and Jere Longman from Baton Rouge, La. Susan Saulny contributed reporting from Baton Rouge, and Joseph B. Treaster from New Orleans.
 
18.5" barreled pistol grip shotgun under a trench coat...

~TMM
 
1) Martial law has not been declared

2) If martial law is ever declared you have no business walking around armed or not. Stay on your property.

2a) Most states (I know PA does) has a law that covers carrying in a state of emergency, like NO is in right now.

§6107. Prohibited conduct during emergency.

No person shall carry a firearm, rifle or shotgun upon the public streets or upon any public property during an emergency proclaimed by a state or municipal governmental executive unless that person is:

(1) Actively engaged in a defense of that person’s life or property from peril or threat.

(2) Licensed to carry firearms under section 6109 (relating to licenses) or is exempt from licensing under section 6106(b) (relating to firearms not to be carried without a license).

3) If martial law were ever to be put into play, no one is going to come searching for your weapons.
 
You know I wonder if there is such a thing as Martial Law in LA. Remember while 49 States are based on British Common Law, LA is French. I don't know much about the rule of law there.
 
OK, many resposnes.

Yes, I totally agree that if there is no police or military presence you had better be armed.

I seriously doubt that the military will work with armed citizens. The military always disarms citizens in areas where they are enforcing the law. The military doesn't permit citizens to go about armed when they are in charge.

I know nothing about the process of declaring martial law. I had heard on the news that both MS and LA were under martial law. Congress didn't do it so either someone else has that authority or the news media was wrong. I am fairly sure the governor has that power.

If under martial law you may in fact have business walking about off your property. What if you aren't on your property when the disaster hits? You may be looking for food or water or a way out. I would not sit still because martial law was in effect.

I would hope the military wouldn't "come searching for your weapons" but I wouldn't be shocked at it, either. Like I said, when the military is enforcing the law in an area their first action is usually disarmament. Even if they don't come looking, certainly if they see you walking around with a gun it will be taken.

I'm with the folks saying get out before the feces strikes the circulating cooling device. If the city says leave, I am gone, baby! Take what provisions I can carry, a couple of key firearms, lock up the rest and head for the hills.
 
Looking around the web, FOXNEWS retracted its statement that NO was under martial law. FOX apologized for the incorrect report.

The Attorney General of LA also 'clarified' early reports of martial law. He said that no part of LA was under martial law and that, in fact, the term 'martial law' does not exist in Louisiana law.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top