RPRNY
Member
I am not much of a semi-auto fan. In fact, full disclosure, my interest in handguns is almost exclusively revolvers. However, I have owned a Kimber full size 1911 and have my father's 1943 issue Government 1911. I also owned another GI 1911 that has moved on. I understand the 1911 and I like it. But, I am aware that I may be a bit of a stick in the mud, old fuddy-duddy on this issue.
I am looking for a somewhat compact semi-auto in 45 ACP. I may concealed carry it at times but this will by no means be a primary carry pistol, and will do duty as both a range gun and a woods carry. My first interest is the RIA 1911 CS, Lipsey's special run in FDE Cerakote (I like the RIA 1911 but their pseudo-Parkerized finish is not nice imo). But I admit that I don't really know much about striker fired pistols. I had a look at the Ruger American pistol this weekend (didn't get to shoot it) and liked the trigger a lot. I will shoot before deciding so just looking for experience and information at this point, preferably from those familiar with both and not violently partisan.
So, is it possible to have a dispassionate, factual discussion of the pros and cons of a semi-compact (let's say 3.5"- 4" barrel) 45 ACP pistol of the 1911 variety vs a striker fired pistol? I am looking for education rather than affirmation. Thanks very much for your knowledge and assistance.
I am looking for a somewhat compact semi-auto in 45 ACP. I may concealed carry it at times but this will by no means be a primary carry pistol, and will do duty as both a range gun and a woods carry. My first interest is the RIA 1911 CS, Lipsey's special run in FDE Cerakote (I like the RIA 1911 but their pseudo-Parkerized finish is not nice imo). But I admit that I don't really know much about striker fired pistols. I had a look at the Ruger American pistol this weekend (didn't get to shoot it) and liked the trigger a lot. I will shoot before deciding so just looking for experience and information at this point, preferably from those familiar with both and not violently partisan.
So, is it possible to have a dispassionate, factual discussion of the pros and cons of a semi-compact (let's say 3.5"- 4" barrel) 45 ACP pistol of the 1911 variety vs a striker fired pistol? I am looking for education rather than affirmation. Thanks very much for your knowledge and assistance.