mpmarty,
Very good post, and I didn't even think about it before I voted. I voted "mostly good, some bad apples." Upon further reflection though, there is some real changes in how I'd vote based on where I am. I grew up in and around Boston. Almost every experience was a bad one, even including harassment and assault on me by a cop. Now I live in Oregon. Since I got here, every experience has been a good one. It obviously helped change my views. I'm not sure what to say, except anecdotally, I think you're spot on.
Maybe big city cops become jaded because of the overwhelming crime, pettiness, hate, filth, anger, angst, stupidity. Hell, I became jaded, and I saw a lot less of it than the cops do. Now I live in an Oregon city of about 50,000 where a lot of people are down to earth, optimistic, semi-rural people. I think these environmental differences can't help but make a difference.
I'll give you a good point/counterpoint:
1) I remember standing right near the Government Center (where there is often a significant police presence) in Boston when a guy walked up to a bike rack with a pair of cutters, cut about 5 locks, picked up the bikes, and walked away. We all just looked at him like, "huh, that's interesting." A few people even chuckled. Certainly noone called for police.
2) In Oregon, I gave my wife a really nice Klein mountain bike, and it got stolen. Being the jaded city punk that I am, I told my wife, "Well, you'll never see that sucker again." Of course, two days later a really nice female cop calls my wife and says, "We found your bike in some meth-head's bathtub, come and identify it." (don't know about the bathtub thing) So, being jaded still, I say, "Well, we'll get a frame out of it at least." Waddya know, we got the bike back in one complete piece. I was astonished. More importantly, the cops were nice and polite almost to the point of being effusive. I mean, they we're honestly happy to get my wife's bike back. Even if the Boston cops had gotten it back, we'd be processed like so much meat.
Anyway, I think you're on to something. And I'm staying in Oregon. period. You couldn't drag me, pay me, or even kill me and ship my body back to Boston after living out here.
Noops