Thoughts on current KaBars?

NIGHTLORD40K

Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2015
Messages
12,943
Location
Nostramo (in absentia), Segmentum Ultima
So, with the demise of OKC, Ive been looking at new Kabars and the website certainly seems to display a nice varied lineup at reasonable prices. Mostly claimed to be USA made - though, curiosly, they've recently removed the USA stamp from many ricasso stamps....🤔

Specifically, Im looking at the traditional "short" model.

Anyone have a recent KaBar and how do you like it?
 
I bought a long and short USMC Ka-Bar not that long ago, but both were LNIB.
Both had the Oleans, USA stamp on the ricasso.
These feel OK, but they just don't have that BTDT feel that the originals had.
-And I haven't handled any imported copies... .
Which one you like better? The long one seems a little bulky for general woods carry.
 
Seeing how I had both out, this pic is for you. Shows how much larger the standard is compared to the short version.

View attachment 1169749
Pretty sure thats an Aircrew Survival and Escape Knife (ASEK) pattern next to the KABAR blade, but for comparison it illustrates the point as well, lol.

The ASEK is actually my go-to kit knife at the moment, and its fine, but Im thinking of replacing it with the compact KABAR.

I bought one of the last OKC SP2s and its a bit underwhelming. Have a SOG Seal Pup too- but I maintain a razor edge on that one and its more of a dedicated fighter than a general field knife.
 
Im looking at the traditional "short" model.

???

Short model of what KaBar product? What use?

The Beckers? Whatever you want to put them through they'll come through.

The Eks? Not a general use knife as much as a purpose built fighter.

The "USMC" type knives? Not state of the craft any longer with their narrow tangs.
 
Last edited:
IMO the traditional Marine fighting knife is not the best choice for most uses, even the shorter version. I have two just for historical and nostalgic reasons. I bought one with leather handle and sheath. Someone gave me one with rubber handles and plastic sheath.

The KaBar Becker knives are a very well made and there are several of them that are very nice.

The BK 16 is one of my favorite fixed blades. I stripped off the coating, replaced the handles with micarta and put it in a leather sheath. Bottom knife is also a KaBar


IMG_1739.JPG

The Kephart is a fine outdoors knife as well.

 
Oops, should've said for size comparison to the ASEK. It's basically the same size as the short version of the Ka-Bar.

Have Ka-Bar on the brain after finding the blank and thinking about what to do with it.
 
Kabar and Benchmade regularly trade top spot for favorite knife brand. And that is only because Kabar doesn't make a reasonably priced, US made folding knife for every day use. After having a Chinese made Warthog folder explode in my pocket, I won't own another Chinese Kabar. Doesn't matter what the stamp says. But a Taiwan folder like the Mules or the Jarosz Tanto are just great pocket knives.
 
Kabar and Benchmade regularly trade top spot for favorite knife brand.
Spyderco, CRKT, Cold Steel individually top KaBar in sales volume. Financials from Zoominfo - Case 95M$, Buck 79M$, KAI 38M$, SOG 21M$, Gerber 28M$, Microtech 20M$, Spyderco 21M$, Benchmade 95M$, kaBar ... 5M$


"favorite" might be subjective but millions of dollars is an objective measure
 
Last edited:
What are going to use this for?

If you just want it for historic purposes, then get a KBar brand USMC Fighting Utility knife without reservations.

If you want a hard use survival knife ... there are far newer designs that have incorporated all the lessons learned.
 
Its going on the equipment belt in my go-bag, so it needs to be tough and versatile. Chopping/sawing wood not a large concern since its an urban/suburban environment. Doesn't need to be a good skinner either. Anticipated uses are cutting webbing, hoses, PVC pipe, and similar materials with a secondary defensive role.
Corrosion resistance a bonus since its going to spend long periods of time in a hot trunk, though I do clean and oil my go-gear regularly.
 
The Becker BK-2's are stout knives, the Camillus version had one with a partially serrated blade.

Not sure if the Ka-Bar Olean version kept the serrated version.

s-l1600 (23).jpg
 
I do pack a pair of finger/ring saws. The ASEK sawback actually does a good job on PVC as well, though not so good on wood. I haven't tried the SP2 on PVC yet, but my example does have nice, sharp serrations unlike some have reported finding.
 
Better to test than find out in a crisis something doesn't work.
Well, the SP2 isn't going to make the cut for a number of other reasons so its kinda moot. Its still an OK knife, but it was cheap and shows it.
Im keeping the ASEK until I find something better.
Something like this but with a sawback would be perfect-
 
I'm a fan of the K-bar, carried one almost all my life (fancied myself a "knife-fighter", although I really had no formal training...a legend in my own mind) before I ever carried a firearm.

Also carried it as a hunting knife for years, up until recently, even gutted a cougar with mine when I discovered it was the only knife I had with me.

After getting deep into bush craft and wilderness survival I have found that the K-bar just won't hold up to hard use, especially splitting wood. Little stuff, yes, but to make a fireboard for friction fire starting it won't take that abuse for long. Or at least mine didn't. (but I fixed it) My handle got real loose real fast.

For fighting, (people or animals) I think the design is great. You can/could skin or gut an animal with it not problem. It will work. Light camp chores it is good, and I sure can get a nice razor edge on mine.

My "solution" is to carry two knives, one for skinning/gutting, and a bigger one for heavy use. Actually I carry more than that, large knife, small knife, pocket knife at least. Usually bring a filet knife too, as they are so super light. Oh and a multi-tool with a knife. !!! Of course there are knives that probably cover all bases, with a bit of a compromise on each base, but I'd not want to leave the pocket knife at home.

Anyhow, got off track there, but regardless of the difference in quality between the new and old ones, the design of the knife. or of the handle leaves something to be desired for real torture testing. For anything short of wood splitting or "batoning", great knife.
 
Back
Top