Man alive thats alot of polish. When I start with fresh corn cob I use 1 cap ful of Nu-Finish "thats about 1 tablespoon", after a bunch of tumbling I'll add another half to one capful and when thats done working it time to replace with new cob.
BTW 5000 pcs tumbled with each new bowl full of fresh media is nothing, should get double or more. Just my 2 cents.