Styx
Member
- Joined
- Dec 11, 2014
- Messages
- 3,302
Frank, I read the decision. I'm fully aware of the Majority's opinion, and why they came to their conclusion.
I don't think you understood the gist of my prior posts. What I am saying, and what even you admitted to, is that no evidence was precented into the record pretaining to the carry permit applicants. Yet, the Majority made assumptions based on information that wasn't submitted. The dissenting Judge even made this point, and he isn't wrong.
Again, I read the decision. I know that the Majority disagrees. I know that they believe it to be irrelevant, and I read why. All I was pointing out is that the dissenting Judge does have a point, and when/if ends up in an en banc hearing or even SCOTUS, these are issues that may cause problems in the case.
For example, if in the en banc hearing or at SCOTUS, say the Judges rebuke the opinion that 134-9 is unconstitutional. At that point, they'll may look to see if it's implementation is unconstitutional.
What I'm getting at and all I'm trying to say is that I want them to cross as many t's and dot as many i's before this case gets kicked up.
I don't think you understood the gist of my prior posts. What I am saying, and what even you admitted to, is that no evidence was precented into the record pretaining to the carry permit applicants. Yet, the Majority made assumptions based on information that wasn't submitted. The dissenting Judge even made this point, and he isn't wrong.
Again, I read the decision. I know that the Majority disagrees. I know that they believe it to be irrelevant, and I read why. All I was pointing out is that the dissenting Judge does have a point, and when/if ends up in an en banc hearing or even SCOTUS, these are issues that may cause problems in the case.
For example, if in the en banc hearing or at SCOTUS, say the Judges rebuke the opinion that 134-9 is unconstitutional. At that point, they'll may look to see if it's implementation is unconstitutional.
What I'm getting at and all I'm trying to say is that I want them to cross as many t's and dot as many i's before this case gets kicked up.