I have had a p22 for over a year, fired many boxes of Wal*Mart Federal 550-bulk packs of ammo through it. Take it to the range every time. Been shooting a box a month lately since centerfire is pricey.
Re: the above comments:
1.
It's a pain to disassemble and reassemble. I find it annoying.
Having the "target" model I find that my faux compensator block comes loose occasionally which means my front sight is floating around until I tighten it down.
Answer: Well, the long barrel/Fauxpensator is what makes it a chore to take down to clean. The 3.42" barrel model is simplicity, I can take it apart and put it back together again in less than a minute. The only "tricky" thing is actually to use the tool that comes with the gun to line up the recoil spring when you put the slide back on, the tool is a little plastic rod that if you didn't know better you'd think was a leftover piece of scrap.
2.
The last time I took it to the range I switched ammo on it, running Federal Lightning, and it wouldn't feed more than 3-4 rounds without a malfunction. This pistol has already seen at least 2,000 rounds -- we should be past any break-in period. Worked fine the last time I took it out with Remington bulk-pack stuff though.
Answer: The P22 can be finicky with ammo, like any blowback gun can, I'll say that is true, but again, the $10 a box W*M bulk Federal has never caused me any trouble with CCI, Remington or Federal. I had a fail to feed the first round from a new magazine if you use the slide release, that went away if I slingshot the slide. Now with about 2000 through it that has gone away and it cycles like oiled glass. If you think a P22 is bad you should try a Jennings J22. However, mine is just fine.
3.
Slide refuses to lock open any more on an empty mag.
Answer: Sounds like you wore out the plastic follower pin on the side of the mag possibly. Odd. Mine has no signs of wear here or in the slide and it never fails to lock open. Maybe more cleaning or more oiling?
4.
There has been at least two posts on here regarding a complete breaking of a slide on a P22 here.
Answer: I bet there has; early P22s had problems that Walther has acknowleged ...and all Glock 40's kaboom, all beretta slides crack, etc. Again, with the early guns there were known problems but those bugs are worked out now. Would you rather have a S&W 22A and have to use a recoil buffer to keep the frame from cracking?
5.
I have twice been at the range with my P22 and switched pistols with somebody shooting a Ruger .22. In both instances I shot better with the Ruger than I did my own pistol.
In my early days of owning it I found myself frequently engaging the safety on accident. I have seen other shooters do this too. That's annoying.
Answer: Sounds like the Ruger is the pistol for you, not a P22. Different strokes for different folks. And what, you think a Ruger is *EASY* to field strip and clean, easier than a P22??
How the heck do you "accidentally" engage the safety on the slide while firing? With what? Pulling it out of a pocket, maybe.
6.
The ONLY good thing this pistol has going for it is that the slide acts like a centerfire pistol. I bought it for that reason alone, to use as a training tool for myself and because it would give newbies I take to the range at least some semblance of a regular manual of arms before they transition to a centerfire. Big mistake. I don't have a single centerfire that has the issues that this pistol does.
Answer: Odd, that's why *I* bought one, and so far have trained 4 people to shoot with it with no problems, except for one guy who kept forgetting the safety was on and wondered why it didn't fire. Again, I have no problems with mine and actually I haven't cleaned it for over 1000 rounds just so I can see what WILL be a problem. So far, no issues, and I have even taken to firing some nasty range-dropped misc .22's I pick out of the weeds with it to try to force a reaction. So far, it eats everything I can get into the chamber.
7.
When it works, it's fun. Unfortunately, it doesn't always work. And the slide might just snap in half on you.
Answer: When it works, it's fun. Mine always works. And as for the frame "snap in half"... well, all Glocks KB. All Beretta slides crack and take off your face. All Taurus handguns jam. ETc ETc. Use good ammo and use the gun responsibly, buy a new model one and not a used one. The early ones had problems, yes. Newer ones, not.
The ONLY thing I can complain about is that in the short barrel a .22LR has not so much mass and it can be more difficult to keep on point of aim just because it is light and easy to move and the bullet itself is also light. At 30 feet I figure if I can keep 4" groups with concentration that's good for a plinker. I have targets that look like shotgun test group targets. But hey, it's great for training and triggertime and it's cheap plinking, and truth to be told, when I stop worrying about hitting bullseyes with it and instead focus on jumping pop cans and empty ammo boxes around on the backstop I can hit better than 50% of the time.