What's the dirtiest you've ever let your guns get? Let's See 'em!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dr.Zubrato

Member
Joined
May 12, 2009
Messages
400
Pertains to carbon, the elements, dings, and scratches on your pistols and rifles.

Recently for fun, I decided to give my firearms a light kick in the pants to show my love for them, and to see how far they will go with zero cleaning, and minimal lubrication.

Let my AR go a little over 2.2k rounds. First 1k fired over 2 day course, lubed three times with froglube,once before firing, at ~700 rounds, once again before putting it away for ~4 weeks. Next 1k rounds, lubed about every 400 rounds. Lubrication was applied with 2 drops of frog lube into the cam pin slot, and only once through the exhaust ports. Next time I will remember to add more lube through the exhaust ports.
Zero malfunctions, or loss of accuracy. Still ringing printer paper sized steel at 400-500m with boring predictability. For reference, I am shooting my handloads, 55gr FMJBT with 27.2gr CFE223 and an H2 buffer in a BCM LW middy.
When the rifle got too hot to hold(happened more than a few times), gave the barrel a light dunk in the pond :D

Wanted to push it further, but at this point I had carbon/froglube pushing itself out of most nooks/crannies of the rifle. And I mean it, operating the charging handle, getting a magwell grip, or even getting a proper cheekweld resulted in carbon gunk on my hands, face, and forearms where it shot out from between the receivers. The magazines around the feedlips and front spine were pretty nasty so I made a habit of smearing them on the grass.
Upon inspection when cleaning, one of the gas rings had thinned down, and either broke or burned away..
Still ran fine. For this AR it's about the 6-7K round mark I believe, so I replaced the gas rings and she's squared away.

I've taken my G19 to ~4-5k rounds, with incredibly boring reliability. Around every 500-600 rounds I take a cleaning brush with chore boy to the barrel for safety reasons, although I only get very minimal leading. Around this time I add 1 drop of froglube to the barrel lug/around the barrel where I'm holding it to clean it. My reloads are quite smokey, I cast and shoot my own 125gr lead reloads with 3.7-3.8gr titegroup to simulate my+P carry ammo, and tumble lube with 45/45/10.
To put it short, I would not shoot these at an indoor range, andi think it's hilarious seeing a glock look like it's shooting blackpowder cowboy action match, BUT I shoot for pennies per round and I can deal with the smoke for the trigger time I get.
At around the 3k round mark, the slide failed to lock back on an empty magazine. This happened again at the 4k round mark with a different magazine. No futher malfunctions after this point, but I did start receiving hot brass to the face pretty hard. Actually had a 9mm case head mark on my forehead I wasn't aware of for most of the day, sorta funny..
At this point, the glock 19 has had north of 10-12k cast +P reloads, and NATO ammo. Cleaning required light scraping around the extractor claw, around the barrel hood. Upon a detailed strip of the firearm all the trigger assembly pieces were polished to a mirror like finish once the carbon/dirt/grime was removed. Trigger feels maaaybe 10% better after cleaning.
Replaced the return spring assembly, since I can feel the gun knocking my hands around quite a bit more, and I'm getting brass to the face pretty hard.

Sorry no pics of the glock, it was very subtle fouling, and still looked relatively clean on the outside, compared to the show put on by the AR. There are areas of carbon buildup pretty much everywhere on the inside except for the breechface, and areas scraped clean by the barrel hood. Carbon fouling underneath the barrel hood, on the extractor, and the underside of the slide in non-critical areas did not impede function, nor did it look as if it would do so in the future.
One picture is at 1k rounds, the other is just below 2k rounds. As you can tell, it used to have words on it ;)

If you've made it this far in the thread, congrats!
Everyone, post your pictures and stories of your dirty guns, any make, model, or creed!
Just no safe queens..
So let's see the carbon, mud, scratches, and good honest wear on your guns!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4571.jpg
    IMG_4571.jpg
    92.1 KB · Views: 202
  • IMG_4443.jpg
    IMG_4443.jpg
    84.3 KB · Views: 193
  • IMG_4709.jpg
    IMG_4709.jpg
    271.7 KB · Views: 145
Well I don't have any dirty guns to show, but Im glad to hear an AR can successfully take that many rds of abuse and keep on firing.
 
I don't have any pics, but I have done similar things.

My AR is a mid length upper built by ADCO Firearms in Ohio on a White Oaks upper with a Danial Defense CHF barrel and a Colt C marked mil spec bolt and carrier. I have taken it out to 1500 rounds without cleaning or lubing. I originally used used Gunzilla before starting. I was shooting a mix of reloads worked up with H4895, IMR 4895 and 4064. No problems. I cleaned it up after that. It even feeds and ejects TULA steel reliably. I recently ran 100 rounds through it to see if I would have any problems. I have no plans on cleaning the rifle, but I did inspect after shooting the Tula. The ammo is very dirty. I recently started using Mobil One Synthetic to see if the rifle will keep on ticking with that.

My Kimber Custom II I have taken out to 1000 rounds before having malfunctions. I was shooting 230 grain cast loaded with Unique. It is a very dirty load. Like the original post, I got a kick out of an automatic that was so sooty it looked like I was shooting black powder. I had someone come down the line at the range and ask me what my black powder load was for my 1911 LOL :D. I use Wilson Combat magazines and Mobil One Synthetic. When I finally cleaned the piece you couldn't tell that the feed ramps were polished or that it had a stainless barrel. There was no leading.
 
I didn't take pics, but I put 5k (factory ammo) through a Series I Kimber without cleaning it. I would lube it, and wipe down the outside, but that's it.

After a few cans of brake cleaner and a whole lot of elbow grease, I gave up and had it bead blasted. Good thing its stainless.
 
I can't post pictures from my phone but my daily carry P3AT was cleaned once....a very long time ago. I blow it out with compressed air now and then and it gets fired for two/three rounds every week or so. I can guarantee this is one filthy firearm but it functions 100%, every time, anywhere, in any condition! I carry it in a Desantis pocket holster and it digests Blazer Brass FMJ like a deer to corn.
 
I really never let my guns get that dirty or let them go too long without cleaning them. Put 250 rounds through my Mossberg semi-auto shotgun once just to see how well it would hold up. Did just fine with a lot of different loads and never missed a beat though it did get rather hot to the touch and very dirty in the process.
 
i had a full auto AR15 and a 22lr upper/ceiner kit back when 22lr bulk packs were $9-12 at walmart. God only knows how many rounds i put through it. it was pretty well sludge inside. i don't know what makes 22lr so dirty, but the combination of that grit and the blow back, and me squirting slip2k in there when it started to slow down just made it about as bad as i can imagine.
 
I don't have a Dirty story.... but long ago, when i was a teenager My Father once sprayed Pam cooking spray as a "lubricant" on a semi auto 22LR.

about 8 months later he attempted to use the gun again..... as you can imagine, the action was pretty well glued shut.

I never let my guns get overly dirty, nor do I let him clean them
 
AR's need oil, not cleaning
The piston system is self cleaning, like your car engine.

That beign said I've never cleaned my ARs, I only add oil and wipe down the gunk on the outside.
 
My R55 Benchmark got very dirty a month or two ago (EDTA: actually these pictures are from 2 years back). It has a suppressor and I fired about 1000 rounds of RWS target rifle through it with no cleaning.

Here's the bolt:

_bolt_01_zps62dbe01a.jpg

And here is the receiver:

_bolt_02_zps0c67ef9a.jpg

The bolt was not coming all the way forward and I was getting some failure to fire.
I wonder why....
 
I refuse to let my guns get dirty. I dont clean them during the season but thats as far as I'll go.

My uncle on the other hand didnt clean his 12 Gauge in 10+ years. When I tried to clean it for him there was so much junk it broke my rod:uhoh:

Took me almost 2 hours to clean, I removed all the gunpowder but uncovered ungodly amounts of pitting:barf:

I will some times leave my Rifles for a month or 2, But I wont leave my shotguns over a week.
 
I let the AR go for a couple thousand rounds, just to see what would happen. For awhile, I was shooting the 10/22 faster than I could clean it, so I pretty much stopped bothering to. For years.

No photos. I'm evoking the "No Pics or it Didn't Happen" clause
 
Excellent work, gentlemen!

Despite what others may think, a rifle that sits around in a safe all day, isn't nearly as loved as one that gets hard use and earns the trust of it's owner!

Odd job, looks like it took a lot of hard work gettin to that point :D
I wish my state allowed silencers...:(

As for AR's being self-cleaning, I don't really agree. I do think you could keep an AR running for a protracted period of time, and not clean it like Filthy 14 from BCM, but you're reaching a point where the lubrication you're adding is basically flushing the carbon or dirt away, and you're going to have to lubricate your rifle pretty often to keep it operational, which is sub optimal compared to a clean and lubricated rifle.

So now, while cleaning isnt necessary, maintenance and inspection of wear items like springs, locking lugs, bolt assembly, and gas rings at appropriate wear intervals definitely is.

I could have kept the test going, and I feel confident it would have reached 3-4k rounds trouble free, but I just didn't want to look like an 18th century chimney sweep every time I handled the rifle or mags. :evil:
 
Odd job, looks like it took a lot of hard work gettin to that point

Yep, it was a lot of rounds. I found there is a big difference between shooting it suppressed and without the suppressor. It gets dirtier much faster with the suppressor attached.
 
years back I wanted to fire my Stainless Gold Match 45 Kimber to find out how dirty it would get till it failed.

after each range session I would drag 3 times a snake up the mag well, over the feed ramp and out the barrel.

after 2000 rounds it was cycling a little slower

after 4000 rounds it was slower still but still functioning 100%
accuracy was still as always -- 1.5" @25 yards but the gun
was just becoming to dirty to handle.

my Sporter H-Bar ( 1/7 twist) has but 2000 rounds in total and gets cleaned, fired & cleaned twice a year. it is zeroed for 300 meters and goes with to the range with a M96 and a K31.

nice to see evidence that the Barbie Guns can run dirty :p
 
Here is my Charles Daly (Armscor) EMS after shooting over 1000 rounds of Wolf 230gr FMJ back in the good old days when you could buy it for ~$120/1000 delivered.

I shoot a lot more than I clean so this is only a little worse than normal as I don't usually run 'em that wet.

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • 10301597_10152187289938235_3933008240288963660_n.jpg
    10301597_10152187289938235_3933008240288963660_n.jpg
    41 KB · Views: 51
Its gone now ( the dirt ) but last year on opening day I went down a hill face and into a river.

308 went RIGHT into the mud, mere milliseconds before me.

Was dirty. Glad I don't have pics of that, it took days to clean it right.
 
Wow!

I dunno...we were raised by Dads and uncles who had fought in WWII, and we were never allowed to go to sleep at night until all dirty guns were cleaned and oiled.
Same philosophy when I was in the Army in the late '60s.
Old habits die hard.

Actually it's very satisfying work, but to each his own.

Tinpig
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top