Which Make

[dispatch55126]

I have an itch to get a new BP pistol. Given the poll above, why would you get the particular make? I like the original colt design but I already have one so a top strap is needed. I also plan on getting a conversion cylinder for indoor shooting.

I already have a 1851 Confederate Navy and like the balance but getting a Ruger would have the "American" stamp and local repairs, if needed.

 

[MikeKeyW]

But the lines of an 1860 Navy are so nice, but then there's the Walker...
You don't know what you've gotten yourself into!

 

[dispatch55126]

I've already got the 1851 and a Hawkens. The problem is I can't shoot it most of the year unless I drive to my farm. A conversion cylinder will at least let me shoot locally.

 

[Timthinker]

RUGER! You knew I would say that based on my previous postings. The Ruger Old Army seems like the most durable and accurate revolver of those you specified. I hope this helps.


Timthinker

 

[arcticap]

I agree that if you want a conversion cylinder then go for the Ruger first.

 

[madcratebuilder]

You could buy a Uberti or pietta 1858 and a conversion cylinder for what they are asking for the ROA. However the ROA is a far superior pistol, particularly the metallurgy. I have both Uberti and Pietta new model army's and the lock works are a little on the soft side. Nothing that can't be fixed with kasenit.

 

[dispatch55126]

Follow up question. How reliable are the conversions? I'm not looking for drop dead HD reliability, but will I spend more time screwing around with the parts than actually pulling the trigger?