Why single action?
- Thread starter UltimateReloader
- Start date
- Status
I can shoot big bore cartridges from SA sixguns, whereas S&W N-frames and Ruger Redhawks are too big for my hands. (too long of a reach to the trigger in DA mode) I can reach the trigger of a Super Redhawk, but that is a m-a-s-s-i-v-e sixgun, not a carry gun.
Recoil is more pleasant from SA sixguns than DA, all else being equal.
Also, SA sixguns tend to "hang" more comfortably from the belt, than many DA revolvers and autoloaders, particularly double-stack-magazine autoloaders.
As others have said, shooting is not all about defense, defense, and defense. Some of us like handguns for other reasons, and an SA sixgun can fulfill those other reasons, and still be far from useless for defense.
And, amen to reading passages from thy Skeeter scriptures.
Recoil is more pleasant from SA sixguns than DA, all else being equal.
Also, SA sixguns tend to "hang" more comfortably from the belt, than many DA revolvers and autoloaders, particularly double-stack-magazine autoloaders.
As others have said, shooting is not all about defense, defense, and defense. Some of us like handguns for other reasons, and an SA sixgun can fulfill those other reasons, and still be far from useless for defense.
And, amen to reading passages from thy Skeeter scriptures.
rocinante
Member
If I was dropped off on an island and told I would not coming back but I could take one pistol with ammo it would be my single action ruger vaquero 357. I don't think you could break it. A very important quality.
fflgundealers.net
Member
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2009
- Messages
- 17
popbang,
I applaud you for actually carrying a SA! What kind of holster do you have?
FFLGunDealers.net
I applaud you for actually carrying a SA! What kind of holster do you have?
FFLGunDealers.net
You hit nail squarely! If for self defense and casual shooting, take whatever fits you better. But for serious business like hiking in a wilderness or hunting, this is where larger bore (41 or more) in strong SA with 4-5/8” or 6-1/2” barrel really shines; moderate weight and size with lot of firepower. Just make sure that all screws are secured. O yeah, #5 base pin would be VERY nice addition.
DNS
Member
I'm a big fan of Gene 'n' Roy; collect their books and moves too.
I do believe I have every story by Louis Lamour.
I like the history of the old west so I guess thats why single actions just seem to feel right in my hand.
I've got others but the SA revolvers get used the most.
BTW, my ten year old daughter is also loving her .22 SA and watching Gene and Roy with her dad
Mike
I do believe I have every story by Louis Lamour.
I like the history of the old west so I guess thats why single actions just seem to feel right in my hand.
I've got others but the SA revolvers get used the most.
BTW, my ten year old daughter is also loving her .22 SA and watching Gene and Roy with her dad
Mike
Magnumite
Member
Many years back they did a "shoot out" between two extremely skilled revolver shooters. I believe it was Thell Reed shooting the SA Colt 45 and John Pride shooting the DA revolver.
It was done at closer range then moved out some. The fastest first two shots out of the holster were consistantly shot by Reed with the single action revolver at close range. Extended strings...especially when distances opened up went in favor of the DA revolver - no surprise.
It was done at closer range then moved out some. The fastest first two shots out of the holster were consistantly shot by Reed with the single action revolver at close range. Extended strings...especially when distances opened up went in favor of the DA revolver - no surprise.
murdoc rose
Member
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2009
- Messages
- 582
saa's just have a special feel to them
Va Shooter
Member
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2006
- Messages
- 83
Getting the job done since 1873 45colt
Ruger bird'shead 45colt
Ruger bird'shead 45colt
NMGonzo
Member
They just look like a revolver.
Holster choices .... plenty of them.
Holster choices .... plenty of them.
bflobill_69
Member.
Quote: "They were good enough for John Wayne. "
...how do you argue with that?
...how do you argue with that?
popbang
Member
FFLGunDealers.net ,
Using a Simply Rugged Sourdough right now. I also have pancake holster made made by El Paso Saddlery, but I am not sure what the name is they give it. I have a PS6 from Mernickle and an IWB from Blackhills. Oh can't forget I even have a kydex from Kytec for my blackhawks.
Using a Simply Rugged Sourdough right now. I also have pancake holster made made by El Paso Saddlery, but I am not sure what the name is they give it. I have a PS6 from Mernickle and an IWB from Blackhills. Oh can't forget I even have a kydex from Kytec for my blackhawks.
Quote from Magnumite:
"Solid framed so theoretically have more inherent accuracy" (single-actions)
You only have to look at the revolvers from Freedom Arms to know that's a fact, not theory. You have to wonder just how sloppy some single-actions have to be put together to make them inaccurate.
"Solid framed so theoretically have more inherent accuracy" (single-actions)
You only have to look at the revolvers from Freedom Arms to know that's a fact, not theory. You have to wonder just how sloppy some single-actions have to be put together to make them inaccurate.
blaisenguns
Member
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2009
- Messages
- 453
Amen to that! I only own single action revolvers.
The_Shootist
Member
Hmmm
After I obtained my CHL all my handguns had to have SOME SD/Concealment role to them. Which is why I'm torn when eyeing a Ruger Blackhawk in .45 colt in the 4 5/8" bbl.
Yeah carrying my 686+/G19/1911 or even 642 makes more sense in a SD role but really ONLY is if you have to reload. I suspect that .45 Colt ....especially THIS variety:
http://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=46
is all you would ever need to stop a bad guy.
But if you are a believer in the "3 shots/3 sec's/3 feet protocol, the SA looks alot more equal. Indeed, isn't it true 99% of the time you just have to PRODUCE a gun to stop a mugging or worse? I suspect clearing leather in the presence of a badguy or two with a Blackhawk might cause them to rethink their intent.
However if you feel you're more likely as a civilian to get into something prolonged (possible - but improbable) needing you to go to the second/third mag or speedloader, then yeah I guess you have to stick to DA's or semi's.
Thats a decision I'm still wrestling with (ignoring the obvious fun I would have with a SA at the range) as I keep eyeing that Blackhawk.
After I obtained my CHL all my handguns had to have SOME SD/Concealment role to them. Which is why I'm torn when eyeing a Ruger Blackhawk in .45 colt in the 4 5/8" bbl.
Yeah carrying my 686+/G19/1911 or even 642 makes more sense in a SD role but really ONLY is if you have to reload. I suspect that .45 Colt ....especially THIS variety:
http://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=46
is all you would ever need to stop a bad guy.
But if you are a believer in the "3 shots/3 sec's/3 feet protocol, the SA looks alot more equal. Indeed, isn't it true 99% of the time you just have to PRODUCE a gun to stop a mugging or worse? I suspect clearing leather in the presence of a badguy or two with a Blackhawk might cause them to rethink their intent.
However if you feel you're more likely as a civilian to get into something prolonged (possible - but improbable) needing you to go to the second/third mag or speedloader, then yeah I guess you have to stick to DA's or semi's.
Thats a decision I'm still wrestling with (ignoring the obvious fun I would have with a SA at the range) as I keep eyeing that Blackhawk.
Love. 'nuff said.
"You know what the first rule of flying is? ...Love. You can learn all the math in the 'verse, but you take a boat in the air you don't love, she'll shake you off just as sure as the turning of the worlds. Love keeps her in the air when she oughta fall down, tells you she's hurting 'fore she keens. Makes her a home." --Malcolm Reynolds
(It's late and I'm feeling sentimental)
"You know what the first rule of flying is? ...Love. You can learn all the math in the 'verse, but you take a boat in the air you don't love, she'll shake you off just as sure as the turning of the worlds. Love keeps her in the air when she oughta fall down, tells you she's hurting 'fore she keens. Makes her a home." --Malcolm Reynolds
(It's late and I'm feeling sentimental)
Magnumite
Member
Well, I had to say theoretically because I had two sin gle action revolvers that were not accurate. But, you're rght a FA single action is one highly impressive revolver
- Status
