Wondering if I got this hunting rifle thing backwards???

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, seems .300 Winmag has gone tacticool. Probably the book/movie "American Sniper" has something to do with it.

Well... considering Nemo released the Omen in 2011 and Chris Kyle’s book came out in 2012, and the movie “American Sniper” premiered in 2014, I don’t think the book/movie had much to do with it....
 
Well... considering Nemo released the Omen in 2011 and Chris Kyle’s book came out in 2012, and the movie “American Sniper” premiered in 2014, I don’t think the book/movie had much to do with it....

Maybe not the gun, but Kyle really talked up how much he liked the .300 Win Mag in his book. The movie didn't cover that part.
 
This is my issue with folks who think .22's should be cheap. Why scrimp on the guns you use the most and splurge on those you only use a fraction of the year? Unfortunately for me, this has always meant that I own more .22's, rather than a handful of really nice ones. I've been contemplating selling off a few to pay for a really nice, heavily optioned Cooper.
I thought about this. Selling them all to get one really nice Anschütz used on gunbroker for $800
 
any caliber would have done that if the shot was the same. try to reach the heart from a quartering away shot on a large deer or a straight away shot. this heart shot was on a very large kudu quartering away in thick brush in Africa.

The 6.5mm Grendel pushes bullets to the same energy factors that the 7x57mm Mauser does, and that’s a chambering that’s been known to do a number on game animals that I wouldn’t even consider it for were it me doing the hunting. Not my cup of tea but there are videos in which the users put down bull elk at over 400 yds dropping right there. That says quite a bit.

What I consider the optimal cartridge doesn’t fit in an AR though, being the 7mm-08 (Ackley Improved).
 
Maybe not the gun, but Kyle really talked up how much he liked the .300 Win Mag in his book. The movie didn't cover that part.

Indeed he did mention the 300wm being his favorite of his issued weapons. A year AFTER the Nemo rifle was released, not driven by his endorsement...
 
try that with the 6.5 G long enough and a lot of coyotes will eat good. I would take a 7x57 any day of the week for elk over the 6.5 G.
 
^^ :rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl:

C’mon man, really? Some of us have been “trying that” (deer hunting) with the Grendel for plenty long enough to prove it’s no more apt to let game run off than any other common deer rifle.

That buck heart above, was punched quartering away in a buck which was over 280lbs.... with a 6.5 Grendel...
 
try that with the 6.5 G long enough and a lot of coyotes will eat good. I would take a 7x57 any day of the week for elk over the 6.5 G.

A lot? With quite similar ballistics. I say hardly and with nothing to back that up with. Silly to say such a thing.

So I suppose the 6.5mm Swede let most animals off the hook since it doesn’t perform as well, right? Yet it has proven itself for how long, and on what kinds of game???
 
Last edited:
well for one my 6.5x55 CZ 550 and my rem classic 700 in 6.5x55 will send the same weight-style bullets 200-400 fps faster and so will the 7x57, in my.custom 7x57 on a 98 mauser action. I have a 6.8 spc encore that runs at about the same speed as the 6.5 G with the same weight-style bullets and I know it and the 6.5 G will kill elk at 400 yards, but its not for every body. I also shoot .257 Roberts and with the heavier bullets makes a good white tail rifle, and it to will and has killed elk, but not my pick as the 6.8 sps and 6.5 G would not be. check the loading manuals for loads and compare the data, 6.5 G- 120gr TSX-2300-2400 fps, 6.5x55-120gr TSX-2800-2900 fps, 7x57-120gr TSX-2800-2900 fps, so use what you want, but not every shooter-hunter is a chris kyle.
 
What I did forget to mention in my first - a motivation for why I never feel bad about spending a lot on hunting rifles which see limited use:

Inheritance.

Someday my son will take on my collection, and hopefully someday, his son/daughter. My son already shoots my grandpa’s old 22LR and 410 break action, both of which were my grandfather’s, then my father’s, mine, and now his. He’ll also take over my first 30-06, 1894, Super Blackhawk, and 12 ga soon enough. My wife has her dad’s 30-06 and 30-30 she’s using currently, as well as her .45-70 she’ll pass down. No idea what he’ll do with the rest of the collection, I suppose keep what he wants and sell the rest to buy a second home.

These wood and steel firearms have a lot more class and inherent ability to accept sentimentality than some of my more modern and utilitarian rifles - my match rifles might be expensive, but they certainly aren’t “fine rifles” which feel like heirlooms, regardless of the price, quality, or volume of use and emotional attachment. My go-to shotgun for the last 12yrs, and likely the next 30, is a camo dipped Benelli Supernova. Great shotgun, and will last generations. My most common hunting rifles are AR’s, most as expensive as any of my bolt action hunting rifles, and some better overall quality. But it’s not quite the same to hand an AR or a camo dipped scattergun to my son as a family heirloom as it is to hand him a wood and steel firearm.
 
AR-15's are more than capable of taking deer size game. The AR-15 platform has a plethora of very effective and potent cartridges useable out to easily 300-400 yards. Some other AR-15 cartridges aren't effective at 300-400 yards but are more than capable out to 150-200 yards or closer, and that's where 90% of deer are taken.

6.5 Grendel, 6.8 SPC, 30 Rem AR, 7.62x39 .277 WLV, 450 Bushmaster, etc. And then there are the variations of above mentioned cases, then of course there's my favorite based off the 6.5x47L case: 7mm Valkyrie, 30 Sabercat, 6.5 Timberwolf, 358 Yeti, etc.

To say the AR-15 isn't a capable rifle to harvest medium game is just nonsense.
 
I have shot many decent size deer with .22 LR and .22 mag in the buck wheat fields as a young man on the farm for crop damage, but I think you owe a clean kill to any animal you hunt. that's why I use enough gun for the game I hunt and the distance I will be shooting.
 
even if legal here in pa. I would not be using a AR-15, I have seen men run and shoot after being shot and hit at less that 100 yards with m-16,s. now if your talking about a legal m1A-14 in 7.62x51 its a different story.

I’ve seen deer shot with an AR-15 drop in their tracks. Men too. It is what it is.
 
Back to the topic....

There’s no reason to sell the Sako. At least I wouldn’t. But I’ve only sold a few guns in my life. I’m more of a buyer of good guns at good deals and keep them. Shouldn’t be hard to save $300-$400 dollars and buy an older levergun in 30/30 or 35Rem. I’m looking at two right now for less than $400. A Glenfield Model 50 with 16” barrel, WWG sights and big hoop. And a pre-safety JM in 35. Neither of which do I need. But they’re good deals and should I ever be FORCED to sell, I would make money.

I don’t really look at AR’s as having any sentimental or actual value later on assuming we don’t run into another stupid ban. That Sako however..... A classic rifle in a classic caliber.
 
I don’t know how threads drift so far, so fast. And there are are dozen replies that have zero to do with the OP.

He didn’t say anything about deer hunting with the AR. He wondered if he should sell a more valuable rifle and get two, one for hunting and one for just shooting

I have a Remington SPS 10 gauge that’s been shot five times in five years, each time getting a turkey. It’s the perfect tool for the job, so I’ve kept it, though my turkey hunting days are probably coming to an end so it will go away. Do five shots in five years justify keeping it? Up until now, yeah.

The Sako should be a really nice rifle. If it’s accurate, you like it, and don’t need to sell it to finance another gun you use more, I’d keep it. If it has not particular emotional value and you can get by with something lesser, that’s your call. I’m a gun snob and like really nice rifles that are above average accuracy, with really nice glass.

If your gun is more of a tool like a hammer is to a carpenter, then I’d get what I’d use
 
How long are your hunts? The SAKO Finnlight is nice and accurate, but if I’m not taking 300 yard shots and hiking 15 miles, a pound more of weight and 3/4 moa doesn’t matter to me.

I also have a Sako 6.5x55 Finnlight and if I had it to do over would buy a heavier rifle. I don't hike much in my hunting and if I do have a 300 yard shot a heavier rifle will be steadier and more accurate. Thinking of putting a non-fluted, slightly longer barrel on it to add some weight.
 
I was cleaning my guns the other day and came to a realization.

I think you should figure out why you don't like the Sako. There's two parts to owning a rifle and that is the rifle itself and the second part is the cartridge. If the rifle is uncomfortable for you to shoot because of some problem try to analyze the situation because if you don' t like the rifle you won't like the cartridge either. Maybe it's the design of the stock or you're afraid you would put a scratch on the stock, etc. I only own one rifle that I don't like and I hardly ever shoot it because the stock is awkward. I enjoy shooting the rifles I like and I would never get rid of them. I take care of my rifles but I use them hard and it doesn't bother me if I put a scratch on one of them.
 
Last edited:
6.5 mm has great sectional density and ballistic coefficients in the heavier bullet selections. Now, am I agog over the 6.5 creedmore or the old 6.5x55 Mauser? Nah, not really, I have a 7 mag that'll do what ever those will do. BCs and SDs are pretty decent in 7mm, too, and the bullets are available in heavier selections. I like the way the 160 Partition shoots in my rifle. But, though I bought this rifle for elk and heavy game, I've yet to shoot anything bigger than a west Texas whitetail with it. I've got my FIRST elk hunt scheduled for this fall, though! :D The gun, itself, HAS taken a Nilgai. I loaned it to a friend along with some 160 Partitions. He said it was a 150 yard shot and dropped in its tracks.

I could download that big 7 and hunt everything with it, but I ain't sellin' my other rifles to become a one gun hunter. I've got a .308 and an old .257 Bob that are very accurate. I don't sell accurate rifles. :D I really don't need another rifle despite the fact that it's all the rage now days and folks think nothing else will work anymore. Game hasn't gotten bigger or started wearing kevlar. I think what HAS worked WILL work. :D None of my rifles are expensive, two Remington bolt guns and a Savage 110. If I had the OP's Sako, I'd sit around and admire it a lot. :D I sure wouldn't get rid of it for plastic and aluminum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top