In the saga of my friend moving from revolvers to a "plastic" DAO type semi auto, I had the chance to shoot a Springfield XD 9mm Subcompact for the first time.
Good points are that the gun is very accurate for it size, the grip is comfortable, and the recoil is slightly less of a Glock 26.
Bad points are the XD SC is a little more bulkier and "top heavy" than the glock 26, and in my opinion the trigger is a lot lighter and mushy-ier then the Glock even though the Springfield web site says the trigger pull is 7.7 to 5.5 pounds (glocks website says their trigger pull is 5.5lb too)?? I spoke to the range owner he says the XD pull smooths out to somewhere between 4 and 5 lb. If this is true the XD definately need a grip safety because the trigger would get unpredictable over time. Also the only way to increase or decrease the trigger pull of an XD is with a trigger job from a gunsmith, costing anywhere from $50 to $100. Glocks' trigger pull always stays the same and seems more flexible with either the standard 5.5 trigger spring and optional 11lb, 8lb and 3.5lb springs, which you can put in yourself at a cost of a few bucks. With an 11lb spring the trigger pull on a glock is very similar to a snub nose revolver (My S&W revolver has the same travel and 12lb of pull). While you should never touch the trigger, 11lb makes it very safe to handle for beginners.
A lot of people recommend XD as a first gun, personally I don't know if that is a good idea. The grip safety is ok, but it is very sensitive. We were able to shoot the gun by holding it as light as possible. That is good for a self defense, but bad if your using it as a safety crutch trying not to put pressure on it while holstering and handling.
Overall I just wished the XD had a more uniform trigger, and the option to adjust the trigger pull weight. I like light and smooth triggers, but a well used XD may be a little to light for beginners.
Good points are that the gun is very accurate for it size, the grip is comfortable, and the recoil is slightly less of a Glock 26.
Bad points are the XD SC is a little more bulkier and "top heavy" than the glock 26, and in my opinion the trigger is a lot lighter and mushy-ier then the Glock even though the Springfield web site says the trigger pull is 7.7 to 5.5 pounds (glocks website says their trigger pull is 5.5lb too)?? I spoke to the range owner he says the XD pull smooths out to somewhere between 4 and 5 lb. If this is true the XD definately need a grip safety because the trigger would get unpredictable over time. Also the only way to increase or decrease the trigger pull of an XD is with a trigger job from a gunsmith, costing anywhere from $50 to $100. Glocks' trigger pull always stays the same and seems more flexible with either the standard 5.5 trigger spring and optional 11lb, 8lb and 3.5lb springs, which you can put in yourself at a cost of a few bucks. With an 11lb spring the trigger pull on a glock is very similar to a snub nose revolver (My S&W revolver has the same travel and 12lb of pull). While you should never touch the trigger, 11lb makes it very safe to handle for beginners.
A lot of people recommend XD as a first gun, personally I don't know if that is a good idea. The grip safety is ok, but it is very sensitive. We were able to shoot the gun by holding it as light as possible. That is good for a self defense, but bad if your using it as a safety crutch trying not to put pressure on it while holstering and handling.
Overall I just wished the XD had a more uniform trigger, and the option to adjust the trigger pull weight. I like light and smooth triggers, but a well used XD may be a little to light for beginners.