I have never seen AutoComp, so have never tried it.
I have a start load of 5.7gn AutoComp and Max load of 6.2gn. I also have Major loads (PF > 165).
For TiteGroup, I have data from two manuals:
4.4gn start and 5.0gn MAX
and
5.0gn start and 6.0gn MAX.
The thing is, the 5.0gn start load has a velocity of 1150 fps and the 5.0 MAX load has a velocity of 1124 fps.
Question: was 5.7gn TiteGroup the max load and you just loaded it or was it the start load? From my manuals, that would not be a load to just start using without working up.
In my .38 Supers, I have gotten decent accuracy with MG JHP with 4.2-4.7gn TiteGroup, Zero 121 38 Super JHP and 3.8-4.6gn TiteGroup, and Hornady 121gn JHP and 4.0-4.5gn TiteGroup. None of these were hot in my guns using my components.