Action preferences

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 1, 2011
Messages
147
Location
DFW, TX
After adding several semi-autos to the herd, for the most part, while I agree semi's are best for limited applications, I'm finding my preference migrating back towards bolt actions....
Advantages of:
simplicity
lighter weight for anything other than .223 (which is too light IMO for many uses I have-again, great for some, but limited)
EASE of maintenance (really picky about maintaining my guns and enjoy taking care of, but it takes me too long to clean a semi!)
accuracy (and yes, the semi's can certainly be accurate too....
just sayin"...)

What say you?
 
I like bolt guns because they make me take my time and aim. I also use fewer rounds with a bolt gun than with a semi.
 
My advice comes as a hunter, if you want a target rifle you may want to disregard.

I've used most everything. I have gravitated toward CRF Winchesters and Kimbers as my 1st choices. Just depends on the weight requirement.

Rugers are a contender and a top choice if price is a big concern. I haven't gotten quite the accuracy from any Ruger I've ever owned compared to the Winchesters and Kimbers, but it is more than adequate for hunting. Still usually under 1 MOA.

Tikka has been the most accurate brand I've ever owned. Good rifles at good prices. I just prefer the looks and function of other brands better.

Lots of Savage and Remington fans out there and you'll probably get lots of recomendations for them. I've owned them. Not bad, but over rated in my experience as hunting rifles. Maybe a good choice if you are looking for a target rifle.
 
With rifles, I went through the stage of "it's cool to have a semi-auto because you can shoot a lot." Then I started getting into accuracy and simplicity and decided I really liked a bolt action. Went from hating bolts to loving them. They are simple, easy to use, generally accurate, reliable, and easy to clean.

I particularly took a liking to the Winchester Model 70 action, primarily because of its 3-position bolt-locking safety. I have one in 30-06, and made one in 7mm-08 (see below). Love the bolt actions.

100_6922_zpsaca1629e.jpg

Semi-autos do have their place in action rifle sports where the bolt would really not work at all (e.g. 3-gun).

Lou
 
i've come to prefer bolt actions over any other. i have semis and they're great for certain platforms and uses. i tried really hard to like levers, but the only gun i seem to enjoy a lever on is my 39 mountie.
 
I have been a bolt action fan for my entire life. Lately I have developed an affinity for lever actions. I bought a 39A and am having a ball with it. It can't get much easier to clean than one of those. I also own a BLR in 7-08 I am thinking might become my favorite of all time.

With that having been said, should TSHTF, I would opt for a good semi auto for all the reasons the military has for adopting them.
 
1. Lever.
2. Bolt, if a left hand action can be found.
3. Semi.
4. Falling block
5. Break action
6. Pump
7. Right hand bolt.

I should probably explain that. Levers are fast, well balanced, slim and friendly, at least to a cowboy shooter like me. They're just about perfect for woods and brush country, where ranges are short, shots are sudden, and you don't want slings, telescopes and bolt handles snagging on every passing branch. Their great limitation, of course, is that the traditional Winchester 94 or 86 doesn't handle pointy bullet, high intensity calibers well, which limits their utility for long range shooting, as is often found in the mountains or on the plains. I know there are Savage 99s, Winchester 1895s, and BLRs, which can be chambered for more modern calibers, and mount scopes more easily, but instead of solving the problem, they seem to me to combine the vices of both levers and bolts into a sort of misbegotten not fish, nor fowl, nor good red herring abomination in the eyes of the Lord. Your mileage may vary, of course.

Bolts pick up where levers leave off, at the edge of the woods. When chambered for high speed, flat shooting calibers, and equipped with telescopic sights, shooting slings, excellent triggers, and free floated barrels, they are much better adapted to the deliberate, precise shooting that's more to be found out in the open.

Semis gain you a number of things. They are fast to fire extra shots. They hold plenty of ammunition. A box mag is quicker and easier to reload than an internal mag or tube. However, they do these things at the cost of increased weight, bulk, and cost. Additionally, most of their virtues are irrelevant to hunting, so they're not really ideal as a field gun. I ranked them as high as I did because I'd surely choose one for fighting, but I tend to have more occasion for hunting than fighting rifles.

Single shots tend to be specialist guns. They can be made very light and compact in comparison to a repeater, and the falling blocks can be very accurate as well. In most situations, though, a repeater is cheap insurance. One caveat to singles, is that the ease of chambering them for any cartridge whatever, regardless of length and other factors that restrict repeating rifles, is that people tend to do silly things with them. A single shot carbine may make an excellent deer rifle. Make sure of your shot, and you're good. Less so for elk. They frequently take several shots, and why complicate your life unnecessarily? But look at the Ruger No. 1 Tropical. A single shot dangerous game rifle? Surely the market for these is someone who wants to play with an African caliber at the range, and doesn't want the expense of a true safari rifle. But if he actually uses it for what it claims to be for? Well, think of it as evolution in action.

Pumps exist. They seem to work. Some people like them. Enough said.

Right hand bolts. I can shoot right handed, but as it involves fighting both eye dominance and the absence of a significant portion of that trigger finger, I get a more harmonious outcome from the other shoulder. Shooting a bolt wrong handed is just annoying, so I don't, if there's a choice.
 
Last edited:
My choices would be 1. Falling block as in Ruger #1. 2. Lever as in Marlin. 3. Bolt action as in L/H Browning I've owned 2 Remington 141's in 35 rem and really like them but they are not made any longer and are very hard to find where I live.
 
As most have here, I have owned, used, and hunted with most all of them.

While my preference is for the semiautomatic Garand style action, the very close second is the bolt action, followed by the lever action.

Also a southpaw, so this may or may not matter with all lefties out there.

Between my 10-22's and M14 type rifles, both pretty much cover all my shooting and hunting requirements..... although I'm a big fan of revolvers when it comes to sidearms.

There are simply less manual steps needed to aquire and shoot another target. ( All focus is on the fundamental's of marksmanship)

While I realize that some folks use them to put down lots of lead in a short time, this has all to do with how the rifle is used, and not the issue with the rifle itself..... (IE...... the rifle provides for the capability, but has nothing more to do with the design itself..... as the person behind the trigger makes the decision.)
The same rifle can be utilized for teaching a person to become a rifleman as easily as any other type simply by controlling the amount of ammunition loaded into the magazine at any given duration of fire.... A single shot if deemed important for the purpose of teaching.
The "coach" has all the controls he needs to teach marksmanship with a semiautomatic rifle in this way.

A Springfield Armory Inc. M1A-A1 will typically weigh more than a lightweight "mountain rifle" chambered in same caliber, but not enough to matter in my case. I like how this type of rifle is balanced, and where the controls are in relation to each other. ( Especially fond of this rifle's iron sights)

If the above rifle was never designed, it might become a toss up between a different semiautomatic rifle and a bolt action rifle.
 
Last edited:
For me, hands-down bolt-actions. Auto, lever, pump, single-shot are all fun. But I like bolt guns best.

Geno
 
Like Louca, I am partial to the Winchester Model 70 action. In addition to the 3-position safety, the other features I like are: very stiff action, easily adjusted trigger, easy bolt disassembly, and flat bottomed receiver for excellent bedding. I have 4 target rifles and 1 hunting rifle based on the Model 70 action at this time.

Don
 
I have to say I'm queer for Model 70s. I understand the new ones are the best ever -- except for the new trigger. There's a case of, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" if ever I saw one.
 
I want semi actions that perform like a bolt. I am trying to get rid of my bolts with semi. I have some bolts that nothing else will do. I do have some semi auto that do great. If I had a semi in 22-250 that was better than my bolt, I would like to own
it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top