Another convert joins the ranks.

Status
Not open for further replies.

horsey300

Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2016
Messages
3,355
Location
Wyobraska
I don't really get weekends off, so when I woke up Sunday to find there was no work for me, there was only one action to take! The better half confirmed with her mother we were headed to the ranch and we loaded up the kids, guns, and ammo. The weather was frigid with blowing snow but the highways were not impassable and by afternoon there was gunpowder being burnt!

Mama is not a stranger to guns by any means but is displeased with the large frame glock that she's had for years. I've been itching to see if there were better options to trip her trigger for some time but never had the right days off to let her try a variety before her next purchase. This opportunity was a wonderful excuse for us all to get together even if the weather wasn't the most cooperative.

We started with informal targets at roughly 15-25 yds. We first loaded .38s into the better half's model 60 pro series and my dad's 19-3 that a certain lady of the house has decided must belong to her. Mama decided immediately that the J-frame was an improvement on her glock. The model 19-3 impressed even more. (The revolvers were reloaded from the comfort of the heated SUV as the 10 yr old daughter and I worked on her open sights skills with a 10-22 and my .22 revolver). In the name of being thorough, full house .357s were loaded into the 19-3 and were still fired off with a smiling demeanor. Next, 18 rds were emptied through my canik for a general comparison, and after all the gals taking a few more cylinders with the .22 and 19-3, I half jokingly offered for mama to take a few shots with my .41 blackhawk...... and she accepted. After a few admonitions about recoil and how to work the single action, she put 4/5 rds right where they were supposed to go! Her trigger control was beautiful through out the entire day, with the semi autos faring much worse off than they had started.
I still need to get new grips on the blackhawk but she was VERY interested in a single action, and the interest only increased when I explained she didn't HAVE to have such a large caliber to get a blackhawk. Compared to the cowboy sights on my .22, she fared much better with the adjustable sights of the ruger, so I think we're either looking at a blackhawk 4 5/8 .357 or a single 7 .327 (same barrel).
All in all, it was a great day. Hearing a lady whose complaint about her glock included her wrists say that the .41 was decidedly rough but MANAGEABLE and actually enjoy some target practice with a classic 19-3 that served its time in a Montanan sheriff's posse more than made up for the windchilled knuckles and finger tips. It also opened a very nice window for a certain feller to discuss adding a blackhawk .357 and single 7 .327 to his arsenal (you know, for friends and family to learn on/test).
Now we're addressing the dilemma of whether we need the blackhawk before we need the single 7 and whether or not we need them before certain other planned rifle purchases. Life is good and the wheel guns gain yet another member in the fan club.
 
I am the same as your MiL. I feel less recoil with similar loads in a DA revolver than an equivalent semiautomatic. I feel less recoil in a SA revolver than I do in a DA revolver. I guess it has something to do with hand shape, maybe.
 
so I think we're either looking at a blackhawk 4 5/8 .357 or a single 7 .327
A Blackhawk in .357 can be loaded from very mild to semi wild, a good choice. Of course the same thing can be said for the .327. Even if you don't reload they are both very versatile. The .327 is an ear splitter with full loads. As much as I love my .32 Longs and Mags, I think I would go .357 first.
 
I am the same as your MiL. I feel less recoil with similar loads in a DA revolver than an equivalent semiautomatic. I feel less recoil in a SA revolver than I do in a DA revolver. I guess it has something to do with hand shape, maybe.

A Blackhawk in .357 can be loaded from very mild to semi wild, a good choice. Of course the same thing can be said for the .327. Even if you don't reload they are both very versatile. The .327 is an ear splitter with full loads. As much as I love my .32 Longs and Mags, I think I would go .357 first.
I too was leaning towards .357 first until I just stumbled across the lipseys blackhawk bisley in .44 sp, and the bisley would be great, reaching the hammer was a bit of a stretch for her, I'd already looked at bisley conversions for my blackhawk, but figgered I'd try good grips before changing too much else. Herein lies the fresh dilemma, would the .44 special fit this role handily enough, or convert a blackhawk .357 to the bisley? I personally wouldn't mind just having one of each as I've been a single action nut for ages, but the boss says there IS a limit as to how many revolvers I can accumulate over the next few months, so now I could use some assistance with getting the priorities right lol. Instinctively I'm leaning bh .357 1st, single7 2ND, and .44sp bisleybh last as the .357 was already well received, it'll give everyone something to shoot whilst waiting for the others to start lining up. However, part of me says a new chambering might be a better idea, and I want the .327 more than the .44, but being able to handle and utilize the bisleybh sure appeals too lol, which brings us back to the conversion of the .357..... hopefully someone can throw some logic into this mess!
 
What I've learned on this forum is...

When in doubt about a firearm, buy it to find out. If you're still in doubt, buy another example! And thus, if you're in doubt about several firearms, buy one of each. If still in doubt, buy other examples! And never sell a gun that you actually like. :)
 
Herein lies the fresh dilemma, would the .44 special fit this role handily enough, or convert a blackhawk .357 to the bisley? I personally wouldn't mind just having one of each as I've been a single action nut for ages, but the boss says there IS a limit as to how many revolvers I can accumulate over the next few months, so now I could use some assistance with getting the priorities right lol. Instinctively I'm leaning bh .357 1st, single7 2ND, and .44sp bisleybh last as the .357 was already well received,
Since I am a .44 Spl fan, I would put it 2nd. Not quite as versatile as .357. You can download it very light, but not as cheap as nor as clean as (IMHO) .357. It's going to be hard to beat the .357 for what you want. Heck, a nice .38 Spl is another choice unless she want to fire magnums. I'd rather have a nice .32 Mag or .32 Long than a .327. But oc course since I reload I could keep it below "ear splitting" level Still, I suggest .357.
 
Since I am a .44 Spl fan, I would put it 2nd. Not quite as versatile as .357. You can download it very light, but not as cheap as nor as clean as (IMHO) .357. It's going to be hard to beat the .357 for what you want. Heck, a nice .38 Spl is another choice unless she want to fire magnums. I'd rather have a nice .32 Mag or .32 Long than a .327. But oc course since I reload I could keep it below "ear splitting" level Still, I suggest .357.
Thank you for that input! I haven't started loading for the handguns yet, but that IS on the agenda. I reckon the .357 is still making the most sense, we can download, shoot .38s etc, and still be able to run full house for whatever reason as well. We considered getting a .38, but I don't remember seeing one in a bh frame, and after discussing the possibility of hunting down the road, the .38 got set aside for the the .357.
I appreciate all of the input given so far, we'll sure be busy with all the fun of house buying AND blackhawk searching, but it'll be fun!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top