For me, I like USA Built pieces..... I prefer Remington products over most semi-auto scatter guns. I have a love affair with remington Model 11, especially the pre 1921 models. That rem 11 in 16 ga in grade D is the sweetest piece I have ever shot scatter gun wise and is where Browning took the Sweet 16 from (even though it is a Browning design, they did not start building them until later).
for me in order would be
Rem 1100 (what ever gadgets and stuff you want)
Win 1400
Older Browning Auto -5, Rem 11, Savage 720 & 700 series
It truly depends on what you want it for and your firearm owning habits and use.
Rem 1100, parts are fully avail and cheap, accessories are avail everywhere, even damn near in the drug stores. They are easy to work on, take a beating and avail in damn near any style, ga, weight, barrel length you could even imagine. I have yet to have a failure with any of my rem 1100's and I have em in all ga. My Win 1400 is OK, but it is finicky on ammo.
Regards,
Mike