Colt Detective Special

Status
Not open for further replies.

Storm

Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
2,358
Location
Georgia
While most of my revolvers are Smiths I decided to hat I really wanted to have a Colt. I've been into snubbies lately, so when I spotted a Colt Detective Special I decided to pull the trigger on a Colt. A clerk in the shop told me that it had been many years since he had never seen so many used Colt revolvers all at once. There must have been over fifteen Police Postives and Detective Specials in the case. I know that most of them weren't there a month ago.

I spotted a Detective Special in fine mechanical condition but with aesthetic issues. I could tell that the gun would do fine with re-blueing so I put it on layaway. The original grips would have to be replaced. When I came back for the gun three days later there was already another Detective Special added since, and it was in vastly better condition with a better trigger (very smooth) and $50 less than the one that I had on layaway. As the shop allows one switch I came home with the "new" one.

On the downside the gun came with grossly oversized Pachmayrs. The gun is around 85% on the right side and 75% on the left side, but is in good enough condition that I'd never re-blue it. I picked up some Stile grips to replace the Pachmayrs. While they aren't exactly my taste (but they feel great), they are better than the Pachmayrs, and only ran me $7. They'll work until I find original Colt grips. I may stick with the older grip profile like the Stiles and will probably add a Tyler T-Grip.

The serial number is H24098 with a "5" below that. Any idea when this gun was built? It's a very tight gun and mechanically I'm very impressed from what I can see/feel.

I can already see an older Colt Detective (pre-ejector shroud) in my future.

coltfz7.jpg
 
Your revolver was built in 1975.

Nice looking piece. I have a 1975 DS on my hip as I write this so I am a little biased :D

I sure wish I had a pawn shop that got such nice stuff in my town.

Be careful, the Colt bug is not easy to shake!
 
Thanks Guillermo. In 1975 I was a junior in high school so that really puts it in perspective for me.

I can see how Colts could become habit-forming. Luckily I haven't seen a Trooper, Diamondback, Anaconda or Python or I would be lost.
 
Yeah, the Colt bug is difficult to get rid of -- even the smaller variety that causes one to buy snubbies. Four for me in the past year -- a Cobra, an Agent, and two Detective Specials. And, I'm still not over it yet. There's a DS out there without the shroud that's just calling my name.
 
There's a DS out there without the shroud that's just calling my name.

Me also. I suspect that tomorrow I'll be putting one on layaway. I like the shrouded ejector, but there's just something about the older style that grabs me.
 
Looks like the twin to my fairly new to me Cobra.
Had a set of smooth walnut Colt stocks w/gold medalions when I got it, that weren't so good for pocket carry. Grabbed a set of the Siles stocks , like yours has, and it's perfect for pocket carry now. I also added a polished aluminum grip adapter.

I agree that the Siles stocks aren't the greatest looking, but the reduced size is exactly what I needed for pocket carry.

At some point I'm going to have a set of Stags made for it useing the Siles stocks as the template.

Wish my computer was more healthy. Can't post pics right now, but will soon.

Enjoy your Colt. It's a beauty!
 
I have a first generation that my dad used as his off-duty gun - folks on one of the threads dated it to 1928.....little holster wear, but works well with standard loads....good gun
 
I agree that the Siles stocks aren't the greatest looking, but the reduced size is exactly what I needed for pocket carry.

Yeah, they are a bit "busy". But, on the postive side, they do result in a very sure and postive grip. I hope to sneak up on some original Colt grips in the same shape with standard checkering, but I've got to say that I do like the feel of the Stiles.
 
I wanted one and finally got it.
I couldn't shoot that thing for the world. I am not sure it was the gun as a friend of mine did fine with it.
I would assume they are bad to go out of time, like most Colts. And the exposed ejector rod versions are prone to bend.
To me they are in the sort of neat category but I wouldn't carry one over a Smith&Wesson.
 
Hey Bubba,

You are right, Colts are known for poor quality and breaking often. Heck, they are of H&R quality...if that!

We wouldn't want you to have such a piece of fecal matter in your gun safe. I will be glad to take that dog off your hands.

Since you can't shoot it I will be glad to give you fifty bucks and pay for shipping.
 
Gee Bubba,

I must be doing something wrong...

I would assume they are bad to go out of time, like most Colts. And the exposed ejector rod versions are prone to bend.
To me they are in the sort of neat category but I wouldn't carry one over a Smith&Wesson.

Back in '57 I bought one of these junkers and have carried and used it ever since. In spite of my best efforts the action is still perfectly timed, and it locks up like a bank vault door. Ejector rod isn't bent either. Still carry the dumb thing. :uhoh:

Maybe it's because it will keep it's shots inside the center of a B-27 silhouette target at 100 yards (measured). Or the fact that the cylinder holds 6, not 5 rounds.

It's not that I don't have any others made by that outfit in Springfield, MA., or that they don't make a pretty good gun to. But I found that a lot of things that folks say about older Colt's are mostly myths - unless abuse is involved. Now when I want to pack a larger revolver there are some very attractive models offered by the "other company," But when I want to go with a holstered snubby it will probably be that Colt. Over the years it just sort of grew on me... ;)
 
Old Fuff, you're too smart not to realize that not every gun acts just like yours. How many Police Positives have you had to re-time?
Sorry to crap on everyone's parade, but them's the facts. You have a good Colt? You love the brand? Great. Live and be well.
 
Bubba,

Nobody is trying to talk you out of it. Heck, them Colts are plain trash. There is hardly a worse gun out there.

I am just happy to help you out and clean out the garbage from your gun safe.

A nice crisp Grant would go a far way to getting you a nice new Smith & Wesson.

Just trying to help you out buddy.
 
How many Police Positives have you had to re-time?

Actually a fair number, mine and some that belonged to others. Often times I could straighten them up by simply hitting 'um with a hammer... :what:

Well not exactly a regular hammer... You see they would fail to carry up because the crane was sprung, and a little tap on the cylinder with a plastic or rubber headed mallet would work wonders. Incidentally this trick works with Smith & Wesson's sometimes, but not too often.

The real problem with the Colt action is that it required very skilled assemblers (which thhe Old Fuff doesn't claim to be) and latter production suffered as Colt lost or fired this kind of employee. Obviously they're management wasn't the brightest. But when the action is correctly set up it will lock the cylinder solid, with each chamber concentric with the bore.

You simply can't beat that... :cool:
 
I was rather thinking that he would send it to me to get it hammered on.... :evil:

Doesn't look like he's going to take the bait. :(
 
Hey Guillermo.
You're right. I don't want this POS. Send me $50 and an FFL and it's yours.
 
Old Fuff is right, send it to Arizona.

He spreads a huge amount of knowledge. I would feel guilty knowing that he could fix this horrendous revolver with the rubber hammer that doctors use to check reflexes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top