Conundrum (mixed feels)

im not a purist, both my ruger blackhawk convertibles got pachmayr rubber grips asap after i acquired them. they both are almost exclusively shot with cheaper 45acp and 9mm ammo respectively.

44sp ammo and aftermarket rubber grips for o.p.

imho, a true sentimental firearm was actually & purposefully used by the original owner. i am a sentimentalist but in this case, if 44sp ammo and rubber grips don’t make this 7.5” 44mag ruger a pal of mine, i would offload it for a more useful & hand/wallet-friendly, but spiritually related, 4.8” or 5.5” 45lc/acp or even 357/38/9mm convertible single-action revolver, a pietta if not another ruger.

IMG_0212.jpeg IMG_0211.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Whiskey - even if you decide not to use this gun, keep it for memory's sake.
I have a gun of my grandfather's that we estimate was made around 1900-1910. On the barrel. it just says "Colt .38 DA" so I don't think it is even a .38 Special, although I have shot it. It's poor accuracy is why I had it checked out. It is no longer safe to fire as the cylinder doesn't lock tightly when cocked. It's also lost all of the bluing.
As a little kid, I remember seeing the butt-end of this "hog leg" sticking out from a shelf below the cash register in his store, so I keep it for the memories.

Colt D.A. rt.jpg Colt D.A. lt.jpg
 
My cousin just inherited a boat load of guns from her dad, my uncle. He was a .30 carbine guy. She is officially his next of kin so they belong to her but she's going to give me some good deals on a few of them. It's not just the M1's. He has a nice little Star 9mm. A S&W 45ACP revolver. A Beretta Cougar. A Colt Detective Special. A Spanish Mauser. A Mauser "Destroyer". A Broomhandle Mauser! An Enfield. A Garand Tanker. The list is long. Personally, I am limited and I know I'll have to settle for some carefully chosen specimens. The first one on my mind is his little .30 M1 "Endorcer" pistol. I've never owned anything in that caliber before, although I used to shoot it with him all the time. Being that I'm an AK guy I think I'm going to forgo his other full sized 30 carbines, as as much as it appeals to me I think I'm also going to let the Garand tanker go. I'm an AK guy and I built my own AK and and have an almost pristine Swedish Mauser of my own...and I'm not giving them up for anything that old guy had! But the Enforcer and the Star 9mm sound like they'll be my first choices. And perhaps a Rossi 357 lever gun he had which had a jamming issue. I've come to terms with the fact that I just can't do it all.
 
If you sell it, find a collector that will appreciate the history and keep the stories alive.

I am sure there are plenty of guys on this site that would be happy to do that.

If you keep it, you don't have to shoot it. I have several guns in the collection that I don't enjoy shooting but keep them anyway for various reasons.
 
Ok so I've posted about my Great Grandpa's Ruger Blackhawk in .44 magnum. It's a great story I grew up hearing my dad tell many times. Well I took it out the other day and fired three rounds of 180 grain Federal JHP. I must say I did not care for the way my hand felt after the third shot. I'm no YouTube influencers like Scott on Kentucky Ballistics (love his content) and dont measure my manhood by how much
recoil can I absorb. I can shoot it just fine I just don't like to. So here is my where I'm stuck. I'm unsure if I want to part with it for something that I will enjoy shooting more or hang on to it because it i am the 4th in my family line to own this .44.
Perhaps by posting on here will help.

I'm not going to post the story again (I'm not sure how to link it either) it's under my other posts. I'm kinda struggling with this because after losing my dad, my best friend and just recently someone I have grown very close to I find myself wondering why am I so wrapped up with the story behind things like this .44. It's a story that I've told all my friends when I bring it out to shoot or just having a show and tell session. However ultimately when I'm gone that story kinda goes with me. To anyone else it's a funny story sure but the .44 is just another Ruger Blackhawk to anyone else. Or am I wrong?

After the third round was sent down range i asked my buddies if they wanted to shoot it. Afterwards it went back in the house and my mind wandered into the you know why not put it towards something you'll actually enjoy shooting. I know the pawn shop down the road has a couple rifles that I have been looking at lately. I immediately felt like I betrayed my family lineage somehow.

I have been back and forth on this for about a week now. There's a part of me that thinks that if I do sell/trade it for something I will actually shoot more often by Grandpa, my dad and great grandpa would be alright with it. Another part of me cringes at the thought of getting rid of "a family gun". The only reason I made sure I kept it in the first place is because of the story behind it.

I don't recall if I mentioned in that post that my great grandpa had to send it back to Ruger in pieces due to double charging a reload. So it's been refinished from the factory and I have the invoice for the rebuild.

That in a nut shell is where I'm stuck. Anyone in a similar bind or maybe on the other side of it. Perhaps this will help someone out in the future find some peace with whatever decision they make with a gun that was passed on to them (assuming we'll still have that option). I appreciate you for reading this post and welcome any thoughts you may have.
We shoot/enjoy best what kicks us least. It sounds as if your Blackhawk has some emotional value to you. Not a thing wrong with that. Commercial .44 special ammo will provide a better shooting experience, and if you reload, all the better....44 Special reloads in .44 Mag. brass. After all, if " Dirty Harry" used them, what's not to like? :thumbup: Good luck !
 
Or gift it to a treasured friend. When my wife died last year, I took some of her possessions to the memorial and allowed her friends to have their pick. Yesterday I noticed my best friend's wife was wearing my wife's favorite insulated jackets -- it gave me a good feeling.
A great post, Dave....you've added another chapter to my eventual plans. Thanks, Rod
 
Back
Top