Mine cost $347.95 no tax. I just shot it today although briefly. Lots of snow here recently and I was in dress shoes standing in 10" of snow. I fired 10 shots, one missfire, but I have used the Remington 22Subsonic ammo before and that does tend to happen. Three shots at about 40yrds were touching and the other 6 were in a group to the right about five inches in diameter. Probably because I am right handed and it was hard to keep from shivering in 20deg weather, standing in snow with a good deal of wind. The action was so smooth, the rifle so well balanced, it was a lot of fun to shoot.
Don't sell the Henry, why sell a nice rifle to have another nice rifle? Keep it and just have nice rifles.
BTW, it was new.