AStone
Member
Well, I've been bitten by a bug called ... yeah, see subject line.
I'm a fan of blades. Have been since I was very young. I remember my first pocket knife that my dad gave me - a Case - and my first fixed blade: a military knife from a surplus store.
But even though I've owned hunting/survival knives, folders, machetes (though no kukri ... yet), I've never owned a dagger or a boot knife.
I've decided that's going to change. For reasons I'll explain later, in a follow up post, I'm in the market for one ... or more - of each.
I've been doing my homework for a while, reading web pages, including some here at THR. I've shared some PM's with a couple of "experts". <ahem>
I've read a lot of reviews of knives by SOG, Boker, Gerber, Applegate Fairbairn, Kershaw, Falkniven, Smith Wesson, Cold Steel ... others.
As soon as I get some time (oh, I hope I get some of that), I'll post some of the essays, history, reviews and sale pages for daggers and boot knives (let's call them "boots").
Yet, I want more.
I want to learn lots about these specialized weapons - and let's be clear, I'm talking here about double-edged, pointy knives that are weapons, either SD or offensive, not pointy utility blades.
{Added by edit the following day: When reading John S's post #13, I realized that it's probably unfair to restrict discussions to "double-edged" blades exclusively, even if I tend to think of daggers and boots in such terms. Suffice to say, regardless of how we define them, I'm trying to keep the discussion here focused on daggers & boot knives, and away from survival knives, hunting knives, culinary, etc. }
The concept alone intrigues me, let alone their potential uses.
I'm also the kind of guy that likes to collect a whole bunch of information about one particular weapon (or type of weapon) in a single place. (Just click on "levers" and "wheels" in my sig line for a couple of examples.)
Now, I know this isn't BladeForum, and that there are fewer officianadoes of daggers/boots here than there. But that's ok. This is weapons home for me, so I'd rather learn here, at least enough so that when I go over there, I don't get laughed at for asking stupid questions.
Here are some of the questions I have, that I suggest we discuss in here.
* Who are the worst/best makers?
* What are the pros/cons of short/long blades?
* Is there an optimal dagger blade/total length?
* Is there an optimal boot blade/total length?
* Is there an optimal blade shape?
* Which steel is best for daggers/boots?
* Do serrated edges matter? Pro/con?
* What's the best shape and material for a grip?
* What should the guards look like?
* Who makes the best sheaths, out of what material?
* What carry tips should we know about?
* What can you share about dagger/boot knife history?
* What should we know about legalities?
* What about training?
* What other stuff needs discussing?
And then, of course, there are the personal stories, those of you behind the scenes in {insert foreign country here} sneaking up on the palace with only your trusted _________ dagger, and preventing the coup de tat at the 11th hour.
Yes, pics are wonderful.
So, does all this make sense?
Hey, we've got a few knife experts in the house. Let's see what we know about these genres of knives.
Let's make this thread into a dagger/boot knife grand central.
Note that I even chose a pointy thing as the thread icon.
OK, have fun with it. I'm here to learn.
Maybe I'll even contribute something.
Nem
PS 1: This thread is dedicated to the memory of Byron Quick (see post 13 for motivation).
PS 2: I just realized that my user name refers to a dagger like projection - a nematocyst - fired from a specialized jellyfish cell called a cnidocyte. Maybe that explains my interest in these knives.
I'm a fan of blades. Have been since I was very young. I remember my first pocket knife that my dad gave me - a Case - and my first fixed blade: a military knife from a surplus store.
But even though I've owned hunting/survival knives, folders, machetes (though no kukri ... yet), I've never owned a dagger or a boot knife.
I've decided that's going to change. For reasons I'll explain later, in a follow up post, I'm in the market for one ... or more - of each.
I've been doing my homework for a while, reading web pages, including some here at THR. I've shared some PM's with a couple of "experts". <ahem>
I've read a lot of reviews of knives by SOG, Boker, Gerber, Applegate Fairbairn, Kershaw, Falkniven, Smith Wesson, Cold Steel ... others.
As soon as I get some time (oh, I hope I get some of that), I'll post some of the essays, history, reviews and sale pages for daggers and boot knives (let's call them "boots").
Yet, I want more.
I want to learn lots about these specialized weapons - and let's be clear, I'm talking here about double-edged, pointy knives that are weapons, either SD or offensive, not pointy utility blades.
{Added by edit the following day: When reading John S's post #13, I realized that it's probably unfair to restrict discussions to "double-edged" blades exclusively, even if I tend to think of daggers and boots in such terms. Suffice to say, regardless of how we define them, I'm trying to keep the discussion here focused on daggers & boot knives, and away from survival knives, hunting knives, culinary, etc. }
The concept alone intrigues me, let alone their potential uses.
I'm also the kind of guy that likes to collect a whole bunch of information about one particular weapon (or type of weapon) in a single place. (Just click on "levers" and "wheels" in my sig line for a couple of examples.)
Now, I know this isn't BladeForum, and that there are fewer officianadoes of daggers/boots here than there. But that's ok. This is weapons home for me, so I'd rather learn here, at least enough so that when I go over there, I don't get laughed at for asking stupid questions.
Here are some of the questions I have, that I suggest we discuss in here.
* Who are the worst/best makers?
* What are the pros/cons of short/long blades?
* Is there an optimal dagger blade/total length?
* Is there an optimal boot blade/total length?
* Is there an optimal blade shape?
* Which steel is best for daggers/boots?
* Do serrated edges matter? Pro/con?
* What's the best shape and material for a grip?
* What should the guards look like?
* Who makes the best sheaths, out of what material?
* What carry tips should we know about?
* What can you share about dagger/boot knife history?
* What should we know about legalities?
* What about training?
* What other stuff needs discussing?
And then, of course, there are the personal stories, those of you behind the scenes in {insert foreign country here} sneaking up on the palace with only your trusted _________ dagger, and preventing the coup de tat at the 11th hour.
Yes, pics are wonderful.
So, does all this make sense?
Hey, we've got a few knife experts in the house. Let's see what we know about these genres of knives.
Let's make this thread into a dagger/boot knife grand central.
Note that I even chose a pointy thing as the thread icon.
OK, have fun with it. I'm here to learn.
Maybe I'll even contribute something.
Nem
PS 1: This thread is dedicated to the memory of Byron Quick (see post 13 for motivation).
PS 2: I just realized that my user name refers to a dagger like projection - a nematocyst - fired from a specialized jellyfish cell called a cnidocyte. Maybe that explains my interest in these knives.
Last edited: