Just gathering information for future use, as a non-Glock owner, but why did you keep the G26 and G34 and get rid of the rest?
Not speaking for P5 Guy here, but I more or less did the same thing. Well, about the 26 and a similar larger gun. Im not down to "just two" though.
After having 17's, 19's, and 26's, and a couple of 42's and 43's, I came to realize that if I had to have just two, it would be a 17 and 26, and if I had to have just one, it would be the 26.
The 26 is a deceptive little critter that is really way more gun than a lot of people realize. Its small enough to go where the 19's won't, yet it shoots like the bigger guns above it, and with a simple mag change, can have the same capacity.
It is slightly fatter/larger than the single stacks, but that mag compatibility cinches things there for me and makes up for any little bit of extra size. The fatter grip also makes the gun a lot easier to control and the single stacks want to squirm around in my hand when I shoot them.
I normally carry a 17, and use a 26 as a BUG or, if for some storage reason, I cant carry the 17, I'll use the 26 as a primary, but that doesn't happen much. I quit using things like my Seecamps, LCP's etc for BU's when I figured out I could just as easily carry my 26 in the same type holsters in the same places.
And while I do still have a couple of them, I still cant for the life of me see the advantage or appeal to the 19's. The 45's are even dumber when you get down to it, and yet I have a couple of them too.