expensive gun / cheap knife - don't get it!!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Granted misplacing stuff or inadvertently leaving small stuff behind happens. I'm pretty amazed at some who've lost car keys/fobs, wallets, phones and any other number of EDC gear. Making the conscious effort to be aware and inventory before leaving helps too. I lost one knife ~$200 because it slipped from the retention device and I didn't hear it hit ground. When I came home to find the sheath empty it was o_O Since then I make sure to do a quick pat to insure that the basics are in place.

Following the knife show I have had urges for a new knife though. I don't feel I'd find the performance differences between them in my typical usage. Budget entry level knives with some steels yes, that may happen in a matter of a few cardboard box cuttings. When traveling by air, the custom is swapped out for an entry level $15 Gerber picked up from Target. If TSA takes that I'm not cursing the loss of my main knife.
 
I have a 1911 I paid $1K for. The bottom one is my EDC knife. The top is a spare I bought when I thought I lost the lower one, less than $2 at Harbor Freight. It has done every thing I've asked of it

DSC02509_zpsfcxfuuek.jpg
 
It's all good my friend,,,
For me it's a funny thing.

Give me a nice ball-point pen and I'll lose or misplace it within two months,,,
The plastic advertising pen from my credit union that's in my pocket now,,,
That el-cheapo is at least a year old.

It's the same with pocket knives,,,
I have been gifted several fine knives over the years,,,
The only one I've managed to keep is the Schrade I have on a display shelf.

My Uncle gave it to me when I went into the service way back in 1970,,,
I knew better than to carry it so I made a small display rack for it.

Aarond

.
 
You poor kids!
There was a time not long ago when every man carried a pocket knife, and not necessarily a junker---these were working tools that were expected to perform. Also part of vocational education in schools would include making a knife of some sort, on a forge. Maybe not a great knife, but we learned what went into making them.
In my town we had a good hardware store and it was a right of passage to buy your first knife from them, accompanied by dad who would demonstrate how folders walk and talk.
For boys that didn't have dads, a kindly old sales clerk filled in but in any case, you'd end up walking and talking whole lot of pocket knives before settling on the one that was going to be yours.
 
IMHO, a good quality knife at a low price is something to treasure, like a Mora, or one of the more basic SAK models.
 
There was a time not long ago

Since I went through high school in the early 1970s I can agree that a pocket knife was common. I carried an Uncle Henry. They became less common as the population in general found less daily use for them and then eventually with "zero tolerance" policies on weapons and the tendency to "fail safe" prohibiting any knife, they essentially disappeared in any but the most rural districts. While my school had a large voc program a forge wasn't part of it. I wish it had been since I'd have forged my first knife there instead of years later. I
 
Well some folks no doubt buy cheap knives so they can afford expensive guns........

Among my "stuff" is what several kids thought was a "messed up arrow head"....even though the size alone would have made anyone round abouts that "knew anything" know it was a "messed up Atl-atl dart war head" and they would have been wrong as well. It was someone's knife likely just before old Pounce (come on , pronounce it Pouncy!) de Leon brought the wonders of moderninity and tourism to Florida. Folks that live in places where man meets nature NEED a knife, folks that work someplace other than the sterile halls of metropolis NEED a knife.

Up through about 9th grade there was technecally a knife ban in public schools, though not only did it not get enforced but it was not unusual for a male teacher especially to ask to borrow your knife or even just see it. When intergration happened in my school system, suddenly the knife ban rules were enforced. Still a lot of us still carried. I had a pearlish handled Old Grand Dad my Old Grand Dad gave me I continued to carry on regular school days until Same Grand Dad gave me my Demo Kit Knife which I then carried. One of my best white buddies carried a hawk billed Barlow with the long bolster (as did my Mother BTW) and one of my best Black Buddies carried a thin, long folding "fruit knife"......that he actually used for a fruit knife. Actually knew a kid that carried a straight razor and noticed the occasional single edge razor wedged between the heel and sole of a shoe while folks changed in gym class. Basically very few of the teachers "looked for a knife" and having a knife was generally just an adittional "charge" if one got into trouble. Oddly although there were a few pretty bad, as in hospital bad, fights I don't recall anyone during a normal school day getting carved up or stabbed.....with a knife..... #2 pencil or ball point pen or fork from lunchroom yes, but no knives. Football games and dances maybe a few times in three years, but rare and oddly not between races.

When I went into the service the first time in the early 1970's I was SHOCKED that first night when they told us they were checking every thing we had for weapons and that included common folding pocket knives that would all be confiscated. Induction center had not warned us either. I had one of my best friends in my pocket and he was a tool by gosh! It was my demo kit knife (don't start, that is what we called them in Demo School and one was part of the Infantry Platoon demo kit and a part that had to be often replaced) I had taken to carrying, non military types can think "Scout Knife, one blade, can opener, bottle opener/flat head screwdriver, marlin spike/punch, bail hanger all stainless no scales. Mine was one of the older models with the stud on the Screwdriver/ bottle opener that helped open it and push out the clip guide pin on an M-1 Garand. I palmed my knife and when a Smokey The Bear hatted NCO came to check my gear opened my palm so he could see it, looked him in the eye, and pocketed it. He sort of smiled and nodded and went on his way. Did not even raise an eyebrow at the little sharpening stone in my shaving kit either. For the next ten days or so I had apparently the only knife in the training platoon. First time they let us go to the little PX annex for polish, soap, and brasso a lot of Barlow knives got bought and a few more expensive Old Henrys and Trees got bought as well. I resharpened and cleaned up a lot edges on knives those first eight weeks. I still have at least one of the Demo kit knives I occasionally carry, though that original one disappeared from the top of my foot locker while I sat next to it cleaning my boots moments before lights out about 14 weeks later. Never knew it had legs. Well at least another Infantryman got it....

Yes the slim little sheath knife I wear to church along the inside seam of my trousers might be worth more than my (cheap) EDC gun. My day to day carry knife though is the cheap knife from Home depot that RC raved about not long before he left us and IIRC cost about $10 and it has worked fine. I even, after using it a bit, bought one for each of my kids for camping and such.

-kBob
 
I have always believed that a good knife was the most important thing to have on your body.There is nothing more useful that you could have on you.It could save a life,yours a dogs a childs, cut a seat belt,break a window in a sinking or burning car,help someone breath.If you carry a firearm to protect those you love but don’t have a good knife or two on you then you are not up to the job.
Learn about knives get a good one and “Keep It Sharp”.
 
I have expensive knives but not guns, well no WC or anything like that. Kimber, SA, S&W - that kind of guns. I have knives that cost over $400 but don't carry them anymore since I lost one. That hurt!

It got replaced by the maker (Thank God) but now I stick to Benchmades for carry, and sometimes a good old Case 048.

I hate cheap knives that can fail, I just won't use them. It has to be quality and made in the USA, that's another reason I like Benchmade.
 
This has been a great read! I have learned some stuff.
I have/do carry off and on for years since my youth. I did not learn from my dad, unfortunately. Always bought and carried cheep stuff but I have a great Browning buck knife from years ago.
I have just recently been learning about qualiy knifes. I now EDC carry Kershaw, Benchmade and Spyderco mid range ($40~100) knifes. Have some better ones at home that I carry as I feel.
The same can be said of my guns. I carry my mid-range ones most often and rotate my $800.00 + ones as needed.

Thanks all for your stories and input.

Lateck,
 
"Some people can keep track of things and others can't. That informs their choices." - hso

The man who wrote that knows more about knives than any person I've ever known.
He gives great advice, but not quite as simple as what my dad advised:

"Buy the best tool you can afford."

Truth be told, my expensive EDC knives get more frequent maintenance than any EDC firearms
I own...but then, my EDC knife of choice gets used many times a day. I pray that I won't have to
use my EDC firearms of choice...just exercise them regularly.

Cheap tools fail frequently when they are used regularly; sometimes they injure you or someone else, or
worse, leave you defenseless in the most extreme circumstances.

Choose any category you like...knife, firearm, drill, chainsaw, impact wrench, etcetera...but take my dad's advice. One of these days, you'll understand why.
 
I'm more likely to cut open a box or uncork a bottle of wine than I am to stab something. So my everyday carry knife is locking blade Swiss Army.
 
Knifes...hmm. I don’t think I’ve ever NOT broken a benchmade. Fixed and folding. I got tired of it after awhile, and started buying SOG, for cheaper, at least at the time. Never broken a pup I’ve owned. Usually always lose folding knives eventually however.
I think it’s just another one if the things that go with lifestyle choices. You can find a gun for a good VALUE, as well as a solid knife. But some people like putting more...or less coin into the matter. Then get vocal about it either way. As long as what you have works for your application, it shouldn’t matter what the masses think.
 
On a separate note, when people say edc gear and are referencing a knife, are we talking as a weapon or a tool? Or is it going to be an array of mixed answers?
 
Reading through this post made me realize how many knives i have. I like and have expensive guns. I have expensive knives a couple are safe queens but i bought a Stewart Mitchell knife, English knife maker , quite a few years ago that is a scary sharp knife that holds a great edge. I only use it when boar hunting. Back in 78 i visited the US and bought an Frontier Imperial eagle knife # 415, $9 i think it cost. That little knife has done hundreds and hundreds of deer. I had a new sheath made for it that cost 10 times what the knife cost new.
I have a couple of folders, a Buck and a Kershaw that a mate gave me and it looked like someone had been cutting bricks with them. I reshaped and sharpened the blades and they are in my work jacket when working in the forest.
I shot in and won a running boar competition a couple of years ago and won a S&W model #860 U.S.A it has Made In USA on the sheath but looking on the internet they are made in Asia?
I even have a buck gentleman's knife i won when working my springer spaniel in a field trial, It was the guns prize.
I also have a couple or three hand made Swedish knives. One made by a old hunter, long dead that follows me on all my hunting trips. It's only ever used for cutting smoked sausage and dried meat.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top