G17 opinions.

[DougW]

My G26 with the +2 mag extensions is nearly as big and my G19's. The slide is a bit shorter making is easier to conceal, but it is as shootable as my 19's or 17"s.

For shootability, I really like my 1Gen G17 a little bit better than my 3Gen G17. But, I do like the light rail on the 3Gen. Both are great shooters.

 

[ckone]

The G17 is THE benchmark 9mm hi-cap semi-auto pistol, a few are as good, but none are better. They're every bit a "classic" as much as any 1911 or Hi-Power.

G34's are longer, but that's about it, they share the same exact lower and feel almost identical, while I like the 34's I prefer the 17's, they got it pretty much right on the first try.

 

[trickyasafox]

tough to go wrong with a g17- especially if you don't mind used. Great deals to be had on used LEO trade-ins.

 

[Tecolote]

The Glock 17 is what a Glock 19 dreams of being when it grows up.

In all seriousness, you can't go wrong with a Glock 17. Some Gen4s have exhibited uncharacteristic unreliability, but Glocks is working on resolving the issue. Unless you're set on a Gen4, I would stick with a Gen3. Check the classifieds for excellent deals on NIB and LNIB. I've gotten excellent prices and superb service from www.scpfirearms.com

 

[Sebastian the Ibis]

Looking into the G17. What do you guys think of it?

Pretty much perfect right out of the box. I took a Glock armorer's course 2 weeks ago, so I just had to put in a 3.5 trigger and other "upgrades." I took it to the range yesterday and the rounds were ejecting weird and the slide was not always locking back. I'm taking the "upgrades" out as soon as I get home.

Resist the urge, and leave it as it is - except for adding Heine straight 8 sights of course!

 

[pvthouse]

Thanks for the opinions guys. The .22 lr kit would be a good alternative with the exception that it makes a duty size weapon feel like a toy due to the lack of weight for reliable cycling. I want something that would be good for the range and for carry. But as far as upgrades go I'm thinking completely stock with the exception of night sights.

 

[tinygnat219]

The G17 is a great gun. I just want something a little more concealable. So I chose the G19.