'Girlfriend won't be charged in man's shooting death'

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stand_Watie

Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2004
Messages
1,506
Location
east Texas
Here is one that goes in the 'win' column, but Sara Brady et al will claim it as anti-gun propoganda as well. This is what they mean when they tell you "your gun is more likely to be used against a loved one etc....".




****
http://www.mlive.com/news/muchronicle/index.ssf?/base/news-3/1074435373153600.xml

Saturday, January 17, 2004

By Lisa Medendorp
CHRONICLE STAFF WRITER

No criminal charges will be filed against a Whitehall woman who fatally shot her boyfriend last March through the closed bedroom door of their duplex.

Rick Robert Butler, 44, of 314 S. Hall, was shot just before 6 a.m. on March 2.

His girlfriend, Wanda Baessler, afterward went directly to the Whitehall Police Department, saying to an officer: "Please help me! I just shot my boyfriend!"

She wasn't wearing shoes, despite the cold and snow on the ground, police reported.

At the time, she told police she was afraid of Butler and had barricaded the door against him. She said she couldn't call police because he'd cut the telephone lines.

The decision not to charge Baessler was announced Friday afternoon by the Muskegon County Prosecutor's Office. The investigation was lengthy and detailed, as was the review of all of the circumstances, police and prosecutors said.

It was a decision Whitehall Police Chief Donald Hulbert said he supported.

"It's one of those things that I'm sure people who aren't privileged to all of the details of the case look at and feel something should have been done," Hulbert said. "But having all the facts and background information, I feel the prosecutor's office came up with the appropriate decision."

That decision was based on a number of factors, including Butler's past history of violence against his ex-wife and a domestic violence charge that was pending against him, with Baessler the victim, Hulbert said...

...Tague described Butler as being "volatile" the night of his death. He also said Butler had a history of substance abuse. The toxicology report from Butler's autopsy showed he had methadone, methadone metabolite and sertraline (brand name Zoloft, an anti-depressant) in his system when he died.

"A search of the residence found over 55 prescription bottles in Butler's name containing controlled substances prescribed by multiple doctors," Tague said...

...When Baessler did arrive home, Butler assaulted her and cut the phone lines. He then left. She took a shotgun and one shell into the bedroom after barricading both the front and bedroom doors, according to the material presented in the prosecutor's opinion.

Butler returned to the residence, kicked in the front door and Baessler "fearing a further assault ... fired one warning shot through the closed bedroom door," Tague said...
 
fired one warning shot through the closed bedroom door

Whoops!

In NC it's legal to shoot through your front door. :)

Good shoot insofar as I'm concerned. Glad she has a shotgun.
 
[blockquote]Butler returned to the residence, kicked in the front door and Baessler "fearing a further assault ... fired one warning shot through the closed bedroom door," Tague said..[/blockquote]
This is ridiculous. Perhaps the girlfriend shouldn't be charged, but there's no way that firing a "warning shot" through a door is acceptable. Now every idiot with a gun is going to think it's okay to do that, because the police don't seem terribly concerned.
 
Hmmmm....she takes one shell in there with her, barricades the door, then, in fear for her life, she decides to use her one shell for a warning shot...
confused.gif
 
Don't bet on it, Ortho. I was in the same position once, right down to the cut phone lines. It won't happen again.
 
Hopefully not including shooting your one cartridge as a "warning shot" through the door... :rolleyes:
 
This is ridiculous. Perhaps the girlfriend shouldn't be charged, but there's no way that firing a "warning shot" through a door is acceptable. Now every idiot with a gun is going to think it's okay to do that, because the police don't seem terribly concerned.
Somebody kicks in the door to your house and is trying to do the same to your locked bedroom door, what's the problem with firing through the door? Do you think he was coming to apologize? Or it was a concerned loved one kicking in the door to make sure she was OK? She knew who was on the other side of the door, and he intended to hurt or kill her, and he got exactly what he deserved.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top