HK P30 Review (Heavy Pics)

Status
Not open for further replies.

ZAT

Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2007
Messages
17
Location
Round Rock, TX
Having spent the day cleaning out the garage, including the safe, I headed over to my local shop to sell off a rifle that hasn’t seen the light of day in a couple of years. Low and behold, what do I run across as soon a I enter the store, but an HK P30 fresh out of its UPS shipper and barely with a price tag on it. Well after some drooling, haggling, begging and groveling I came away with an even trade on the HK. If you have followed HK for a while you will know that the P30 is about as anticipated as the still upcoming HK45. The hype on both these guns has been in overdrive over the past few quarters. Needless to say, the units that have seen the shelves of dealers are going for a wide range of prices.

Depending on your location anywhere from $790-$1000 buys you:
1 gun
2 fifteen round magazines
1 large back strap
1 medium back strap (installed)
1 small back strap
1 set large side panels
1 set medium side panels (installed)
1 set small side panels
1 key for internal lock
1 P series owners manual
1 warranty card
1 HK rebranded Master gun lock
2 spent cases
1 small bag desiccant

contents.jpg

Out of the box the gun was literally dripping in lubricant. I am willing to bet that HK owns stock in some lube company :) As soon as I got home I took the thing apart and spent a LOOOONG time cleaning out the grease and oil form the various nooks and crannies. Disassembly is simple:
Retract slide until the tab on the slide stop aligns with the take down notch on the slide.
left-side-close.jpg
The neat thing about locating the take down notch so far forward on the slide is that it is impossible to disassemble the gun with a round in the chamber.
You then push out the slide stop lever from right to left until the tab clears the slide and it locks in place.
Slide-stop-out.jpg
This is as far as the lever goes as it stays attached to the frame after disassembly, which is very nice as it leaves one less loose part to misplace.
The slide then comes off to the front as with any other handgun. Below are some pics of the gun after disassembly.
side-panels-off.jpg
back-strap-off.jpg
lock-up-close.jpg
guide-rod-in.jpg
Trigger-close.jpg
slide-assy.jpg
Slide-inside.jpg
Guide-Rod-Side.jpg
Guide-Rod-Bottom.jpg
Chamber.jpg
mag-disassembled.jpg
Left-Side.jpg

After spending considerable time trying to get all the goop out of the gun, all the while wishing I had bought some gun scrubber to hose the thing down with, I got it back together and had a chance to inspect and dry fire the crap out of it. Fit and finish is above average for the most part. Exterior surfaces have no machining marks visible, but the inside of the slide where some of the reliefs are cut you can see slight marks. “Bluing” is even through out the gun, with the exception of the slide stop levers. These look like they are worn at the edges. Not really bad, but also not what one would expect from a gun commanding premium prices. Side to frame fit is pretty tight,. You can barely feel any movement in the slide either side to side or up and down. Lock up is also very tight. About the only thing that is loose is the slide stop lever on the right side of the gun which hs a good amount of play.

Size wise the gun is definitely a compact with a full sized frame. Below are some pics of the P30 next to my MP9, G21SF and the MP9 mag.
mp9-top.jpg
mp9back.jpg
g21-top.jpg
P30mag-mp9mag.jpg
mags-front.jpg

The pictures, however, don’t do it justice wrt ergonomics. The P30 is probably one of the most comfortable guns that I have held. I would rate it better than the MP series simply because of the ability to separately adjust the with and length of the grip. You can mix and match the various panels and straps to get just the right feel for your hand and shooting style. For me, because of the DA/SA transition I ended up with the medium back strap coupled with the large side panels. This offers me a good purchase on the gun and still allows me to reach the DA trigger without having some huge grip transition to the SA trigger. Below are some measurements of how the various panels effect trigger reach and circumference. Trigger reach for all panels when measured horizontally form the center of the trigger to the back strap is 2.9”(DA) and 2.5” (SA). Grip circumference was measured at the middle finger groove.
Small back strap and panels: 5 5/8”
Medium back strap and panels: 5 3/4”
Large back strap and panels: 6 1/4”

Say want you will about the Spider Man grips, but they work. They offer very good grip without being abrasive. I will preface this that all shooting was done at an indoor range. While there was no AC in the place, it still isn’t the same as sweating buckets outdoors. Also, many people have complained about the addition of the finger grooves. While they are there I did not even notice them. About the only negative I can add about the grips is the fit of the back strap. If you hold the frame in one hand and move the upper end of the straps they wiggle. My guess is somewhere around .005”-.010”. I am surprised that our German friends didn’t incorporate some tab/dowel to fix this end of the strap as well. I will add that I could not feel the strap shift during firing or handling of the gun, so this is probably a non issue.

Trigger is your standard DA/SA jobber. DA trigger pull feels to be around 12# and the SA pull measured a consistent 5.5# out of the box. DA travel measures around .70” while the SA travel is around .25”. These measurements do not include any pre or over travel. I am estimating that these are both around .10-.15”. Trigger reset is very long at .40” from full travel to reset. There is a bit of stacking on the DA side of things, but the break is pretty predictable. On the SA side of things there is a bit of creep, but again the break is predictable. I would love to see an over travel stop incorporated like the USP match series, but then this is a duty gun, not a comp gun…yet

Sights are standard 3 dot with a .140 front mated to a .155 rear notch. They are coated with Superluminova and appear yellow instead of white. The SL is a neat touch, but I would rate it only slightly better than nothing. The sights work as needed. The post to notch ratio allows for enough light for quick sight picture, but also for finer shots to be placed. I would have preferred a wider notch, but them my eyes aren’t what they used to be.

cover.jpg

After a few days of dry firing I finally managed to get to the range and put a few rounds through her. Below is a list of ammo used all of which was 115 FMJ

Winchester WB 150 rds
Monarch 100 rds
CCI Blazer 100 rds
PMC 50 rds
Sellier&Bellot 200 rds

Total round count 600 rds.

I began the day with the Monarch, since my MP9 loves the stuff. The HK did not like it at the onset. It is pretty soft shooting stuff and I experienced 3 stove pipes out of the first magazine. I went through the rest of the ammo with no further malfunctions, including the rest of the Monarch. The gun is a very soft shooter. Recoil is pretty mild and very manageable. I would put it on par with the MP9 as far as controllability and feel goes. I didn’t really shoot it for accuracy, but when I did my part I was able to put together some very tight clover leafs. I also didn’t have an PD ammo to run through it, but will do so at the next outing.

So what is the conclusion you may ask. Well it’s a great little gun. Great ergonomics. Seems to be a pretty good shooter which will improve with some dry firing. Over all, I think that it will fit in great as an EDC gun. However, I would not run out and spend the exorbitant prices that these guns are getting right now. I don’t regret making the trade on it, but I would wait till the supply side of the equation catches up with the hype and prices settle down a bit. The biggest bummer about the whole thing is that it leaves one Jonesing for the HK45 even more.
 
great write up and pics!!

that being said...for $1000 it looks like yet another Glock, XD, M&P, PX4.....with $500 tagged on for the HK logo.

No thanks.

Im with you on your last sentence...if you are going to spend that much get the metal one!

:D
 
The price is a bummer for sure. Although, I have seen prices drop by about $100 over the past week or so. I would think that if the price settles down around the $700 price it may be worth it. Given that it is HK i doubt that it will get that low. HK may end up pricing itself out of the running for most folks. They make a damned sexy gun that runs great and shoots very well, but it surely isnt worth twice the competition.
 
Zat

I had a chance to handle (fondle), one at a gun show last week. The only think I wasn't crazy about was the shape and location of the decocker tab at the back of the slide. I thought the hammer dropped very hard when the decocker was activated, making me wonder what was happening inside the slide with the firing pin. I see by your pics (very helpful, by the way), that there is a block for the hammer to engage, but how sturdy does this look to you? I also noticed what seemed to be a lack of bluing on the slide stop levers, almost as if they were worn or used already. Other than that, I thought the gun felt great in the hand, and I hope it performs as well as it looks.
 
Thanks a ton for the review. Really excellent reading, maybe you should freelance for gun mags.
It seems like an interesting pistol, to say the least. Now granted as a new pistol it doesn't have the rep of the GLOCK for instance, but as a slim alternative to fatter doublestack autos, this could be a really great CCW piece.
 
Excellent write-up; I enjoyed reading it. Thank you for taking the time to put this together.
 
I just picked mine up today. Its a great feeling handgun. I cant wait to run a couple thousand rounds through it.
 
Thank you very much, outstanding post on the new HK30. This is the kind of thing that makes the highroad such an great forum. Although i'd love to have one, i think the HK's are still overpriced. Unfortunately i think our american dollar will continue to buy less and less in the coming years.
 
bannockburn,

I wasn't all that hot on the decock system either till I got a chance to use it. Its definitely not ambidextrous, but does work very well for a righty. I also like that it leaves the profile of the gun clean. Since there is no safety there really is no reason to have levers on the side like the v3 USP. The hammer does bang forward with some oomph if yoi simply let it slam forward. I try not to do that too much and end up riding the hammer forward with my weak hand. Just looking at ths mechanics of it it looks like the stop is pretty solid. It is loaded in compression for the most part so you would have to crush the metal for the hammer to go forward completely. You also have to contend with the firing pin block before you can create a discharge.

Tecumseh,

I cant comment on how it compares to the P2000 as I dont own one and have never shot one.

On a different note I wonder if the trigger mechanism is identical to the P2000 so it could be converted to the LEM or better yet a Match LEM.

Thanks for the complements on the review.
 
That "Zat" fellow sure can put together an amazing technical document!!!!

IN fact, I think the write-up itself is better than the gun :D

If HK were smart, they would have hired him to promote their product.
 
Very good review, I am sure that its a fine pistol as HKs tend to be, but I agree with the poster about price being so much because of the HK stamp. Plastic frames are about $4.00 to make.............
 
All that effort put into making the grip just perfect, and they still can't give it a single action trigger? Not even as an option? Come on, HK. Even SIG has gotten the word.
 
Thanks for the info, good write up!

I'll stick with my M&P, the P30 doesn't do anything for me the more I look at it and hear about it. I think if I were going to spend that much on a handgun I'd go with all metal construction. That just seems like a huge hunk of change for a polymer gun....oh wait that's right its got the HK logo on it, I forgot how expensive that feature can be.

The grip still makes me think of Batman:rolleyes:
 
Zat,
Thanks for the review, great pics and labels, very easy to understand. The decock button by the hammer is one of the better ideas to come along. Now that I've used it for about a year, it's one of the those slap your forehead "why didn't I think of that" innovations.

Everyone reviewing the P30 remarks on the terriffic grips. That feeling that it was made for me is important in a gun you plan to shoot alot.

As to the price...well, all I can say is that I was happy to find My P2000SK at $684, and I've never looked back. Well worth the money IMHO. I've paid more for guns and I've paid less...but I don't think I've found better. At around the $700 mark the P30 may turn out to be a great deal...

What did you think of the sights, which are a slight departure from normal H&K?
 
I prefer the M&P which is also much more reasonably priced and Smith has better service than HK. I also think the bore axis on this pistol is rather high and it feels unbalanced or top heavy. I am not a fan of DA/SA but at least this trigger doesn't suck as much as most HK triggers do. It does feel like it is built like a tank which is good. Anyway it's interesting but I have no desire for one. Which also tells me the .45 will probably leave me cold. Great review though. Thanks.
 
The sights are different to say the least. I am not sold on the whole Superluminova thing. Great for watches, but I am not so sure its the best thing for gun sights. For one, the rears tend to glow brighter since they are exposed to more light, not being tucked into a holster and all. I dont consider that a good thing. Just as important is that they can lead one into a false sense of security in believing that they are true night sights. They are not and will stop glowing a few hours after being charged from a light source. My biggest disappointment in the sight change is the fact that NOBODY makes tritium for it. Makers will have to set up new tools which they are not going to do till the gun starts selling in numbers. HK would have done much better had they stuck to the P2000 or USP design so that accessories could be easier to get.

I think the lack of a SAO action has more to do with sales numbers than not getting the hint. Sig SAO pistols are still hard to find, and in my area its not because people are buying them up like crazy. I would love the option of a V1 that could go DA/SA or SAO, but i dont think the P30 will have it. About the only thing I can see coming for the P30 is the LEM.

I dont find the gun to be unbalanced. It actually points very well for me and my hands/grip. Seems to point better than the MP9, but again, that is a very subjective thing. As for the bore axis, I have whined about it myself, but I dont think its HK, but more so the hammer fire system. All the guns with lower bore axes are striker fired guns like the Glock, MP and P7. If you look at Sig it too has a pretty high bore axis. I havent grown the testicular fortitude to pull every pin on this baby yet, so I cant comment on how much "wasted" space there is in the assembly.

I will stick to my statement form before on price. If they settle down to around the $700 range, it will do very well and will be worth it. If the price stays as high as it is currently, HK will loose market share as there is no reason to pay $800+ for a compact polymer 9mm. With that stated, I find it pretty funny that people pile on HK for the prices their products carry. Kick them in the nuts all you want for bad service, arrogant attitude, and lack of civilian support, but their prices are more the creation of the consumers who are willing pay and the individual dealers who are willing to charge. It is highly unlikely that HK sold my gun to dealer A for $X and a week later they sold a second dealer in my area a similar gun for $X-$100.

Thanks again for the positive feedback on the write up.
 
Congrats on your new pistol. It looks very nice. While myself I would not buy one at that price, do not let that discourage you from enjoying a firearm that YOU enjoy.
 
ZAT

Thanks for the write up and review I have been curious about these ever since I heard they were coming out.
I am curious to see how it rates and compares to the upcoming Sig 250.

Great review BTW.;)
 
Great review. I'm going to hold off and wait for the HK45. I have too many 9mm's as it is... is that even possible? I'm sure if my local dealer had one on the shelf when I walked in I would have it in my car 20 minutes later.
 
The decock button by the hammer is one of the better ideas to come along. Now that I've used it for about a year, it's one of the those slap your forehead "why didn't I think of that" innovations.

Yeah, except that CZ used it on their Model 110 over a decade ago.

It is a really nice review, Zat. Even though it makes me want to ask, "How much for just the little dessicant pack?"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top