How many of you have bought identical "spares" of your favourite handgun?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BCRider

Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2008
Messages
7,853
Location
Pacific North"Wet" Coast of Canada
Often I've been VERY tempted to buy a second copy of my favourite shooters. Especially if I see them for a decent price and in lovely shape. It takes some serious will power to just hand it back or step away from the computer.

But I know that the rest of you are weak and easily led astray :D So how many of you have bought a second or even third copy of your favourite or regular carry gun?

Pictures of the lovely pair or trio would not be amiss either.
 
Very guilty! When I find the ones I like, I get several. Concerns of parts to some degree, concerns of bans to a larger degree, desire to pass them down, current ease of purchasing them, etc.


How many times have you heard, "I wish I had gotten/kept xyz gun when they were easy to get..."
 
I wish. I'm lucky to buy two guns. Now my son has two of everything and he is not born yet.
 
Nah. I specifically make a point of not doing so as once I have one of something I consider that my "representative copy" and don't want any more of them.

This applies to categories in general - IE, since I have a Glock 17 I no longer care to own any Glocks (since they all follow the same general pattern).

Now that I have an M&P 9L, I no longer care to own another M&P (regardless of full-size/compact/chambering), though for a completely different design from S&W (say, a Sigma), I wouldn't mind getting.

That's just sort of my way though. I'm big on variety. Having multiples of an item to close to another just bores me. I also consider the spare parts argument fairly weak, as from a financial perspective it'd likely be far more cost effective to track down the parts you need when you need them then to buy a whole 'nother gun. Besides, in the unlikely event that you DO need them, you're still going to have to render one perfectly fine gun inoperable in order to bring the other back to life. Thats about like taking you finger out of one hole in a dam to plug another :D.
 
I should add that the closest I've gotten to a duplicate is when I recently bought a short barrel Model 66S&W. For my DA revolvers I've settled on mostly K frame guns in .38 or .357. Up to the 66 I had a Model 10 6" and a model 19-3 6". I'd used the 10 for some IDPA practice nights and liked it. So then along comes the 66 that's been "stretched" to 4.25", which up here converts it to Restricted which I can own. So now I've got 3 K frame guns in 38 or 357.

Like you guys are justifying it's not really duplicates so much as growing a family. Besides I've got a supplier for K frame Safariland speed loaders. Thus my focus on the K frames. WHICH, being as the K frame design is such a lofty example of perfection, isn't hard to take.... :D

But the point of this was buying Actual Identical TWINS ! ! ! !
 
They're not my carry guns, and they're not identical (one's a -5, and the other a -6), but I have a backup for the 686 I use in matches. It's setup and tuned nearly identically to my primary gun.

686pair.jpg
 
Just to follow up, in my lifetime it's gotten harder (meaning more restrictive) to get guns and such. I'm not optimistic about it getting easier. Get 'em while you can.

When I was a kid, guns were displayed and sold at the hardware store. I don't know what was required to buy one, but I suspect it was little more than handing over your cash.

Now, many places have purchase limits, wait limits, always a background check, and more reasons to deny people than ever.

What's the phrase, "here today, gone tomorrow.."
 
Only 1 here... When my Dad passed he left me his J frame. I carried it for a while, then thought of what would happen if I ever got into a bad situation. Well, rather than it winding up in an evidence locker without the chance, or, gosh knows how long to get it back, I bought another to carry and leave Dad's at home. I can't take the chance of losing Dad's, and the replacement, they can have....
 
None of mine are identical. Some are close...

Two S&W 39-2
Two Model 27...(ones a "pre" the other a -2)
Five Model 10/M&P's, different barrel lengths
Two Model 15's (one a "pre" the other a -3)
Two Charter Arms Undercover 38's (different barrel lengths)

Three 10/22's
Two Type 53/Chinese Mosin Nagants
 
I am well known for having matching sets of handguns. The past couple years I have been striving to pay off the mortgage and I sold a number of guns towards this goal. Still have a few pairs (although not all are absolutely identical). I like 22/38 combos.

standard.jpg


standard.jpg
 
I have duplicates of many guns. I make a point of having duplicates of carry guns and I always have them with me when I travel. That way, if one gets broken/stolen/lost I have another available that will use the same magazines/speed loaders and fit the same holsters that I have with me.
 
The only reason I would ever own two of something is if I intended to carry them both at the same time.
 
I like pairs, especially for defensive guns as mentioned above, since using one will normally see it confiscated for evidence. I like to keep things simple, especially for the certainly high stress situation that using a gun defensively would entail. I don't want to worry about manipulating a safety or dealing with a change from a da/sa trigger. I only want to have to worry about two things, front sight on the target and finger OFF the trigger unless it's GO time.

It's also fun having a spare second at the range with friends for a little friendly competition. My brother lives several hours away now and had to sell most of his guns when he got maried and things got tight. My best friend lives out of state and lost nearly all his guns to a nasty ex and extended unemployment. When they come in we can still go to the range and have alot of fun shooting the same guns with them using my spares.

Spares IMHO don't have to be exact duplicates. I have a Glock 34 & 17L, the same other than barrel length, and in .454 my Ruger SRH 7.5" & Alaskan are substantially different but I have two weapons that use the same ammo & have the same controls & similar feel. My Ruger Charger .22's however are exact duplicates, both topped with an Eotech and are an absolute blast to shoot against one another.

I personally like limiting calibers so as to only have to stock a couple different kinds of ammo. I mainly have .22lr, 9mm & .45 colt (for the .454's). If my brother brings his shotgun we both use 12ga. Keeps accidents from happening, don't need to worry about dropping a 20ga in the 12, or putting a .44 mag in a .45 colt etc.. Also means if I have a pistol mag it's a 9mm Glock, no worries about mixing in a .40 mag or one for an M&P. Both my .22's can share mags. K.I.S.S. is a very good concept IMHO.
 
Purt nearly. My carry is a Taurus Millenium PRO in 9mm. If the DA gets it, I have the next upgrade, a Taurus 24/7 PRO C DS. Same ammo, same ergos, same holster.
 
My EDC on the bottom, and my spare above it.

Kimbers.jpg

Since this picture was taken (several years ago), I have swapped the triggers in my 4" gun and my spare, so the only real difference between them is that the spare looks new, and the rollmarks are different. The EDC is a "Classic Stainless" and the spare is just a "Stainless." Aside from the trigger, changed by the previous owner, I cant find a difference.

I got the spare in case my EDC went down for some reason. Other than "I want one," which is a perfectly good reason IMO, I don't see a point in having doubles. It would be like having three Caprice Wagons (sprocket, are you on here?) for family or "wont fit in my Honda" duties instead of one. Sure the miles wont rack up as fast, but I would have to worry about maintenance on three cars, instead of just one.
 
Last edited:
I used to, I'm working away from it. When I got my first 3913 I was instantly enamored with the S+W 3rd gen single-stack 9mm's and went a little overboard. At one point I had a 3913, 3913 LS, 2 standard 3953's, a PC 3953, 3953 TSW and a CS9. When I accepted the fact that "I'm not a gun collector" :eek: I started getting rid of a few. I'm down to a std 3953, PC 3953 and 3913. When I decide what gun I want next, one of those will probably be sold to pay for it. (I try to not sell a gun away except to use the money for another gun.)

I figured out I don't have the money or the room to be "a collector", and I don't shoot the duplicates enough to justify keeping them. My daughter has recently started shooting with me for fun and showing a real interest. If that contiunues and she shows a preference for one of these or one of the other guns I have dupes of, it would probably become hers instead of sold or traded for another one for me.
 
Yes and No. I have 3 XDs, but each is different. One is a 9, one a 40 and one a 9SC. Don't think I'll exactly duplicate anything unless my wife wants her own, hence the two 9mm.
 
I can't say I ever have.
Then again, with school and everything my pockets were pretty empty. One of these days perhaps.
 
The one guy that made having 2 of the same gun for carry acceptable was Hopalong Cassidy and his matching Colt SAA's in .45LC, white stocks in the dual black holster rig embellished with silver detail. Now THAT made sense :D
 
Last edited:
The only gun I've yet owned that I considered buying a duplicate of was my Glock 26, just so I could carry both. :neener:

Kind of a pipe dream, and I doubt I'll ever do it, but in reality, I shoot the G26 nearly equally well with the right or left hand, while shooting one-handed, so.....;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top