I think it's started.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carl, the last time I was in Germany (several years ago) I picked up a couple of traditional German hunting knives, one for myself and one for my father.

They were in my checked luggage, and I got popped for a random check. The screening lady flipped when she saw the two 4" blade, stag handled hunting knives. She said it wasn't legal. I said, you're kidding, I bought them from a store in the city. There were bigger knives there. I have pocketknives in my bag, too. Oh, but those are legal. These aren't.

She ended up talking to her supervisor, and then marking my bag as containing "antique knives" to allow me to exit the country with them.

Blew my mind.
 
So will it end as illegal to point a little bit of steel? If so what about rocks?

Will eye surgey be reduced to how good a knapper is?

Perhaps we can do it all with a beam of light until the power goes out..
 
Macmac,
I think you may find that you are wrong, when you say:

You don't have the Right to Kill anyone ever!

I live in Oklahoma, where we have what is commonly referred to as the "Make My Day" law which allows authorized occupants of a dwelling to use any degree of force, including deadly force against intruders.

I have absolutely no desire to have to use this however and would only use force of any kind, especially deadly force as a last resort.

Outlawing knife ownership because you can hurt someone with it is illogical.

Penn and Teller once said, "You can't stop insane people from doing insane things with insane laws. That's insane!"

I could beat someone to death with my fists, should we outlaw hands as well?

I am simply saying that the ownership, transport, ability to sell, etc. any type of tool, including knives and also defense against violence are basic human rights which the government should not have the ability to regulate.
 
Well I suppose I might be wrong, but if I were sitting in a jury and you said I had the right to kill that sob, I wouldn't like hearing it, and would probably believe you were killing for a reason other than defence.

On the other hand if you said I had no choice but to stop this SOB, and he paid for it with his life I would be much more forgiving..

It is all in the words you choose. I am no lawyer, and my time spent in Ok can be measured in hours with ease.

In NH I can use lethal force to defend myself, but i need to 'stop' the bad guy, not 'KILL' him. Which means if he must be stopped, and he dies that is his bee's wax not mine.

I agree with you, these laws are written by fools who probably would get a lethal cut if they attempted to sharpen a pencil.

Maybe we will get lucky and they will slit their own throats shaving.
 
Poor East Texan has it right.

What are the people in Washington DC planning that is so big that they don't even want folks to have their knives?
Why do they want all the control when it comes to power?

By the way, MacMac, You are absolutely right about these laws!

Look how they treated Joe Horn v. Texas!

Laws are written out with so much "grey area", and they do it on purpose.

They know when something happens, THEY will get to interpret it however they want.

Most politicians, in my opinion, just want every sharp stick gone so that we are defenseless.

They do this under the ruse that they will protect us if somthing happens.

But when something does happen, they come in, take tools and weapons away and leave (like Katrina)!

All the while, they tax us under the same ruse (we will help you) and then they squander OUR money on pet projects and BS bailouts.

I would encourage everybody to take a look at www.BornAgainAmerican.org

You don't have to sign the pledge, just look at it.

We have got to get this kind of thing back under our control.
 
Kevin, I am not to familar with texas and so Joe Horn v. Texas. If i recall he shot 2 thieves in the back with out having been endagered personally. I think I saw a vidio where he spoke on the phone to 911, and then said he wasn't going to let the thieves who offered no violence to anyone so far as I can tell to get away.

If I have this right, he didn't yell stop, or anything he put the phone down and went out and just shot these thieves in the back.

Had i been on that jury I would have convicted Joe Horn of 2nd degree murder. Texas has different law than I do, and i am basing this on NH law where items of value like tvs are not something you can use lethal force like you can in Texas.

If it had been me and I took the gun and said STOP and they ran away, I would not and could not shoot them in the back. Nothing I have is worth shooting a man in the back, when he is clearly running away, and most important no violence of any kind was offered.

Now my take on Texas and that event is that the people there have been let down by law enforcement so many times they have taken the law into their own hands, and for that alone I wouldn't convict Joe anymore.

The social order is broken, and the enforcement has failed whether or not they ment to.

Take virginia tech, which all the time other people call Vt and make me think they mean Vermont. The social system failed there too and the fat cops hid behind skinney trees, doing not one thing. This isn't anti cops, it is what I saw.

So it must be that this is common or something like this is common in Texas, and perhaps where you are since you appear to have much harsher and lesser penalty by law than even in NH.

That would be the ability to shoot someone simply stealing items of some base value, like a tv set. While I think a thief is a bad guy, I am not so sure being sentanced to death for stealing a tv set is valid. Now if that thief raised a fingernail in violence I'ld say snuff his lights for keeps and call it, I simply tried to stop him and I did, he died but thats his bee's wax.

I go to a number of on line sites, and I find a lot of talk from city boys who never so much as hunted a squirrel, and to them killing seems as easy as pulling the trigger, and I guess maybe it is, but it isn't for me.

I suspect after their first kill, things will become a bit more complicated than just pulling a trigger. I am fairly certain the first time any of them kill a man it will get real complicated whether or not the law does anything.

As I personally see it the Govt can do what ever it wants and do what ever it thinks it can do. If say, somehow they could just come and take my guns that alone would be an event I'ld like to be the fly on the wall to see, and for a number of reasons.

And lets say they get every gun I have, i would just build another one the next day.

Then there seemingly is no one posting here with a gun collection worth over 1 million dollars. If there is a total ban and therfore a turn in demanded by law just how is the Govt going to compensate these collectors? No collector with a collection of that value or more is going to accept pennies on the dollar.

That same thing goes for sharp pointy things. Banning all knives is plain foolishness. With a hunk of junk steel and 2 minutes at the grinder I can have a crude knife. Who are they fooling? Surely not me.

Guns are simple tools anyone with some metal skills can duplicate with out much trouble. Sure they might be crude, but who cares it is still a gun.

To stop me I would have to be convicted and then placed in the pen somewhere far away from most tools.

If all this is true we must be going back into time pre man as even the first man had tools and that tool was a stick, a sharp stick, and the next was a rock, a very sharp rock and some sharper than the best steels we have today. I know because i get cut on these very same sharp rocks anytime I work with them. They cut on the molecular level dividing cells rather neatly I might add. Quite painless, but very messy.

So I suppose the Govt can ban rocks too? Please excuse me, but I don't think so. I also just happen to really start fire with a bow drill, so I can't wait for the Govt to ban fire.

Maybe you are right on, as it sure does appear to me some members of the Fedral Govt are much more like early man than they are modern people. Some of them are just frightening to see! I can almost visualize that nacy with Biden squatting over a camp fire nearly nakes wearing plants.

Ahhh Stop it Kevin stop it now! :D
 
So I suppose the Govt can ban rocks too? Please excuse me, but I don't think so. I also just happen to really start fire with a bow drill, so I can't wait for the Govt to ban fire.

The government has already banned fire where I live!
This has me so mad. There has been a county-wide fire ban where I live for about a month now even though conditions have not been too bad.
I need to burn a large pile of brush so that I can get a good hay harvest this spring.

I always burn responsibly and because there are some idiots that have burned down their house because they don't know not to burn on a windy day, I have to sit and do nothing.

I suppose you should take what I say with a grain of salt, because I am just blowing off steam.

By the way, I am not condoning shooting anyone in the back, I was just referring to the gray area in the laws that had to be fought out in court in the Horn V. Texas case.
 
Oh the local Govt here gets nutso over fires too... Winter snow only sort of thing for a brush fire. They don't really mean it :D

Why if I couldn't have fire i wouldn't be re-married.... Back in 95 there was this pretty long drought and i was living in the volcano. My Bride just couldn't wait another day, and so right smack in black fly season she decided to go bare legged in a skirt and get us hitched right down by the stream.

She sure did get bit up..

Thing is I went down there and cleared the area, set up a old CCC wall tent and a 18 footer tee pee. Made a fire circle you could scrape sand from and get drinking water fit for a king, and had a metal trash can chained to a tree right next to it.

That was about 2 weeks early.

I was out in my dooryard doing a tune up on my old 84 chevy 4x4 truck I still got. All of a sudden this mad man in a new bright red truck comes slidding into my dooryard and locks his brakes, slides to a stop and gets out yelling at me to put the fire out!

I was under the hood, pretty much in the engine compartment, and I looked up trying to look as stupid as possible, and handed him a cold spark plug.

That got me a queer look, and then I said got no fires... Poof like magic he was gone. Went up the road to the end that last 1/2 mile. I coulda told him there was no fires up there either... :D

Well here he comes doing a 100 if he wasn't I'ld be lyin, and with another big cloud of dust and that set me off, so I went and called the cops.

Turned out they knew all about it and this brain was the fire warden. So I got his number, and waited 3 days, and called him. Told him I was getting hitched and we had food to cook and I didn't know how or where he thought there was any fires, but thar' was gonna be.

He appeared to object on the phone, so I told him to bad. To come see my preps.. Well he didn't like that either, so I expalined that he can't have it both ways, and so either he comes or he don't, but either way I am cooking foods..

So he decided he must, and he picked a time and I was home. I set up before he got there, and no sooner did I tell my name, shake his hand I dropped onto the living room rug, and spun up a fire with my bow drill and chucked the mess of flames into the wood stove. With out speaking, I stepped to my table and cracked a flint on steel into a tinder nest and tossed that mess of fire into the wood stove, and then said lets go see the site. All that was in under 4 minutes.. he said he had better things to do than inspect my weddin site, signed the paper and left...

6a17.jpg

Did you mean to say you ain't no sort o' watton killer? :evil:
 
Well, they really do mean it about the fire ban down here.
Getting caught means a $500.00 fine and/or jail time.
They don't enforce the jail time unless you go around setting public land on fire on purpose.

It is just another revenue collection thing.

As I type, there is a thunder storm passing over and we have had a few inches of rain in the past few days, but if I were to go outside and start a fire in the dark with the rain coming down, that would technically be illegal.

I just hope that the county commissioners meet tomorrow and lift the ban due to all the rain.

They normally discuss fire bans only every Monday.

I will call and check in the morning.

Burning during the a ban is out of the question, because I live only a few miles from a country fire station and with a fire of this size they would spot it and come to collect their money.

(Not that I would ever consider breaking the law :)) LOL
 
Last edited:
I ain't giving up guns, knives or fire no matter what those SOBS in DC say.

I won't have an open fire when it's dry, but I'll dang sure burn in a barrel (with a water hose nearby - from a well)
 
right from the Hawaiian news service:
By Ron Mizutani

Story Created: Feb 10, 2009 at 5:47 PM HST

Story Updated: Feb 10, 2009 at 6:04 PM HST

A bill aimed at prohibiting manufacturing, selling or possessing a pocket knife is drawing criticism across the country.

The public's reaction has also forced a Hawaii lawmaker to re-evalute a policy he's maintained for 22 years.

Ken Onion of Kaneohe is a master of his trade.

"I've personally designed thousands of knives," says Onion.

Onion is one of the most sought after custom knife makers in the world. His custom work commands big money.

"500 bucks and go up to 25-thousand," says Onion. "The knife is the most valid invention in mankind history -- without we would have instinct a long time ago."

It's one reason he and many are puzzled by a bill introduced by Senator Les Ihara that would make it illegal to possess, sell or manufacture a pocket knife.

"I think it's the first proposed legislation of its kind in the United States -- it shocked me," says Onion. "My wife carries a little Swiss army knife in her purse -- she can be convicted of a misdemeanor and put in jail for up to a year I mean it's insane."

Ihara has been bombed by emails.

"I think they think I support it and I've made clear in the magazines and publications that have written to me that I oppose the bill and if it ever came up to a vote which I don't believe it would I would vote against it," says Sen. Les Ihara, (D) Palolo-Kaimuki.

So why introduce it?

"In 22 years I've introduced many many bills by request," says Ihara. "By request in the capitol essentially signals that we don't agree with the content."

"Are they obligated to do that? So why would take the time to propose something like this knowing that it's not a very good idea," says Onion.

Ihara says it's been his policy to provide a voice for his constituents and did so again.

"I may for the first time in my 22 years reconsider this policy," says Ihara.

"I think he should," says Onion.

The chair of the Judicial Government and Operations Committee , Sen. Brian Taniguchi, understands Ihara but...

"No I'm not planning to hear that bill," says Taniguchi. "I think it's impractical."

The irony of it all Senator Ihara owns a pocket knife.

"It's one of the Swiss knives," says Ihara.

"I think it's a total waste of time -- we got much more important things to deal with -- I mean economy is one of them," says Onion. "How many people have been injured in car accidents in the last five years in Hawaii -- what are we going to do outlaw cars -- I don't think so."
Doc:D
 
"I think they think I support it and I've made clear in the magazines and publications that have written to me that I oppose the bill and if it ever came up to a vote which I don't believe it would I would vote against it," says Sen. Les Ihara, (D) Palolo-Kaimuki.

So why introduce it?

"In 22 years I've introduced many many bills by request," says Ihara. "By request in the capitol essentially signals that we don't agree with the content."

So to please one knucklehead he exposed himself to all this ridicule?
Could this guy live in our world and hold a real job?
 
My only hope is that this bills shock factor is great enough to make all of the dipstick politicians realize that this is BS.

They are certainly going to hear about how we don't support it!
 
While I would hate this Bill made into Law and hate as much to see Ken Onion create things from sticks and a sharks tooth, I'ld kinda like to see it pass and become LAW...

Hey I am evil ok! :evil:

Then when these high elite fancy pants paper pushin morons want something that takes doing with a blade it will make their day.

I can visualize one of their fancy smancy dinners with cost $5,000.00 at tax payer expence for a mob of these would be kings, and with nice fat juicy steaks lumped on their plates 6 inches deep and no damn way to eat it, other than picking up the hunk of meat and tearing into it just like a cave man.

That when the fatty acids kick in and clogg their arteries they must suffer being ripped and torn open with NO blade work somehow, and then suffer that sort of mess.

Who in the hell do they think they are, and who is it they think they are saving from a jack knife?

Which tool is next the hammer? Maybe the screw driver? Why not the ink pen?
 
If we are going to outlaw sharp things, why don't we start with politicians tongues?
All I know is, I can make a new knife faster than they can take them away.
I have made knives before, and I can forge them again.

I am a quiet law abiding citizen (most of the time).
But I won't turn in any guns or knifes or anything else.
They will have to come get them, and personally I think that they have better, less time consuming things to do.
 
If we get political too much we will get locked up..

I am like you Kevin, I make things for the fun of making them, that include flintlock guns, and can include brass catridge guns if and when I really want.

I must admit I find 'Transparency" very interesting, and sort of very sneaky too.

I don't dare go on my rant here though.

Poor East Texan , Yes you are correct and i forgot. They are exempt from the law for common man.. Thanks for the reminder..
 
You are welcome. I have been chastised via PM.

I'll try to be a good boy, but them "people" in DC get my back up!
 
The only ones that don't get their backs up over the fools in DC are the dead, or the folks that are dead from the neck up.

I've been involved with both the ATKI and the Kniferights organizations from before they went public. This sort of stupidity comes from politicians with nothing useful to do with their time so they come up with pointless bits of legislation to fill their empty lives with. This is the sort of foolishness that we get.

The problem is that this example is in no way unique. Goofyness like this comes up all the time. A locking blade prohibition was proposed in NY state over a decade ago. Fast action helped keep it from getting very far, but it took a lot of people working very fast to kill it.

Since most politicains have nothing better to do than create mischief, it falls to us to be vigilant for their mischief, alert others when we find it and make organized efforts to thwart it. Both the ATKI and Kniferights provide a means to do the first and second jobs and they can help with the third, but I think sites like ours help alert a wider circle of people to bring pressure to bear on the naughty children we've elected when they get out of line.
 
hso, With all due respect a site like this would help more if perhaps not as many threads were not locked so fast.

I know nothing of any anti knife laws.. I have spent my time fighting for gun laws, which you are likely familar with, other than the big they also wants black powder guns.

That is older and over looked now, but it was 'The Topic' in the mid 90's.

I can't say as I don't know why most anything leading to a political line here gets locked, and I don't understand at all why in these times this happens here. Perhaps i will never know.

With Poor East Texan mentioning that the the elite amounst us are not subject to the law they write it flipped a switch in my head, because i had forgotten that, but he is correct. I recall that now!

In life I am nobody, and I like to mess around in How To, which I am no expert in anyone thing, but do well in with many.

These current times are right up my back too. I feel like I and all of 'we' here are being made into common criminals over devices we are allowed to own by the CONS and the Bill of Rights.

I am sure there are reasons why we can't discuss these things here, but I don't yet know why.

When you found me i was just trying in my country hick way to explain some things I saw and didn't really understand. I am not a complicated man.

Steel has rules, and if you don't follow the rules steel makes the tool won't be the tool you expected.

Man and lawmakers are over complicated. These days it takes a committee to see How To change a lght bulb, which all sorts of expence comes to hand. The first part is to see if there is a need for a new light bulb, then it goes onto how to get it changed, and ends up with a debate on who should do it.

In my world that new light bulb would have already burned out and yet a 3rd light bulb would be in place.

In legal I ashed a few questions and the mod came and said that legal wasn't the place to ask about law... I don't know why, and he did say.

I didn't ask there again. I learned that lesson. What that tells me is one way or another the 1st ammendment isn't valid here, at a site where the 2nd seems to be of some importance. being just me that old long hair country hick, it causes me to wonder...alot.

I am not asking anything, nor wanting any changes.. I think we all are getting a good many changes anyway whether or not we will like them, don't you?

I am not trying to be a wise guy, nor, a thorn in your side. I still appreciate what you did for me. But still here I feel lost not being able to speak my mind, no matter how foolish it may appear.

So I am hoping this post will be taken for what it is. Just a comment.
 
I can't say as I don't know why most anything leading to a political line here gets locked, and I don't understand at all why in these times this happens here. Perhaps i will never know.

Our unfortunate experience is that once THR passed the 10,000 member point political discussions couldn't stay civil. Otherwise rational members loose their minds and forget the purpose of THR (civil discussion) and the marginally adult amongst us don't even think about trying to be logical, rational or civil. While we'd love to have political discussions, and we've tried repeatedly in the past, the undisciplined ruin it for the rational and we've just given up on being able to have them.

Discussions about specific laws still get iffy because folks drift into politics instead of staying focused on the law itself.

What did we do instead? Dump the discussion part of politics and create the Activism forum. It's a workshop where the scope is very narrowly defined and maintained with an iron hand by the biggest SOB of a Mod here. Plan, build, work. If the thread isn't a practical plan with enough detail for others to put to use the strawboss dumps the thread in the trash or leaves them out for ridicule so others don't clutter up the place with whining, hand wringing or chest beating.
 
Last edited:
Can't get out---need a knife??

How often have you heard the news talk about the victim in a car crash, trapped there because his "safety" belt won't release! Maybe you've been there yourself. I carry my "escape" knife. I've always had a fear of being trapped and unable to release my belt. That's what my "escape knife" is for!
 
hso, Fair enough.. Thank you for the kind reply.


polekitty , I live in New Hampster where there is no seat belt law. We didn't get the fedral funding either.

As a result I don't wear a belt, other than to hold up my pants. I need a belt to hold up my pants.

I don't need a belt to hold me in my car or truck though and surely don't want any no-shun of a belt to hold me on my motorbikes, but the would be world savers wanted me/us too..

I carry one and more knives everyday for farm related work, machine shop work, and work as a mechanic.

Heck of a lot easier to cut something than it is to shoot it off.

With that, I don't go any place even the shower un-armed, and if I leave this property I carry 2 guns in addition to which ever knife I might have.

Long ago, before maybe a man had to go everywhere armed, I carried a knife, but never considered the knife as a weapon.

There was a time I didn't feel any need to be armed, and my Father thought of hand guns as man killers, and he never owned one.

On the other hand when i turned 6 he gave me my first long gun in the form of a single shot bolt .22. I was allowed that gun as mine all the time and didn't need any supervision to take it out and shoot.

All I can say is this so called superior society we have come to be, isn't nearly as good as when I was a wee lad.

Right now I live in a world i can't even understand. This is something like 1+1= 7 trillion.
 
I just wonder if/WHEN the "stimulus" (PORKulus) package gets read all the way through just how bad the alien critters in DC have gotten to us.

There is no possible way the house could know all about it before they passed it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top