I'm Kinda Writing a Short Story.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
May 19, 2008
Messages
2,791
Location
Council Bluffs, Iowa
I'm sort of writing a story, and going in no major direction, but it was an idea I had and started flying with it. It's fictional, and is plotted in the future. It's about the USA being invaded by the Chinese (don't have a viable reason yet, but I'll have one when I get into writing the chapters. I'm writing as first-person, seing in the eyes of a reporter named Robert Strong, who is a war correspondent during the war. After the war, piling footage upon gruesome footage of the war, he decides he wants to track down the recognized and unrecognized war heroes to glean their side of the story, to find out what they felt like, to see if they felt the same remorse and revulsion as he.

I'm trying to put a lot of the characters' emotions into play here, and I'd like y'all to take a quick read, see if I'm on target. The story bounces back (with italicized text being a memory, or recording of Robert talking to another; standard text being Roberts' side of the story, and how he feels. Here's an excerpt of the prologue:


Eugene Stilz wasn't an average looking man. He looked messy, with his short-cropped hair, and stubbled chin and cheek area. He had a scar running down the right side of his face, about six inches long, only breaking at his eye. Stilz's complexion was rough, all the depressions high on his cheek bones looked like craters; the only thing that shone above the grim-looking exterior were his eyes. His bright blue eyes that shone with intensity, vitality unheard of in a man of his years, were set deep into his eye sockets. But I guess twenty years fighting will do that to a man.
I talked to this man, just the other day in fact. He was quite an elusive character. He avoided talking to me, over two weeks of me trying to get him to talk. This man either had a lot to hide, or didn't want to talk at all.
Let me introduce myself; my name is Robert Strong, and I am a reporter. Not just any reporter, though, and not a very good at the pen-and-paper side of reporting, so bear with me. I'm a war correspondent, and I report better with my cameras and voice recorders. I covered the last war with my many cameras, and even had to take a life. You'll hear about this later on in this story; but don't get me wrong, I did not want to kill that young man, but you'll read stories of those with remarkable courage, those who'd done remarkable things to preserve them and their own; to save their freedom, the steadfast reminder that we are a free people, and will fight for that right to remain so.
I ran into Eugene Stilz at a bar, just outside of town. McClelland, Iowa. A quiet place, and it seems the right place for this kind of man. I recognized him from TV. He was rewarded the U.S. Medal of Honor, with full honors therein, and overnight, by my knowledge, became the Hero of the United States of America. I pulled up a stool next to him.

"Can I buy you a drink?"
"Why for?" Eugene asked, gruffly. He didn't even look at me, but took another pull from his drink.
"To thank you for your service, Mister Stilz. I recognized you from the TV. Our most recent Medal of Honor recipient," I replied.
"Leave me alone," came Stilz's reply as he kicked over his stool and left the bar.


I wasn't sure what I had done wrong there. But it didn't take me long to find out. The bartender had told me that Eugene Stilz wasn't much for talking about what happened. He told me that I was wasting my time. I wasn't about to give up there, though, and as any good reporter, I didn't let up. I had seen him over the next couple weeks, seeing Eugene at the bar, on the same stool. Every time I offered to buy his next drink, he'd get up, kicking over the stool all the same and, leave.
Another night he came in, things went terribly wrong. I admit, I was pestering the man, and indeed needed to be shown humility. My methods of persuasion, gentle, like any good reporter, were impeccable. But they never prepared me for the punishmend I would receive in trying to crack the hard shell that was Eugene Stilz.
Here's what happened:

"Can I buy you a drink?" I asked him, losing count of how many times before.
"Why can't you just leave me the hell alone!? I don't want to talk to you!"
"Mister Stilz, please, I just want to buy you a--"
It happened before I knew it. He hooked his right arm wide, in a path that would take his aged, clenched fist across my chin. My vision swirling, I could hear the floor beckoning for me to come down and join it, but I stood my ground trying to get my bearings. I could hear the music stop, and I could feel the stares of everyone in the bar on me.
I managed to spit out the end of my sentence cut short, to everyones' amazement, with the word "drink."
Eugene's glare softened, I could see something in his eyes relent; something cracked. He grabbed me up and guided me over to a booth in the corner of the bar, and set me down. I felt like swooning, my head was spinning, and I noticed Eugene wasn't standing in front of me anymore.
Damn it, I told myself. I drove him away again.
A bottle was slammed down in front of me, along with an Advil, a bag of ice, and a water.
"Put that chin on ice. It'll keep 'er from swellin'," Eugene said as he sat down, shot glasses in hand.
"You've got quite an arm, Mister Stilz."
"Call me Gene. I hate that formal crap," said Stilz, ignoring the compliment. He continued on in his gravelly voice, "Now, why are you here? You've done nothin' but piss me off these last weeks, and I wanna know why. I've had all the trouble I cared for in my life, and more on top o' that! Can't a guy live his days in peace?"
I didn't answer for a minute, and sat there taking in the visage in front of me. Surely, this man in front of me deserved many things, things that never would be.
"I know, and I'm sorry, Mi-- Gene. I'm a reporter," I answered at length. "I just want to get your side of the story, for a book I am writing. One veteran to another."


I still hear popping in my bottom jaw from time to time, and that punch was one hell of a punch. I don't remember receiving worse in my time!
Here is where things started going better in my efforts to get Eugene to tell me what he'd been through, though, at the same time, I felt for the guy. I knew he didn't want to relive those miserable moments again, and I hated to do it to the guy. But my side of the story isn't so great either.

"Veteran? You're just a reporter!"
That one actually stung me.
"I am a reporter, yes. But I am a veteran as well. I fought in the same [explitive] war that you did, Stilz, and I'm no better man because of it!"
Eugenes' glare came back, boring into me like a drill to a solid rock wall. He poured himself a shot, threw it back, and poured again, filling the second glass as well. I knew what he was thinking. The images were coming to my mind, too.
"You fought too, huh?" he asked at length, in the same gravelly voice.
"I was a war correspondent. I was there with my cameras. I seen it all, Gene, and I still see it to this day. I collected tons of footage, more of it than I care for! I wish I could burn all those images I captured from my mind and the film. But the film... The film is somewhere I can't get now, for the nightly news to be played.
"I had to kill a man, Gene. I wasn't proud. That sinking feeling you get in your gut when you take the life of someone who's feeling the same as you, it's nauseating. I could tell, by the look in his eye, that he didn't want to be here, but he had his duty, and I wanted to live..."


I'm referring here to December 7th, 2019. I was following a militia detachment near Springfield, Nebraska, through fields that were to be corn-crops, but never came to fruition. A man named Eric Dawson had given me his pistol, a Glock 17, and I remember that clearly, because the lettering on the slide was filled with a dried, white liquid. He told me that I would probably need it. Little did I know, that in a short time I would.
My group came under attack around 19:42, 7:42 pm central standard time. I wasn't estranged to combat; this was probably my one-hundredth time being under fire, and my helmet-camera was rolling. I remember seeing Dawson bobbing up and down from behind the berm with his AR-15, a prized possession of his, squeezing off both aimed, and un-aimed fire at the Chinese invasion force, before ducking down to change his magazine.
We were holding off pretty good until their tanks started rolling in, with their wounded, multi-platoon charge. I had caught the whole thing on tape, well, on a Micro-SD card, but the point is moot. The militia fought back spectacularly, I was impressed. Stolen machine guns were playing their song, I heard Capparzos' sniper rifle, thundering booms adding to the amazing palate of sounds. I was, indeed, in awe.
A young man, with his rifle in hand, stepped over the berm. I took a deep long look at him, he did the same towards me. He couldn't have been much older than 17 years old, but I'm being a little conservative there. I could still see some of his boyish features on his face. The look in his eyes screamed fear, revulsion, not wanting to be there. I couldn't agree more. I was frozen in place, seemingly not able to break my trance, and it looked, to me at least, that he wasn't able to break his easily, either.
A grenade went off somewhere behind me, over-thrown by my guess, snapping us both to reality. He began to heft his rifle to his shoulder, a strange looking bull-pup rifle, one I've never seen before. Then suddenly my trance broke, and I swung the pistol up and squeezed the trigger four times, not hearing the blast, not noticing the recoil, and the boy's legs crumplled underneath him, causing him to fall forward, almost like slow motion, down to my feet at the bottom of the berm. I could see the life leaving his eyes, the pool of life leaving his body. I immediately felt the nausea coming, and swooned, one time, two times, three... I don't remember. I caught that horrible scene on my helmet-camera, too.
Off in the distance, miles away it seemed, I heard jets, and they swooped low, strafing the enemy soldiers, exploding enemy tanks with their air-to-ground missiles. The enemy retreated, thankfully.
I was congratulated on my first kill. My only kill in the war that lasted almost 10 years. I was caught in a bunch of hands clapping me on my back, celebratory cheers from my friends, whooping and hollering, portraying me as a "stone-cold killer!" That was not me, I told myself. I never--

"--wanted it to happen again."
I let loose a long, drawn out sigh as I finished my tale. I took the shot that Eugene offered, thankful for its burning sensation to my cold stomach.
"That's... That's quite a story, Mister...?"
"Strong. Robert... Strong."
"You know," Eugene began, leaning back into the booth. "I can relate to that."
I looked at him incredulously. This was a man, who, by numerous accounts, had slain upwards of 150 of the enemy. I simply could not believe he could relate to me. But he noticed my misbelieving look.
"No, really, I can relate to that. What do you portray me as? Some sort of monster who enjoys killin'? I felt bad for every soldier that I brought down, Robert. Never once did I smile while on the battlefield. I felt sick, more often than not, with what I had to do. I didn't enjoy what I was doin', I don't even
like fightin'! I'm sorry I hit you!"
There was a small crowd gathering around the table now, believing Eugene Stilz was finally about to crack, to recount his actions in the great war. I noticed some taking up chairs, not even an arm's length away from either me or Eugene, but the man across the table didn't seem to notice, and if he did, I took it that he just didn't care anymore.
"I was simply doin' what I had to do, Mister Strong," Eugene continued, leaning back into the conversation, pouring himself another shot. "I was kill or be killed out there. Where I could avoid a fight, I would. Not out of cowardice, but merely because they did not know I was there. I fought against the Chinese, Robert, but with no prejudice. They were attackin' my homeland. They were attackin' my ideals! They were to take our freedom, if it weren't for guys like us! But never once did I desire to kill them for bein' them. I killed them because they were tryin' to kill me..."
He downed his shot quickly, savoring the burn.


**Edited to fix grammatical and spelling errors. Some may have been missed.**
 
Last edited:
The Chinese are invading because......the crooks in Washington and Wall Street pledged our public lands, National Parks, and Interstate Highways as collateral on loans. China is coming to take possession after we default.
 
I was gonna say the same thing.

China isn't going to invade us, because they already own us.
They already have outstanding loans against half the money & property in America.
It would be foolish to come over here and blow up their own property!

And Mexico has already invaded us, without a shot being fired.
If you don't count the occasional Border Patrol Agent who probably got demoted or arrested for using his gun to defend himself.

rc
 
Well, Buck, I've read worse . . . I've written worse, in fact, though that's been a while.

First thing I notice is that the writing seems a little scattered overall; you seem to change topics in mid-paragraph at times. Tighten up and stay focused; follow a thought to its completion before going on to the next. A professional newsman would; they structure their presentation in the clearest way possible.

This jumped out at me:
Anywho, I ran into Eugene Stilz
"Anywho" is an example of what's called "breezy" writing, and it would be very out of place to a seasoned reporter. Closer to "valley girl," actually.

Stiltz doesn't come across too well . . . a bit too much of an exaggerated stereotype. Also, his motivation lacks credibility in suddenly changing his mind about talking with Strong; it doesn't quite ring true.

You are doing good to focus on the characters' inner thoughts and feelings; that's an excellent way to make the reader care about the characters and want to see what happens next.

Make sure to clean up the spelling and grammar at some point, but overall, it's not bad, and I am curious about the outcome. Your descriptions of action and setting are quite good.

I haven't read this yet, but it got a high recommendation from another writer:

http://www.amazon.com/Immediate-Fiction-Complete-Writing-Course/dp/031228716X

I'm thinking of buying my own copy.

Keep working at it, and good luck.
 
Thanks for the criticism. It's what turns crap to gold, in a sense, lol. Any grammatical and spelling errors that jump out to you?

I know, but I thought in the standard text, with thought changing in mid-paragraph might make it a little more... interesting? Robert Strongs' character isn't as skilled with writing as his is with his cameras. That's what I'm trying to get at with my writing. Maybe it's getting too confusing?

Thanks for the words about the action sequences. It took me a while to figure out how to write like that, and now I try to imagine myself in that situation to glean the best wording to describe it.

It'll come to it later in the story, but the reason Eugene Stilz changes his mind about talking to the reporter was because he struck Robert. When Mister Stilz explains that he was more of a pacifist, doing what he had to, to Robert, I thought that said enough about the change of mind, so I didn't say anything more about it.

Suggestions?
 
Wow, great start! When you finish it, tell me, this was great! Can't wait for the rest, a China-invasion seems fairly likely, actually. Great job!
 
I dreamed this morning that we paid our debt to China by giving them the western half of the country. The first thing that happened was our capital was moved to Beijing.

I shudder at the thought.
 
Free advice (and worth every penny!)

With all due respect, because I don't like to discourage young writers, but...

I'll let others critique your content. Even if your story is compelling, it is dragged down by your weaknesses in form.

If you are writing for anything other than your own amusement, try to study spelling, punctuation, grammar and syntax. Learn, e.g., not to say "palate" when you mean "palette" (not to be confused with "pallet").

Do that, or be prepared to have your manuscript summarily rejected. Alternatively, be prepared to hire a re-write specialist, because a re-write encompasses the extensive proofreading and copy-editing you require.

The very best thing one can do in preparation for being a writer is to read. I'm sorry, but I get the feeling that you haven't really done a lot of reading.
 
Kinda writing? You're either writing it or you aren't :D

Anyhow, I've written a novel (never gotten around to being published; I'm lazy like that), but I'm not good with first person. Eugene Stiltz struck me as maybe an exaggerated Vietnam veteran stereotype. I can't speak too much, but what I remember from speaking with a WW2 vet maybe a decade or so back was that he wasn't fighting so much for American ideals as it was in order to protect something important to him like his town, his family, and the other men he was fighting with.

Not all veterans handle killing people in the same way. Some people can barely make themselves do it. Others find that it gets easier. Others can't do it at all. Others naturally can. Watch Band of Brothers to see how a diverse set of personalities handles war. Of the vets who I've spoken to who have killed in combat, both of them were teachers. One of them was my freshman world history teacher. The other was my senior economics teacher. The former was definitely gruffer and may have had PTSD symptoms going on. He lost about 1/3 of his hearing to a grenade in Desert Storm. He probably killed people, but I don't know how he feels about it. The latter was much more glib and served in honestly, I'm not exactly sure. According to him, it was classified Ranger stuff. I think he might have even been in Afghanistan or maybe Iraq at the beginning. He admitted to having killed people in combat and does not in any way regret it. He summed it up as feeling recoil and seeing someone fall. BTW, I never did ask them because I felt it would have been rude to do so but my classmates weren't always so respectful.

I personally would change how Robert got the info about the war story from Eugene. U'd find it more credible if he had earned his trust first before getting him to open up. I did overall like the story.
 
Last edited:
Ringolevio:

I read more than you suspect. Why else would I have vocabulary that isn't ebonics, like so much more of my generation these days? I've read The Hobbit, LOTR Fellowship of the Ring, Two Towers, Return of the King, Silmarillion; Harry Potters 1-7; Dan Browns Digital Fortress, Angels and Demons, The DaVinci code; Darren Shan's Demonata: Bec, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court by Mark Twain; The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis; John Gregory Betancourt's Herculese series, Tom Clancy's Red Storm Rising, End War, Shadow Warrios, Rainbow Six; Raymond E. Fiests The Magician; Earthseed by Pamela Sargent and so far the Legend of Drizzt of the Forgotten Realms books 1-7, working on book 8...

Plus more in high school.

I may not be a grammatical expert, but I know how to read.

Mortablunt:
Glad you liked it over-all. Since it's only the prologue written now, plus a few paragraphs into chapter one, it'll be easier to fix. But I may just keep it the way it is, going deeper in depth later on as to why Eugene Stilz opened up.

A prologue is designed to hook, anyway, so.
 
Last edited:
Readin' and writin'

LJ-MosinFreak-Buck:
Ringolevio:

I read more than you suspect. Why else would I have vocabulary that isn't ebonics, like so much more of my generation these days? I've read The Hobbit, LOTR Fellowship of the Ring, Two Towers, Return of the King, Silmarillion; Harry Potters 1-7; Dan Browns Digital Fortress, Angels and Demons, The DaVinci code; Darren Shan's Demonata: Bec, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court by Mark Twain; The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis; John Gregory Betancourt's Herculese series, Tom Clancy's Red Storm Rising, End War, Shadow Warrios, Rainbow Six; Raymond E. Fiests The Magician; Earthseed by Pamela Sargent and so far the Legend of Drizzt of the Forgotten Realms books 1-7, working on book 8...

Plus more in high school.

I may not be a grammatical expert, but I know how to read.

Uh, this is a reading list you're bragging about?
Well, having never read any of 'em aside from Twain and Clancy, I have no idea if any of those writers have any better command of English than you do.

Have you really only read one of Mark Twain's works?

I suppose that, in keeping with the current values of our "educational system", you should be highly praised (or perhaps even given a major award!) for having a vocabulary that exceeds the 50 words of Ebonics. But there's a lot more to being a writer, like knowing whether what you're attempting is a short story or a novel.

Did your school curriculum include reading anything by Edgar Allan Poe?

'Wanna learn about short stories? Besides Poe, you might enjoy reading Jack London (my favorite, and not just 'cause he mentions guns).

But Hey, I wish you luck.

And remember what Hemingway said (in his characteristic short, pithy fashion) after reading Jack Kerouac's "On the Road": "That's not writing. That's typing."

=====================

I see you're also getting advice from "Mortablunt"; now there's a man who really knows what he's talking about...!!
 
Last edited:
What's your beef, Ringo? You seem to have a problem with me. All I did was tell you I knew how to read. You're practically attacking me, here, guy. I should be cursing and swearing at you... But I'm not.

I've probably read more, but I don't recall. I read all the time in highschool, forgetting many of the titles that I read. I've read Edgar Allan Poe as well. Those listed above are all the books that I own, and they've all been read more than once.

If you don't like what I have to say, or what I write, don't make yourself heard in the post. Thanks.
 
You know, this isn't the first time I've been attacked on an open forum. I wonder why that is? There's always that one person who decides to take it upon himself to attack everything I have to say. Happened over on Surplus Rifle Forum for the post I had about my stock ideas.
 
Mosin, don't let Ringo get you down. He was close to being very helpful until the backhanded insults started flying.

Keep your head up and your pen on the paper, I think that it is coming along quite well.

(And btw, I liked the stock ideas too ;))
 
You know, this isn't the first time I've been attacked on an open forum. I wonder why that is? There's always that one person who decides to take it upon himself to attack everything I have to say. Happened over on Surplus Rifle Forum for the post I had about my stock ideas.
Don't feel bad, it's not just you. There are some people out there that have no concept of how to treat people.

That said, your grammar, punctuation and word usage need work. Your spelling isn't as bad as some, but it could use some work.

As to content, I agree that the reporter seems contrived and the war vet seems like a caricature to me (overly exaggerated), and your "flow" doesn't go in the same direction at times.

Basically, in a nutshell, what heron said.
 
I don't know what stock ideas you've had, but I'd like to see you develop your writing idea out to at least a 50 page novella or anthology.
 
Thanks guys, and yes, until Ringo's post went negative, I was going to take his advice.

Thanks, guys. I'll keep writing on it and post for those who do like the read.

AllAroundHunter, thanks for the kind words, from stocks to story, lol.
 
OP, are you looking for feedback or just posting for the sake of posting? If you're serious about writing, you can't have a thin skin, especially on an Internet forum. If and when you start sending in your manuscript for publishing, you will be rejected, many times over. It's just the nature of the business.

I do commend your attempt at writing. It's something rarely seen in this Internet generation, what with so many young folks taking shortcuts with texting and chat and not knowing how to write a complete paragraph anymore.

To put it mildly, your writing needs some polishing. To be brutally honest, it comes across like watching a B movie. The reading list you posted (or rather the books you own) caters more to the juvenile crowd. I read most of the books on your list by the way, when I was 10 to 12 years old, obviously with the exception of the Harry Potter series and similar contemporary works. While these books are entertaining and some of which are considered classics in their own right, I don't think Tolkien or JK Rowling are particularly laudable for their writing skill. Tolkien is more of a linguist and it comes across in his dry, purposely archaic style that seems to transcend any particular time period. Rowling is very imaginative but her style is again nothing special.

You will need a lot more serious reading and you have to open up your horizon to include non-fiction, non-fantasy works of literature. Don't stop writing though.
 
I've read a lot of non-fiction as well, though more for educational purposes than for recreation. I'm not posting just to post, I would like some feed back, sure. I accepted everyone elses fine, both positive and negative. But attacking me was a little out of line. Telling me, I don't know how to read, when I could read at a college level when I was in the primary school, is a little harsh. While I may not be as grammatical proficient as most, I do pride myself with having a larger vocabulary than others my age. I got a 67 for an ASVAB score, so I don't think comments like Ringolevio's hold any merit, but againt, while his criticism was there, his rude comments were, too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top