Is there any room for serious improvement in the world of shotguns?

Status
Not open for further replies.
At three buck's a shot, people won't be shooting them that often!:eek:

And the upper receiver is $1950.00, don't think too many people will be running to buy one.
 
Last edited:
No but I mean, it's not a shotgun shell as much as it is a .72 caliber Glaser Safety Slug?

Is that it?
 
At three buck's a shot, people won't be shooting them that often!

Wow, at three greenbacks a round, plus a proprietary design, they won't be moving fast.

No but I mean, it's not a shotgun shell as much as it is a .72 caliber Glaser Safety Slug?

It apparently opens up. Info here. No idea how it patterns though.
 
At three buck's a shot, people won't be shooting them that often!
I know I won't be when I can get Federal Flite control OO buck or Winchester segmented slugs for under a buck a round.
 
I think hulls made out of improved resins for longer reloading life would be great.
 
The only group seeking radically new designs are the tactical set, and most of that centers around increased magazine capacity and better feeding. Makes sense. I don't think there is a large enough market to make it happen economically unless the military is willing to pay for it, and right now they have a LOT bigger issues to face. Different design shotshells won't work in the millions of existing guns, which aren't going anywhere, and reloading equipment is non existent.
Looks like the target and hunting set wants better and/or cheaper shells - nothing wrong with the current designs of shells or guns really.
 
Greyling, I still have about 100 boxes of activ. 12-16-20ga. Only ones worth a flip are the 16ga that are called hornet swarm or something wierd involving a stinging insect...the rest are steel shot my buddies buy off of me 4-6 boxes at a time to kill swimming cripples during duck/goose season. The though process was good, but I had had plenty try to stick in several guns and rip the lip off. Have to shove a dowel rod down it to clear the hull. Have had lots of squibs too. Since I bought a pallet of these though at $1/box and a pallet of metallic rifle/handgun for a sum of 2 grand a few years back (2008?) I'm not complaining. Luckily I have a pile of T-shot left which I was tearing down and loading into high brass and using for coyote, but I no longer do that so they sit.
 
Virginian kinda made the point I had when I started this thread. The tactical guys want capacity, and to do it you either have to box-feed or shorten the shell. I have had a couple threads closed over the latter so I won't go further than to say that 12 ga short shells are the answer to that problem in current pumps. It would be very nice if the same luxury were afforded to other platforms and gauges. There have been some neat ideas come up though, which makes me wonder why the 45gap or other large, long rimless rounds haven't been modified to fit some of these needs. Even an AR could take a shotgun barrel if the ammo were available in the form of a rimless 410, but they would be rather weak. Very interesting concept though, even more interesting is why Saiga didn't do something like this and open source the ammo to help sell their guns. I'm sure they considered it though. And no I'm not talking about thing like 45acp snake shot but a similar round taken out to 2.5ish inches with a shotwad and all, just smaller caliber and AR capable. Like the old 9mm shotgun, but rimless and more powerful.
 
Definitely not a "serious improvement" but how about a pump gun that could be quickly field stripped without the need to remove the barrel first? It seems every one I've handled needs the barrel pulled and then most of the guts removed from the front of the receiver. A minor improvement, but one that may serve to inconvenience the user a little less.

Also, would like to see a single shot break open, that could have the barrel removed via some kind of quick detach lever or something rather than having to first remove the hand guard.
Would be a bit quicker to snap a broken down single shot together while camping or on the trail if I don't have to pull and then replace the hand guard from the barrel every time I break down the gun.
 
Was thinking about shells, would be nice if the company's went backward and made a 2 1/2 or 2 inch shell.

I know a few co's do make them, but also a pump or auto-loader that was made wirh a shorter frame just for short shells. Shorter pump racking and a faster cycle time on the auto's.
The HD guy's would love them, since greater magazine capacity.
 
I disagree. I got down to 1.8 inches in a 20ga before feeding became an issue. At 1.7 they were trying to flip up. This was in a pardner pump which is an 870 copycat so I would think most 870s should be very similar. I haven't loaded any yet to know how ejection is. So no not all would have to be modified, but a dedicated short stroke gun would be very nice for the HD guys. Give it a semi-bullpup action with about a 24 inch barrel and an AR type stock... Tacticool for sure. Would be best with a afg2 on the forend and glock type trigger safety so one is not fumbling for a safety at 3am when the window breaks and you hear footsteps in the hallway. Say it's a 2" on a full length tubed 24" you have room for 11 under (leave room for spring and follower) and one in. That could be mighty useful.
 
Last edited:
What I'm saying is short shells and a gun to go with them.

Not todays 3 1/2 inch cannons that need wheels on them to carry!

A nice shorter pump or autoloader, just think a receiver that is a 1/2 to 3/4 inch shorter.
 
Yes, now your talking. I'm still thinking hard on this ar upper. There's gotta be a market for say a 50beowulf smooth bore shotgun or at least something similar.
 
There are all sorts of interesting things in the shotgun world. Most are imported due to a lack of interest in making new designs in this country, box magazines have come a long way.

There are:
Saiga-12
Vepr-12
Fury I & II
MKA 1919
Black aces Pro series.

All can be the 'do anything shotgun' if setup correctly.

Magazine designs are not that complicated, however double stacks are almost impossible with a soft bodied shell.

Here is a basic 8 round stick magazine for a saiga-12. Simple anti tip follower and rim lock prevention built in with a handful of stamped shapes. Why I'm stuck making magazines for import shotguns is still beyond me.
CIMG1414__62617.1389375706.1280.1280.jpg
 
One gun with a lot of modularity.

Semi auto, 3" chamber.
Bottom ejecting.
Gas system recoiling, like just about any modern semi auto.
Quick change stock system for adjusting length of pull, adding pistol grips, or installing bull pup furniture. Should appeal to those who want burled walnut to those who want black plastic with rails and flashlights and lazerbeamz.
Quick change barrels from 18"- 30+".
Adjustable bolt face/ extractor for the ability to change from 12-16-20 gauge.
Hydraulic buffering recoil reduction.
Adaptable magazine feed system to allow seamless transition from tube fed to detachable box mag fed, available for multiple gauges.
Complete ambidextrous controls.
And either a non-reciprocating bolt handle or a reversible bolt handle that can be swapped left or right, depending on the shooter.

A second model with 3.5" chamber and a 10 gauge option.

Build that, and slap a price tag of less than $1000 (all barrels and accessories not included) and I would be a happy camper.
 
Last edited:
I know a lot more about shotguns than I do rifles but somehow never frequent this section of THR. Guess I should start. I've been a clays shooter for 40 years and a bird hunter longer than that. I've had at least a dozen shotguns and still have way too many.

To get back to the OP, I really think things stopped evolving with the auto loader, probably in the 50's. Most of the really good improvements came along before WW2. With all the new auto loaders on the market I still prefer O/U's and SXS's. Pumps have their place also and I still have an 870 that I purchased new in 1970.

I've had British game guns and those are the very pinnacle for upland shotgun development. You haven't lived until you have used a 6.5 pound sxs that is perfectly balanced. Those were available about 100 years ago.

As hunting opportunities diminish and non-tox shot prices increase there will be fewer shotguns sold. About the only thing keeping them around now are the games and even that has some folks dropping out because of the cost. I just did a quick calculation and it costs me about $15 to shoot a round of trap, $10 if I load my own ammo. I can shoot my pistol for a lot less.
 
You mean like the old ACTIV shells?

I loved those things, whined when I couldn't get 'em anymore. The hulls lasted and lasted in the salt marsh conditions, never a speck of rust being plastic and all. They had a metal rim encased in plastic, worked REALLY well, but then, i didn't have an auto back then. I don't see why they wouldn't work in an auto as well as my pumps, though.

As for box magazines, I'm a hunter, got no use for more'n 3 rounds of firepower since any more is to break the law on the birds I hunt. I don't really worry much about tacticool guns. I'm not sure how big the market is for SA type box fed guns, either, to go changing all shot shell design from what works, already, but I, personally, would welcome the comeback of the Activ, especially if it were available in fasteel loads. I shot a Saiga (single stack, of course) a while back. While it was weird and if I had one, it'd be a 12 gauge rifle for me (hogs at night are my thoughts), it functioned just fine with conventional ammo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top