More Glock 36 recoil spring problems? Or is this normal??

Status
Not open for further replies.

gbelleh

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2002
Messages
1,747
Location
Kansas
I got my replacement recoil spring assembly from Glock today. I installed it, pulled the slide back and it seems that the coils of the spring are rubbing against the metal tube of the guide rod. This causes a very rough slide motion and a rough grating noise when the slide is racked. Is this something that needs to break in and will go away?

I've decided to get a Wolff steel recoil spring assembly anyway, and I would be interested in your comments regarding the stronger springs.

Wolff offers 15, 17 (standard), 19, 21 and 23 lb. spring sets for the Glock 36.

What are the advantages, disadvantages in these stronger springs? How might they affect reliability?

I don't plan on shooting +p or any extra powerful ammo through it. I'm mainly interested in reliability.

Any suggestions? Comments?
 
I must've missed your first post which explained why you needed a new recoil spring assembly from Glock ...

Don't take this as gospel, and you should also ask this question over on the Glock Talk forum, as there are a lot of G36 owners over there ... However ...

What you MAY be feeling during manual slide retraction is the rubbing of the recoil spring on the bottom of the barrel. The next time you remove the slide take a look at the bottom of the barrel, along the "center" of it, lengthwise. If you see any rub marks, that's more than likely what you're hearing and feeling. This is considered normal by most Glock owners, and has been reported by many of the large caliber Glock owners and shooters over on GT. As long as it isn't out of the ordinary, and doesn't actually interfere with the normal operation of the pistol, you're probably just going to have to ignore it. Lubricating the entire external circumference of the barrel is always a good idea ... especially the bottom of the barrel, which might help lessen this noise. This issue has been raised by some G21 owners over on the GT forum ...

Also, it's not uncommon for the manual operation of a pistol's slide to feel differently ... less "smooth" ... than it actually operates during shooting. You ought to be able to manipulate it by hand, though, and if you can't the pistol should be checked out by a Glock armorer or factory technician.

Going to a heavier recoil assembly may create the potential for "limp-wristing" issues in a polymer framed pistol, depending on the shooter, as well as affect the ejection characteristics of your pistol. While I've installed heavier recoil springs in some pistols, I've done it for specific reasons. I've also installed heavier magazine springs to compensate for the faster slide velocity during counter recoil caused by the heavier recoil springs, as well, so the velocity of the slide doesn't "over-come" the strength of the magazine springs.

A compact & subcompact pistol, with a short recoil cycle, can often be more sensitive to slide mass & slide velocity issues, which are sometimes complicated by a shooter's grip, and increasing the recoil spring strength can sometimes create a new problem where one didn't exist previously ...

Unless you have a reason to believe the pistol is unsafe to fire ... in which case it should examined by an armorer or the factory technicians ... if it works when you shoot it normally, I'd leave it alone and enjoy it.

The great folks at Wolff Company can certainly discuss this issue with you, as well ...

Also, keep in mind that shooting "under powered" ammunition has caused malfunctions in more pistols than just Glocks ... Shoot good QUALITY ammunition in your G36 ... and while I personally don't favor +P ammunition in short barreled pistols due to recoil control/recovery, you can get a lot of input about using +P in G36's from a lot of the owners, as well as asking the factory about using +P ...
 
Thanks,

By the way, my original problem is posted here:
http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=7041

I am in the process of researching this question in other forums, but THR (and formerly TFL) is my favorite place to ask.

I was planning on going with the 17 lb. spring from Wolff.

I just disassembled the Glock and I don't see unusual wear on the barrel. While slowly pulling the slide back, I can see the outer tube of the recoil spring assembly moving in small jerky motions as the spring catches on it. I can also clearly see wear marks on the outer tube from the spring contacting it. It does seem to be getting a little less severe the more I rack the slide. This only happens during the last inch of backward motion of the slide.
 
Have you had any problems w/ function? Will it still shoot properly? I wouldn't worry about it unless you start havig reliability issues. I doubt Glock would let it go, especially after seeing it as a warranty return. Start enjoying it!
 
10-Ring,
Glock just sent me a replacement part, I didn't send the whole gun in. I also haven't shot it yet. I did have a stovepipe during the 88 rounds that the gun fired before it broke, but I figured it was due to a problem with the recoil assembly that was about to break.

I hope to take it to the range this weekend.
 
After shooting I find that the underside of the barrel in several of my Glocks is coated with silvery flecks where the recoil spring rubbed against it. This appears to be normal and to do no harm. However, I put a light coating of grease in the area just to reduce the friction between these parts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top