newbie question: is XD .45 acp same or better than glock?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Call or email Springfield to confirm, but I pretty sure that all the XD45's in .45ACP have the new coating.

I'm not sure about the older .45GAP models, but who cares about those? They're DOA.
 
re: XD .45 acp same or better than glock ?

I have shot both the XD-45 and the Glock 21.

The range I shoot at rents both of these. When I rented them, neither had been cleaned. They were absolutely filthy !

The XD kept jamming on me every 3rd or 4th round.

The Glock never hiccupped once.

I would have to vote for the Glock.

-HCrab
 
I have Glocks and my wife has XD's. I like both. After she bought her two tone tactical .45 she said she might sell her 4 inch. I have been looking at a bigger .45 to CCW. I am currently carrying a Glock 36 or 19. I am thinking I might use her 4 inch XD .45. The only concern is the length of the grip. Before I go out and buy a expensive holster does anyone else carry the XD45 and what do you recommend for a good holster for a old fat man... :D I use inside or outside holsters depending on attire and heat.
 
I carry my XD45ACP Service Model (4") daily. I really like the pistol in my CompTac C-T.A.C. IWB (the best, IMO), a Don Hume Open Top or a DeSantis Speed Scabbard. Oh, yeah...I'm an old, fat guy, too! :D
 
I have shot both the XD-45 and the Glock 21.

The range I shoot at rents both of these. When I rented them, neither had been cleaned. They were absolutely filthy !

The XD kept jamming on me every 3rd or 4th round.

The Glock never hiccupped once.

I would have to vote for the Glock.

-HCrab
Click to expand...

HCrab, I was wondering what kind of ammo you were shooting through the rental XD?

I absolutely love my XD, but the one thing I ran into when I first bought it, was that I thought I could just go out blasting with my light target LSWC reloads that I used for my 1911's . . . . I had exactly the same problem you describe. Increasing the speed and COL seems to have cured the problem but I'm still playing to be 100% sure. I don't find that as a fault because the XD is setup to handle "duty" ammo and not "bullseye" ammo that is as light as I can shoot and have it reliabily cycle my kimber. :)

Just my .02

Regards,
Dave
 
I apologise!

I admit, that after 3 pages i do not read all responses. So if this has been posted already i am sorry.

Right now, the glock has alot going for it in the acccessories dept, if that's your thing:

In my dreams, i want the XD45 probably the 4" (but 5" will do) with its 13+1 capacity and integral rail to add-on the following:
1. tritium sights (looks like the going favorites are the TRUGLO Tritium/Fiber Optic sights, right?- although i have used meprolight at other times and liked them just as well, so i am sure they are all fine)
***Available for both XD and Glocks***
and,
2. light/laser combo: ideally, these would be separate with the Crimson trace laserGrip and an undermounted light on the rail. But with that bevertail-type safety I wonder if a CT grip can be done?)
***No grips for the XD45, but i believe there is an integral guide-rod type- which I dont like, and of course the rail mounted combos are around. Crimson Trace makes lasergrips for the Glock, and newer glocks have a rail for lights or whatnot. Even the older glocks can be fitted with one of those add-on rails from Brownells***
and,
3. a threaded barrel for the Evolution 45 suppressor: well, that seems a tall order. I have found questions but no answers as to wether or not the 5" barrel will fit in the 4" AND allow reliable cycling. That would be the easy fix. Otherwise, I wait for an aftermarket threaded barrel. Fortunately, the Evolution has the built in Inertia-device for cycling.
***Again, the G-17 has threaded barrels available, and of course 9mm Suppressors abound***

Having 13+1 rds of 45ACP is approximately equivalent to 17rds of 9mm for the Glock-17, in my guesstimation and shooting style/skill.

In my own particular case, I am trying to build up a 'house gun' that can be used by the untrained members of the home- hence the laser etc, and indoors- hence the suppressor.

That's really the only thing holding me back from the XD45 at this time.

C-
 
Glock Vs Springfield Armory XD-45 ACP

Glock Vs Springfield Armory XD-45 ACP

Here is the scoop.. I own both a Gock model 22 40 CAL and Springfield Armory XD-45 ACP. I have shot both guns considerably and can honestly say that the XD is more accurate, easier to shoot, safer to handle and just a all around beter gun. I know ill get back some arguments, but the difference in my shooting scores was 10-12% better.

The safety features in the gun are outstanding.

Sorry Glock...
 
I'm a little later to the polymer pistol party than a lot of you guys, I'm sure(bought a Kahr PM9 a couple of years ago, Beretta PX4 9mm last year (18 rounds of 9mm is nice!), and most recently Glock 29 - 10mm compact.). I'm not a huge Glock fan, but I absolutely LOVE my 10mm Glock 29. Based on popularity, I'm most likely going to add an XD-45 in 4" soon as well.

Eleven rounds of 10mm in the 29 is a great thing. Fourteen rounds of .45 acp in a stone reliable, comfortable handling pistol is pretty dang nice too! Glock 29 AND XD-45.... can't go wrong with that combo! When you have a hard time deciding between two desireable options, get them both if you can!
 
I prefer the balance of the service model XD-45 over the tactical.

Trigger work, feed ramp & chamber by Canyon Creek Custom
Sights by Dawson Precision

xd45acp0051a6hd.jpg
 
I would love to see Glock come out with a Gen IV frame that has interchangeable backstraps. I have no problems with the current Gen III frame, which fits my hand almost like it was made for it. My Glock 20 points like an extension of my body and is very natural, and even the finger grooves seem to agree with my hands. I seem to be in the minority here. I think getting rid of the finger grooves and adding interchangeable backstraps would be a relatively inexpensive way for Glock to gain back some of their market.

The Glock has other advantages:

It is simpler--you could train a monkey to detail strip one. It is like playing with Legos. Any parts breakage or upgrading can be done by the user, usually for pretty cheap.

It is simpler (did I mention that?)--it doesn't have a grip safety, for example, which the record shows John Moses Browning was opposed to including on even the 1911. I simply don't feel it is necessary or even advantagous.

Bore axis--the Glock sits lower in your hand, which provides it with less torque, or leverage. The result is less muzzle flip.

Trigger--easy enough to fix if you don't agree with the stock trigger, and as mentioned, the Glock trigger has a faster reset. The result when combined with the above is that the Glock is easier to shoot in rapid, controlled strings. Granted the differences may be minor enough that most of us couldn't appreciate them without a lot of practice, but the differences are there.

Plus the XD isn't available in 10mm. Anthing but the .45s currently isn't going to have near the metal treatment/finish of the Glocks. A Glock 22 will be more corrosion resistant than even a stainless XD 40. XDs just don't float my boat right now. My dad and bro each want a .45. But even acknowledging the design is sound, I'll pass in favor of my Glocks.
 
I've used the Glock 21 a fair amount, and only fondled the XD 45. With that disclaimer, I will state my preference for the XD. The grip feels far better, and the balance is superior. I'd prefer it without the grip safety but even with it, the XD is my personal favorite of the two. And I actually like the 21.
 
XD hands down.

1. The XD is cheaper by at least $50.
2. The XD comes with more accessories. (Mag loader, holster, mag pouch, 2 hi cap mags)
3. The XD has a better grip angle and slimmer grip.
4. The XD has a better trigger pull.
5. The XD has a grip safety.
6. The XD is every bit as reliable.
7. The XD's finish has been improved, if you're still worried you can get a stainless slide.

I shot a G19 and XD Service back to back and walked out with a XD9 SC.
 
I'm a little later to the polymer pistol party than a lot of you guys, I'm sure(bought a Kahr PM9 a couple of years ago, Beretta PX4 9mm last year (18 rounds of 9mm is nice!), and most recently Glock 29 - 10mm compact.). I'm not a huge Glock fan, but I absolutely LOVE my 10mm Glock 29. Based on popularity, I'm most likely going to add an XD-45 in 4" soon as well.

Eleven rounds of 10mm in the 29 is a great thing. Fourteen rounds of .45 acp in a stone reliable, comfortable handling pistol is pretty dang nice too! Glock 29 AND XD-45.... can't go wrong with that combo! When you have a hard time deciding between two desireable options, get them both if you can!
Click to expand...


Hello, DHart~

That is exactly what I did! :)

3newguns_3web.jpg

They are both excellent sidearms with features that make either one a superb pistol.
 
all i know is i been wanting one for a long time went down to the gun store last week they were sold out then i went to 4 other gun stores turns out i have to wait two months for one eta so cal
 
rented a coupe gocks and xd45acp and after playing with them i instantly bought the xd 3 weeks ago....it is an accurate gun and love it but my S&w 686+ is still my favorite handgun (its my first gun and the one im most accurate with at this time) 1st gun is like 1st car.
 
Glock or XD? Are you sure you want a .45 over a 9mm? Or a plasic pistol over a 1911? Is it just me or have I see this before? Well I had to give you a little grief over starting this neverending thread right? I own a Glock, but I would also love an XD. They are both fine guns and either would serve you wonderfully. One is not definatively better than another, simply a difference of opinion. And, as they say, opinions are like.....
 
I am in no way trying to be rude or disrespectful but I must reply to a recent post.

XD hands down.
1. The XD is cheaper by at least $50.
2. The XD comes with more accessories. (Mag loader, holster, mag pouch, 2 hi cap mags)
3. The XD has a better grip angle and slimmer grip.
4. The XD has a better trigger pull.
5. The XD has a grip safety.
6. The XD is every bit as reliable.
7. The XD's finish has been improved, if you're still worried you can get a stainless slide.

Well, allow a few counterpoints if I may.
1. The XD is cheaper by $50- True, but in my opinion 50 dollars should not be the sole factor in deciding between weapons. More times than not, one will go with the gun they prefer. Although saving 50 dollars is never a bad thing.
2. The XD comes with more accesories- Again true, but all of the cheap accesories in the world should not be a deciding factor. Sure they are nice, but I would rather have a gun I like than one I don't that came with a lot of stuff.
3 & 4. Better grip angle and trigger pull. These are opinions. Not facts. This is not to say that one shouldn't have this opinion, just that they are OPINIONS and should not be stated as fact.
5. Grip safety- Again no disrespect meant, but so what? While the grip safety may be better/prefered for some, others don't care at all. As a glock owner, I do not feel I need a grip safety. Again, just my opinion.
6. Reliabiliy is equal- Probably.

Well folk, sorry for the length, just wanted to make the point that one is not "hands down" better than another. As a Glock owner, I couldn't be happier. I am sure that I would also love an XD. In the end, I must encourage you to try both and choose the one that YOU like.
 
I've never had any difficulty in getting used to operating a wide variety of different types of handguns.

I was raised with the BHP, CZ and 1911 platforms but I have no problem in going plastic - if it's reliable (my 1st criterion) and reasonably accurate (my 2nd), I'll carry it.
 
XD vs Glock vs 1911

Viewing old posts thought I'd toss in my $0.02

I have an XD45 tactical that I use for IPSC competition L-10. Love it for ergonomics, and no safety to deal with on the draw. The felt recoil is less than a 1911 when the mag is full, more when down to the last couple shots. That means I pick my hard targets to be shot just after a mag change.

I have a couple of Glocks, 17L and a 20C, Nice but not quite as good a fit in my hand. Lots of accessories and gear for glocks. Accuracy of a Glock is questionable. Not bad but I suspect larger groups than XD

I have a couple of 1911 and clones, Nothing will ever replace it. The trigger and accuracy of a 1911 is second to none in my opinion. I shoot these in conventional pistol competition (Bullseye)

Where speed is involved, "I" flinch if using a 1911 in IPSC events when "I" try to go fast. That may be something I could train out of however, using the XD or Glock I can shoot faster. The "safe action" trigger is not like the crisp snap of a 1911 trigger. More like pumping a spray bottle. It works for ME.

If reloading for the XD, I could not get it to feed SWC. Only RN or TC. The rim of the extracted case would smack into the round in top the mag. Mush it over a bit and cause feeding/seating problems.
 
Sold XD9 got a G19

This a little of the .45 topic but still XD vs Glock.

I had an XD9 that I sold and got a G19. I didn't like the stiff slide pull on the XD. It takes really strong hands to pull. Also, the trigger reset is too long on the XD and the G19 has a sweet trigger. The XD9 had a few too many failures in the first hundred rounds. I don't know but these failures may have worked their way out with a break in period.

Simonz
 
xd 45 jamming

i have had alot of pistols in the 20 years of shooting...my xd 45 jams often, this pistol has jammed more than any pistol i have ever had....:cuss:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

S
  • Locked
Which is better, Glock or Springfield XD??
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
131
Views
15K
mbruce
M
G
  • Locked
XD Melonite vs. Glock Tenifer.
2 3
Replies
73
Views
11K
madmike
M
4
  • Locked
Xd-40 Vs. Glock 22
Replies
6
Views
1K
emann
E
A
  • Locked
Gosh, I hate to ask the question (Glock vs XD)
2 3
Replies
71
Views
3K
varoadking
V
S
  • Locked
Glock or XD
2 3
Replies
67
Views
2K
shooter1
shooter1
Back
Top