Rate my video!

Status
Not open for further replies.

MachIVshooter

Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2005
Messages
17,934
Location
Elbert County, CO
As many of you know, I like to scratch build guns, which means I'm also curious about what others have done. I see many other quality and professional level builds on some of the dedicated boards, but then there's Youtube :eek: The number of home builds that are cobbled together, sketchy and downright dangerous is astonishing. In light of that, I decided to make a short talking video about home building guns, and how to do it properly and safely, in hopes that my title wording will leave it in the playlists or suggested links of the aforementioned homemade gun videos.

I had no notes or script, no rehearsal, and I've never done such a monologue before, so I would like this community's feedback on that video!

 
i tried but the wife kept interrupting. What I saw looked good, very informal but informative. Good tone, good advice, and not boring.
 
Last edited:
Pretty decent and straightforward video. Adequate lighting and off-the-cuff narrative were fairly well done, along with demonstrations and build information about the various scratch built firearms. Very informative and entertaining. Thank you for not using any kind of musical accompaniment to "enhance" your video production.
 
From about 1:30 to about 10:00 the camera essentially shows the same scene. You talk about a lot of stuff in those 8 1/2 minutes. Your presentation will be more effective if you can show specific examples of the things you are talking about as you talk about them. Scene changes promote interest.
 
Thanks, guys! I'm generally pretty well spoken in ordinary dialogue, but trying to do a lengthy sermon off the top leaves me battling both my constant issue with mind going 100 directions at once, and trying to select the most appropriate wording as I'm saying it, sometimes resulting in portmanteaus of synonyms :eek:.

Obviously there is a lot more to be said about the subject, but in this age of sound bites, I think that >10 minutes carrying on about what is a fairly dry subject to many is going to lose all but the most dedicated in the audience. I'll make more in-depth videos later for people who are more interested in the technical minutiae of gun building, machining and metallurgy. This one was really just meant to deter folks from mimicking Royal Nonesuch and other Youtubers who are building and showing off dangerous improvised guns with little to no understanding of the perils.

Bonus points for correct use of "myriad."

Hahaha. Annoying how often folks put "a" before and "of" after, isn't it? Really? A 10,000 of?
 
Your presentation will be more effective if you can show specific examples of the things you are talking about as you talk about them. Scene changes promote interest.

I know. I'll do more of that with future videos. But I'm new at this, and it is also difficult to demonstrate effectively what I'm talking about. You can't really "see" the difference between low carbon steels and chromoly or tool steels, nor can one really demonstrate headspace without a cutaway. So, I tried to simply have an interesting and relevant backdrop to speak against.

I suppose I could go in front of the camera, but that ain't really my thing, either. I think my quick firing demo video with the pack rifle is the only one you actually see my face in.

Not a very good channel name... "nunya biness"...?

It's kind of a long story, but "nunya" was the colloquialism we used to use in our group as teenagers and young adults when someone butted into a conversation. I opted for it because so many of the comments made on YT are exactly that kind of rude interruption. NB also happens to be my real initials, as well as those for my handle there.
 
I have a MAC that came with iMovie and it is a great video tool. There are apps you can get for a Windows PC that allow you to do the same thing.

I don't like to narrate a video. I use title boards and stills for a lot of my movies. Not saying you should do like I do, but here is an example of a non-narrated movie that gets the information across, I think:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wk5CMtWquGM
 
Subscribed, and thumbed up'ed.

Don't be afraid to put your face in the scene when you are doing a narration like that, just remember to wear a clean shirt.
 
Mach, I liked it! But as J-Bar points out. It would be good if you could have examples.

I remember someone did a video of loading BP gun with, I think, 50 gr. of HS-6. They did a remote firing to demonstrate failures due to the wrong powders. An eye opener to say the least. Maybe you could have a controlled failure from the use of the wrong material, or improper treatment of material.
 
Well done sir. Informative, educational and just the right amount of technical. I am very impressed with your level of skill. One thing that I am curious about (maybe you already covered it previously) is the BATF ramifications?
 
Maybe you could have a controlled failure from the use of the wrong material, or improper treatment of material.

Well, that would involve building something specifically to destroy it, which isn't my usual motivation. Lol. But I'll entertain the idea!

I do want one of your .22 single shot pistols! Any idea on the price?

I'm not an FFL07/10, so I'm not able to build them for sale. But my sketch is in the build thread in general handgun discussions, and I also just did a video detailing that one a bit more. It's certainly something you could make yourself! Nowhere near as complex as the other 3.



it!
 
One thing that I am curious about (maybe you already covered it previously) is the BATF ramifications?

What specifically are you curious about? It's perfectly legal (federally, and in my state) to build personal firearms, so long as you comply with title I regulations or obtain an approved form 1 before constructing a title II NFA firearm.
 
From about 1:30 to about 10:00 the camera essentially shows the same scene. You talk about a lot of stuff in those 8 1/2 minutes. Your presentation will be more effective if you can show specific examples of the things you are talking about as you talk about them. Scene changes promote interest.
I found your video very interesting. Lots of good feedback here - this comment comes close to what I was thinking for a large part of the presentation. I will be looking for more videos!
 
Mach.
I'm at my daughter's violin class now just read the thread. I will rerun the video it later at home.
Any way your work is outstanding, a real example of ingenuity.

czhen

RIP RC
 
I thought your video was very good. Love your half-scale AR, hilarious. What sort of machining equipment would you suggest for a guy that wants to dabble in 80% lowers and threading?
 
Mach
Hard to add something to a well done.
What I do like is the term that we are the embasadors of the shooting community, inviting to do thing according to regulations.

czhen

Rip RC
 
What sort of machining equipment would you suggest for a guy that wants to dabble in 80% lowers and threading?

Barrel threading? Because if so, you're really looking at two separate machines. I've never seen a combination mill/drill/lathe machine that would be capable of barrel threading.

For 80% lowers and other light machine work, you really can't beat the little Seig X2 and it's variants sold by Harbor Freight, little machine shop and Grizzly. They're pretty capable little machines if you take the time to set them up right and dial them in. I still have mine, use it frequently for drilling and other secondary operations. I have a tilt/swivel vise on it, so if I need to make a compound angle cut that doesn't have to be super precise, it's a lot quicker than fixturing in my big mill. I actually used it to drill the firing pin holes in my O/U pistol with their wonky angles on two axis. This is mine, sporting DROs and a modification to Z axis for more travel:

IMG_1187_zps62024314.jpg

Mills are also fantastic for internal threading. I power tap a lot with spiral flue taps, especially through holes, but even if you're not comfortable doing that, you use the quill with a tap guide centered over the hole, and you will have perfectly true threads every time.

For barrel threading, however, if you're wanting to turn out precision work, there's no better way than single point cutting. But that takes a fairly substantial lathe, and some experience. I wish I could tell you there's a good alternative, but if you're threading for suppressors, it needs to be pretty dang straight. I actually do not have single point threading capability on my lathe, but can make custom die guides and wrenches to perfectly fit a bore or major diameter, and I use a chuck on the carriage to apply perfectly even pressure to the die. Now, mind you, this is after I've indicated both ends of the barrel with a spider and 4 jaw chuck, then turned it true.

IMG_20160416_180859135_zpsldjb1hws.jpg

This is a custom die wrench I made for threading 1/2-28.

IMG_1658_zpsbqimt5tv.jpg

The die is a very tight fit (tap it in), and is perfectly centered to the guiding bore:

IMG_1660_zpspds1jxbn.jpg

And I can turn out some pretty nice threads with it

IMG_20160422_145433495_zpsoewsxtwe.jpg

But it's still a lot of careful work to get them true to the bore.

In summary, the mini mills are cheap enough, small enough, and handy enough to easily justify purchasing them. Vertical mills are the most flexible machine tool, and you'll find yourself using it for all kinds of things you did the hard way before. But unless you plan to thread a lot of barrels, you'd be better off paying to have it done. Even a used lathe you found on the cheap probably wouldn't amortize it's cost threading your personal barrels until you did well North of 20.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top