thanks for the compliments guys. As far as gloss goes, I kind of wanted this one to be shiny. not authentic but I think it looks good. I could have hit it with some steel wool to dull it down but chose not to. For a stock that is exactly 100 years old, I think she cleaned up nice. It should hold up a lot better than that shellac did too so I can pass it down to my kids one day. Also, I cant say Ive heard of the brownells product you speak of.