Ruger LCR 9mm review

Status
Not open for further replies.

minutemen1776

Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2007
Messages
885
Location
Alabama
I have said quite a bit here about acquiring the new Ruger LCR chambered in 9mm. I have looked forward to this offering from Ruger like nothing else I can remember for some time. After I found one online, I bought it, and I received it from my LGS last week. I took it to the indoor range yesterday. Here it is, ready for action:

RugerLCR9mm.gif

I brought 100 rounds of Speer 124-grain target loads, plus a handful of Speer Gold Dot 124-grain +P and Federal HST 147-grain +P defense loads. Having no experience with moon clips, it was a bit awkward getting started, since rounds have to be individually snapped into place. Later, the unloading process was very similar. I decided that, for range use, moon clips are a bit of a pain. If I had enough of them to load up all my rounds before going to the range, that would be great. But with only five 5-round moon clips, loading and unloading was considerably slower versus using rimmed cartridges.

Shooting the 9mm round in such a small revolver was eye-opening. While not as violent as shooting .357 rounds in a small-frame revolver, the 9mm loads were very "snappy." The +P loads gave a little more recoil, but the difference was not great. It only took about 10 rounds to start feeling the sting of the 9mm loads. After one 50-round box and 15 +P loads, the recoil had become downright unpleasant, and I was done. Both the web of my shooting hand and my trigger finger are still very sore today. So, plainly, this isn't much of a fun gun for the range.

Mechanically, I had no malfunctions of any kind. Once placed into the moon clips, cartridges inserted with ease, and empty brass extracted without any signs of stickiness. I did note that much of the brass was very sooty, and I have not experienced this using the same ammo in my semiautos.

Shooting mostly at seven yards, most of my shots hit about 6-8 inches too low. Shots with the 147-grain ammo were slightly better in this regard. By adjusting my sight alignment, I was eventually able to get my shots more on target. To be consistent, though, I had to really focus on my trigger pull. The trigger pull, by the way, was pretty nice. I did not measure it, but it seems to have the same smooth pull that other LCRs are known to have.

Ultimately, I have to admit I am disappointed in the 9mm LCR. After just a few rounds, it was uncomfortable to shoot, and it was hard to keep on target. It's a bit big for pocket carry, and I like my Kahr K9 better for belt or IWB carry. The Kahr is also easier for me to shoot well and, being heavier, has less felt recoil. Not being one to keep guns that I don't like to shoot, I doubt I'll keep the LCR around for very long.
 
Sad that you didn't like it as much as you'd hoped. Perhaps a different set of grips might help with the recoil?

If you do want to sell it I don't think you'll have any trouble finding a buyer.

BTW, I have no personal experience with this moon clip tool, but it looks nice:

http://www.mooncliptool.com/
 
I too just bought an LCR, but in .38 special. The first trip to the range I shot factory ammo. I knew it would have some bite, but it took me by surprise as well. I went home and worked up some loads with 4 different powders. I went back to the range yesterday and came home happy. I learned how to shoot the little gun on target, narrowed it down to 4 different loads to be tested again, and was able to shoot about 100 rounds without getting beat up. After my reloads I shot some of the factory stuff again and the recoil was about the same. I think once you get used to it things will settle in.
 
Thanks for the review! :)

I figured it would have some "bite" to it, since the S&W 940 (all steel J-frame.) is a bit snappy.

As already stated you shouldn't have much trouble selling it. (I might be interested.)

You could try shooting some .380 out of it.
 
The reason 9mm has so much more bite than you expect is because it performs very similar to 357 in a snubby revolver. But as you note the advantage is much reduced blast.

I'm curious. How is this revolver setup? Do the moon clips recess into the frame or do they sit behind it and essentially give a 9mm round a 38spl thick rim?
 
The 115gr Blazzer Brass are some of the more anemic commercial rounds you can purchase.

105gr Guard Dogs are also soft-shooting but expensive for practice, but then again the 115gr Guard Dogs are an option for people who think the 9mm is too snappy. The terminal performance of the 105gr Guard Dog is almost identical to many 380 ACP rounds.
 
I don't think shooting 380 out of it is a good idea, the 380 cartridge isn't going to actually chamber, so you're hoping that the moon clip keeps the cartridge centered, which they'll never do a perfect job of doing.

So basically you'd be bouncing a 380 bullet off your chamber walls, albeit a shallow angle, you can start shaving the bullets, especially on the ledge where the 9mm rim would sit, if you keep shaving the bullets you can get an obstruction, it's just not a good idea.
 
My review of the LCR in 38 sp would be very similar to that offered by the O.P.

Does/has anyone compared the LCR and S&W 38?

I had a Smith that my wife did not like due to the felt recoil. I was hoping that the LCR 9 would be better. That was one of the reasons I wanted one.
 
I plan to get one since I like the idea of my backup pocket revolver shooting the same ammo as my belt 9mm. I had some bad experiences with the S&W 940 and sold it off right quick. The "case sticking" gremlin had a'hold of that little revolver a might fierce! :) This Ruger version might be just the ticket to retire my S&W 638.
 
To the OP:

You bought the wrong gun if you expect to shoot a significant amount and not feel the recoil. It's a lightweight gun meant for easy carry primarily. The SP101 would attenuate the recoil much more in a small revolver.

You might try some lighter loads to attenuate recoil, otherwise I'm guessing there'll be plenty of folks willing to take it off your hands If you're in Ohio, I'd be one of them.

Don't suppose you'd care to trade for an SP101?
 
I have found a buyer for the 9mm LCR as of this morning. And, I won't get dinged too bad for my buyer's remorse. I'm mainly losing shipping and an FFL fee. I can live with that. :)

I'm on the opposite end of the revolver spectrum now, looking at Ruger Blackhawks. It's interesting to me that a revolver that's two or three times bigger than the LCR can cost about the same money.
 
I did not make friends with my LCR on it's first range trip either. By the third outing, I was enjoying it and not feeling the effects of the recoil.

Still, it's one of those guns where a single box of 50 makes for a nice outing.

The secret is in the factory Hogue grips.
 
I run some +P's though my .38 every month or so, just to keep up. I can stand only a handful of those (10 or so) before I'm very, very done with it for the range trip.

With standard pressure factory ammo I'm pretty done with it at around 30-50 rounds, snappy little gun that it is. Nice thing is if I warm up with that, pretty much everything else that trip shoots like a dream. Numbed hands, I guess.

I've been intrigued by the 9mm version of the LCR, but I'm not sure that I'm convinced its an upgrade from the .38, so I'll probably never try one.
 
If you want to shoot 9mm's thru a revolver, just get some 125 grain Golden Sabers magnum rounds. They are virtually identical in weight and velocity to Remington and Speer 124 grain 9mm loadings. And after all these years, the Golden Saber is still hard to beat as an anti-personnel round.
 
just get some 125 grain Golden Sabers magnum rounds.

Are you saying that shooting 125gr .357 magnum Golden Sabers out of a 357 revolver is the same as shooting 124gr 9mm rounds and therefore it obviates the need to get a 9mm revolver?
 
If the recoil is bothersome you can make some pissant loads for play/practice. or have a reloader friend do it for you. You can shoot ammo in a revo that won't even cycle the slide of an autol
 
I've been making the rounds of the LGSs every week trying to find one but I was told Monday they aren't shipping yet. Apparently that's not true. I really want one!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top