The problem, as I see it, is that 5-Star (and Kimber) decided to rotate opposite of HKS. If they had only made them release the same way I would be much happier.
Over the years I have been happy with the way that the Safariland Comp loaders work, but they don't seem interested in reviving this old line of products. Jetloaders would be nice, but alas they are only made for S&W.